What type of floors do new home buyers look for in their kitchens?

Real Estate Agent with Beringer Realty

Hardwood flooring isn't very often seen in kitchens here in Champaign County, Illinois. Tile flooring is a much more common choice for homeowners when remodeling. However, the information provided in the blog below is thorough and useful, regardless of whether you're having a new home built, planning to update your current flooring, or perhaps considering whether or not to reveal those old hardwood floors underneath the carpet or vinyl.

Many thanks to Debbie Gartner "The Flooring Girl" of Westchester, NY for this wonderful information!

Original content by Debbie Gartner

Kitchen flooring for new homeowners - most popular types

types of kitchen floors for new home owners in WestchesterBelieve it or not, hardwood flooring is now the most popular type of new flooring installed in kitchens for Westchester County NY! In fact, I continue to be amazed by how many new homeowners actively rip up the tile in the kitchen and change it over to hardwood flooring.   In Westchester County, most homeowners that are remodeling their kitchen select either hardwood or tile. The same holds true for when they are simply changing the floors (but leaving the cabinets in place). The choice on hardwood vs. tile is an individual taste one, pending on which benefits are most important, but hardwood represents a larger and growing portion of the flooring. 

Why is hardwood flooring so popular for kitchens in Westchester County?


1. Hardwood flooring is easier on your feet.

Hardwood flooring in kitchen westchester countyFor those that spend a lot of time cooking or just congregating in the kitchen, this is a huge benefit over tile which tires your feet and ankles much faster. 

2. Hardwood floors are warmer than tile.

In the winter, Hardwood flooring feels much warmer on your feet than tile, and that is a big benefit for those cold winters we have in Westchester. Also, it helps with those electric bills. 

3. Hardwood in the kitchen will help make your home look larger

By using the same type of flooring in the kitchen and adjoining areas, it will make your home look more cohesive and spacious. Most homes in our area have hardwood flooring already. It's fairly simple to make the hardwood in the kitchen match the color in the other rooms...or to refinish the entire first floor to match your preferred color - if you'd like to make a change. This is also becoming more important as more homeowners are looking for open floor plans.  

4. Usually, hardwood flooring is less expensive than tile flooring

hardwood floors westchester NY kitchen open floor planBy using the same type of flooring in the kitchen and adjoining areas, it will make your home look more cohesive and spacious. Most homes in our area have hardwood flooring already. It's fairly simple to make the hardwood in the kitchen match the color in the other rooms...or to refinish the entire first floor to match your preferred color - if you'd like to make a change. 

5. Hardwood floors are easier to clean and maintain

Most of our customers find it easier to clean hardwood flooring than tile. They feel the dirt always gets stuck in the grout areas and it tends to darken over time. Hardwood also tends to show the dirt a little bit less. For kitchen floors in particular, we recommend adding unfinished wood and refinishing on site so that floors are properly sealed. It's often better when you can add an extra coat of polyurethane for some extra protection.

6. Hardwood flooring never goes out of style

It's true - hardwood is the preferred flooring in Westchester County, and it will never go out of the style. The colors may change, and one of the great things about hardwood is that you can refinish and stain them different colors - based on what you prefer, or what is stylish at the time, or as the home transfers owners. Hardwood will last for generations to come. On the other hand, over time, tile tends to crack (and this can not be easily fixed without replacing the whole floor. But, even if the tile doesn't crack, it will go out of style in 10-20 yrs from now while the hardwood will remain in place much longer. And, even if you have some water damage on the floor, it is much easier to repair hardwood floors and refinish them than to replace tile.  


Tile is the 2nd most popular kitchen flooring in Westchester County.

Tile flooring for kitchenTile seems to be preferred by many of our customers from Italy, Spain, Latino backgrounds and some of our older customers. Here are the benefits of tile flooring for kitchens.

1. Tile is waterproof

For those that have a lot of accidents/spills, this takes out the worry about making a mess on the floors. Some of my customers that have young kids or dogs who may spill their water prefer tile flooring.

2. Tile flooring goes better with some cabinet choices

For those looking at mid toned wood cabinets, they often want to contrast the floor with a lighter tile and sometimes the hardwood floors won't look as good since you can't go as light with the hardwood as you can with a light beige tile.

3. With tile floors, you don't need to worry about scratches

Kitchen tile flooring and backsplash westchesterTile flooring is very resilient and you don't need to worry about scratching the floor, nor do you need to worry about refinishing them in the future.

4. There are endless design possibilities with tile flooring

With tile floors, you can easily mix and match tile sizes and shapes, add borders and inserts. There are so many fun choices and there are even ways to tile in the flooring with the backsplash or granite countertops. On the flipside, though, some tiles are very taste specific, and if you are going to sell your house within the next 5-10 yrs, choosing neutral (rather than taste specific) styles will help you with resale value.

5. For apartments that are on a concrete slab, tile can sometimes be more cost effective

Tile can go directly on top of concrete (as long as it's flat and level). So, with some apartment buildings tile is a more practical option. Solid hardwood requires a plywood subfloor and if you don't have plywood, you would want to install that first, and this can both add to your wallet as well as add height to the room (which sometimes in kitchens creates height issues with cabinets and appliances. Alternatively, you could use an engineered hardwood floor and glue this directly to the concrete, but some of those can not be sand and refinished. 

