Should I Calculate Rent vs Own or True Cost of Rent vs Owning - How To

By
Mortgage and Lending with iLoan - NMLS ID#4474 NMLS 79048

Every time we read an article online about taking a more analytical approach to deciding whether or not to buy a home, you’ll always get comments about how “personal” or “emotional” the decision is but if you’ve found this page, that’s not why you’re here.  You’re looking for a “left brain” experience and you’re going to get it.

When analyzing a decision on a move, it's important to know the variables, have all the tools and take the whole decision under consideration.  It can be frustrating poking around all over the internet to find these facts, tools and calculators so we’ve done our best to collect them for you here.  Ultimately, you want to calculate the true cost of homeownership but to get there, you must complete a fact finding mission via the following 5 steps:

  1. Find Your Market Rent using the widget below
  2. Find Your Neighborhood Appreciation Rate
  3. Calculate Your Market Mortgage Rate and Closing Costs
  4. Calculate Your Mortgage Insurance
  5. Calculate the True Cost of Renting vs. Owning

If you’ve gotten this far; congratulations, you’re a real do-it-yourselfer.  And now that we know that, allow us to express our concern for your wellbeing.  If you keep it up at this pace, you're likely to consider trying to negotiate your own lease or mistakenly try to find you own home on some piece of junk website and we'd hate to see that.  No, . . . if you’ve gotten this far it’s time to get thee to an excellent Realtor!

Posted by

Charles Dailey - Branch Manager, Loan Officer, Certified Military Housing Specialist - iLoan - NMLS ID# 79048 -  612.234.7283 - charles@charlesdailey.com


Search Real Estate

The Home Buyers Scouting Report® is provided directly to the buyer by HBM II, a licensed national real estate brokerage service company, not to or through a lender. The FREE home finding service is provided directly to prospective homebuyers by HBM II and its real estate brokers, as part of their ordinary real estate brokerage services. HBM II, Inc. works cooperatively with other real estate agents across the United States in attempting to find ready, willing and able buyers for homes listed for sale. The role of the Preferred Loan Officer is to assist in determining a comfortable home price range for Home Buyers Marketing II, Inc. (HBM II) to use when it is searching for property listings within the buyer's search criteria.

Comments (20)

Gary Frimann, CRS, GRI
Eagle Ridge Realty / Signature Homes & Estates - Gilroy, CA
REALTOR and Broker

Personally, I think throughout history, it is better to buy than rent.  If you rent, the landlord gets the appreciation, building of equity with every one of your rent payments, and depreciation.  At the end of thirty years of renting, one only has a box full of rental receipts, with an almost guarantee that the most recent rental receipt being significantly more costly than the first one.

Mar 31, 2013 07:02 AM
Lenn Harley
Lenn Harley, Homefinders.com, MD & VA Homes and Real Estate - Leesburg, VA
Real Estate Broker - Virginia & Maryland

A little overlooked motivator in the rent vs. own debate is the public school rankings in residential communities vs. rental commuities. 

Hard to quantify but it's a fact.

Apr 01, 2013 12:57 AM
Matthew O'Hare
Osterville, MA

Ahhh, a question that will forever remain. It is always important to examine your personal needs as well.

Apr 01, 2013 01:05 AM
Charles Dailey
iLoan - NMLS ID#4474 - Saint Paul, MN

That's a great point Lenn.  I have to figure out how to factor that into this without blowing my "left brain" thing.  Maybe find stats tied to resale value in good school districts vs. bad ones.

Apr 01, 2013 07:45 AM
Silvia Dukes PA, Broker Associate, CRS, CIPS, SRES
Tropic Shores Realty - Ich spreche Deutsch! - Spring Hill, FL
Florida Waterfront and Country Club Living

Charles, I like that you are giving people the information and tools they desire but still make your services available to them.  Going out alone to rent or buy contains many pitfalls, better to go with a professional like you.

Apr 01, 2013 09:37 AM
Bob Crane
Woodland Management Service / Woodland Real Estate, Keller Williams Fox Cities - Stevens Point, WI
Forestland Experts! 715-204-9671

Entertaining Charles, but not very functional, some of these calculations in the rent or own worksheet are not realistic.