Other kitchen flooring choices in Westchester

cork flooring for kitchens westchesterBeyond hardwood and tile, for families in Westchester, the other choices depend on personal preferences. For those on mid to higher end of the scale, cork flooring is often a great option.  It's environmentally friendly and it's so much easier on your feet (and it feels soft/soothing on your feet.  Cork tends to be a bit more expensive than hardwood, but less expensive than tile.  But, it is a very taste specific and niche product (so not the ideal choice if you are about to sell your home.


For those on a more limited budget, laminate provides a cost effective choice.  It will cost less than hardwood and it is very scratch resistant.  It can look like hardwood or tile, but more choose the hardwood look (given hardwood's popularity) and given that laminate that looks like hardwood tends to cost less than laminate that looks like tile, and there is often more variety of choices.  It's important to understand that laminate is not waterproof (and many customers find this out after it's too late).  If you're looking for waterproof or water resistant, try vinyl flooring - either sheet vinyl or the higher end luxury vinyl.

Types of kitchen floors in Westchester - New Homeowners vs. existing homeowners

Westchester kitchen hardwood floorsWe work with new homeowners as well as owners who have lived in their homes for many years, so we see it all. Across both types of owners, we are seeing a stronger preference for hardwood flooring in kitchens, and we are seeing it even more often among new homeowner. It's one thing when you are upgrading from vinyl or laminate floors to either hardwood or tile. But, what I am finding more and more often is that homeowners are trading out tile flooring (that is in good condition) for hardwood...that's how strong the preference is for hardwood flooring in the kitchen!

What should you do with your kitchen floor if you are selling your Westchester home?

First, I want to caveat this by saying that every home and flooring situation is different, and it's best to consult your realtor and a stager (as well as a flooring expert).  This will vary based on area of the country as well as your neighborhood.  But, I do see some common themes among homeowners looking to sell - they generally want to spend the least they can for the biggest impact on sales price. Right? So, using that principle, usually, in Westchester County, you will get your strongest return on investment by adding hardwood (rather than tile). After all, that will usually cost less and appeal to more buyers. Of course, if you budget is more limited, laminate flooring that looks like hardwood will generally be the next best option. It costs less, but it doesn't get you as much from a selling perspective. 

When you're ready for new kitchen flooring in your Westchester Home, give the Flooring Girl a call at 914-937-2950.


Map of Westchester flooring

View Westchester Hardwood Flooring in a larger map


Original version:

Kitchen Flooring - Which is better - hardwood flooring or tile flooring? Westchester NY

What type of floors do new home buyers look for in their kitchens - Westchester County?

Hardwood Flooring - Carpet - Tile/Natural Stone - Laminate - Refinish Hardwood - Backsplashes

The Flooring Girl logoDebbie Debbie Gartner - Westchester Hardwood FlooringGartner, Owner

"The Flooring Girl"

Floor Coverings International Westchester NY

You can download our free flooring guide.  Or, visit our flooring selector - 2,000 options.  We install hardwood floors, carpeting and runners, tile floors and backsplashes.

Call us for a free estimate 914-937-2950. 

"We bring the store to your door."

If you enjoyed what you are are reading, feel free to subscribe to blog to my blog.

WC19920-H07, HIC619252

Posted by



Shannon Lewis is a Realtor® and broker at Beringer Realty located in Urbana, Illinois. She and her partner, Debbie Hensleigh, help home buyers and sellers in Urbana, Champaign, Savoy, and many other surrounding communities.

Homeplace Advisors on Facebook  Visit Our Website  Email Shannon!

Search for Homes in Champaign-Urbana IL

To contact Shannon with a question, for real estate assistance, or just to say "hey!":

call 217-552-8059, or email Shannon@HomeplaceAdvisors.com

Comments (4)

Bruce Walter
Keller Williams Realty Lafayette/West Lafayette, Indiana - West Lafayette, IN

Shannon, this is a great post and I am so glad you re-blogged it.  Bookmarked!  We have hardwood floors and it has been a learning experience trying to keep them clean!

Dec 11, 2012 12:33 AM
Shannon Lewis
Beringer Realty - Champaign, IL
Realtor, Broker - Champaign-Urbana, IL

Glad you happened across my re-post, Bruce! I can completely relate to your "learning experience." We have procedures in place to protect the 100-year-old hardwoods in our home :-)

Dec 11, 2012 12:56 AM
Debbie Gartner
The Flooring Girl - White Plains, NY
The Flooring Girl & Blog Stylist -Dynamo Marketers

Good morning, Shannon and thank you so much for reblogging this.  I really appreciate it.  Yes, in some areas of the country, tile is still very popular.  I hope you have a wonderful day today.


Dec 11, 2012 07:54 PM
Shannon Lewis
Beringer Realty - Champaign, IL
Realtor, Broker - Champaign-Urbana, IL

Debbie, I wish hardwoods were more popular in kitchens around here. I LOVE hardwood flooring :-) Thanks so much for the blog!

Dec 11, 2012 08:57 PM