 

Apr 01, 2013 09:06 PM
Kimo Jarrett
WikiWiki Realty - Huntington Beach, CA
Pro Lifestyle Solutions

It depends on many factors as to what is best for a consumer, their current, short term and long term future goals and objectives and the variable options that might lead to their best solutions.

Apr 01, 2013 11:35 PM
Thomas McCombs
Century 21 HomeStar - Akron, OH

Realtors (including me) have a bias towards buying and owning.

The buy/rent decision has so many variables that it is practically impossible to make a decision based on "facts" alone.

Having participated as a data source myself in those rent studies that appraisers and lenders conduct, I know how much guesswork goes into them.

Apr 01, 2013 11:39 PM
Roger Newton
Roger Newton Real Estate - North Plains, OR

It costs more to own.  You have to figure in the cost of maintenance and repairs when you own.  There is NO return when you rent, and there is plenty of return on owning.

If you have a 30 year mortgage and the market stays flat for 30 years, your home will be paid off in 30 years.  You will have the equity of how much the home is worth when it is paid off, regardless of market conditions.

Apr 01, 2013 11:52 PM
Ron Aguilar
Continental Mortgage - Saint George, UT
Mortgage & Real Estate Advisor since 1995

Hey at least all the RVB calcs out there are much better than in the past

Apr 01, 2013 11:58 PM
Charles Dailey
iLoan - NMLS ID#4474 - Saint Paul, MN

Rob Chrane - which calculations specificially in the worksheet are not very realistic?  

Apr 02, 2013 01:38 AM
Ric Mills
Keller Williams Southern Az - Tucson, AZ
Integrity, Honesty, and Vast Real Estate Knowledge

Great analysis.  It rarely pays to rent unless you will live there for a short time.   If you plan to stay 3+ years it is really probably a no brainer.

Apr 02, 2013 01:46 AM
Hella Mitschke Rothwell
(831) 626-4000 - Honolulu, HI
Hawaii & California Real Estate Broker
There are those things we cant calculate We need to keep in mind that many renters went for home ownership when loans where easy to get. Well, many lost their homes, many through no fault of their own Others just don't have the temperament for it, all the extra responsibilities that a landlord does for them.
Apr 02, 2013 04:48 AM
Wallace S. Gibson, CPM
Gibson Management Group, Ltd. - Charlottesville, VA
LandlordWhisperer

Rent v mortgage payment is a sqewed ratio - the mortgage payment needs to ADD the cost of maintenance - like an HVAC compressor every 7 to 10 years....at least $300 per month for MAINTENANCE should be added to the mortgage payment v RENT where these costs are paid for by the LANDLORD

Apr 02, 2013 09:08 PM
Charles Dailey
iLoan - NMLS ID#4474 - Saint Paul, MN

Good Point Wallace and this calculatory does take that into consideration (see step 5 and see the annual maintenance factor).  

Apr 03, 2013 02:17 AM
Tyler Soulliere
Windsor Realtor - Windsor, ON

This is a great blog and great idea of putting in a widget to calculate local rents. To bad doesn't work for canada postal codes!

Apr 03, 2013 05:43 AM
Bob Crane
Woodland Management Service / Woodland Real Estate, Keller Williams Fox Cities - Stevens Point, WI
Forestland Experts! 715-204-9671

the taxes and maintenance allowed in the calculations are higher here that the worksheet allows, this skews the data to make owning seem more appealing than it really is, of course maybe this is the objective.

Apr 03, 2013 06:57 AM
Charles Dailey
iLoan - NMLS ID#4474 - Saint Paul, MN

Bob that's great feedback.  If you have a factor that would be better, that would be super helpful because I'd like to see if I can get the calculator adjusted.

Apr 03, 2013 12:09 PM
Maurince Pierre
Premium Properties Real Estate Services - Orlando, FL
Because Experience Matters!!

Nice post and helpful tools. 

Great job Charles.

Apr 03, 2013 01:27 PM
Bob Miller
Keller Williams Cornerstone Realty - Ocala, FL
The Ocala Dream Team

Hi Charles, thanks for sharing that cool widget.  Makes us want to find an app like that for our iPad.

Apr 03, 2013 08:19 PM

What's the reason you're reporting this blog entry?

Are you sure you want to report this blog entry as spam?