Special offer

Agents that don't work for their sellers....

By
Real Estate Agent with Advantage Realty #1

A seller contacted me today through my website. He basically asked if I had a buyer for his home. The email included a MLS number, so I went and looked it up.

It was listed by an agent a few hundred miles away and in the comment section it was noted to call the seller directly for all questions, showings and offers.

The compensation was 5% for Buyer Agents (that's a Single Agent), 0% for Transaction Brokers, 0% for Non Rep's. I don't know of anyone in my MLS that is a Single Agent, we're all operating as Transaction Brokers. So, right off the bat, this seller eliminates the vast majority of agents he is obviously trying to get to sell his home.
Florida, by default is a "Transaction State".

I emailed him back informing him of the compensation situation and I also asked why he is contacting agents instead of letting his agent do the work for him. He replied that his agent doesnt' work for him and that he is aware of the compensation situation and authorized it. I'm having tons of question marks going up at that point. Obviously, he paid his "agent" a certain amount to get in the MLS and he's now doing the agent's job.

From the email conversations I've had with this buyer it appears that he believes 5% commission is going to get his house sold. I had to disagree. The buyer will not care what the compensation is, the buyer will not care how much the agent makes, the buyer will not care about anything but getting a good deal. So the question should be: In order to sell my house, what can I do to be competitive with other homes for sale? Am I priced right? For what kind of buyer is my house suitable? Where do buyers like that live? How can I advertise to them? If all these questions have been answered and addressed accordingly, buyers will ask their agents to see this home. Buyers will not ask to see this home because the agent gets 5%.

My question to you is: will you push this listing onto your buyers because of the 5% and are you willing to walk your buyer through a transaction where you are not dealing with another professional on the other end but a seller instead?

Anonymous
Dawn Aquino

Wow, I am a Broker in Springfield OR. I know what you mean, buyers do not care what the Broker make commission wise. It really is about the house and what deal they are going to  get, as well as neighborhood appreciation, Are they making a good investment.   I personally would rather work with another professional, rather than a seller directly. I have never heard of anything like this happening around here.  Great post!

Dawn Aquino

Oregon Real Estate Properties

 

Feb 07, 2008 11:47 AM
#1
Sharon Roark
United Real Estate Lexington - Lexington, KY
Realtor Extraordinaire in Lexington KY
Very thought provoking. To be honest, I'd probably make sure my buyers had every opportunity to see this house, but I don't believe in pushing certain properties on clients so past that, I'd let them see if the home appealed to them. It's really a sad comment on that "seller's agent" though.
Feb 07, 2008 11:50 AM
Barbara Dougher
Coldwell Banker United East Texas Division - Tyler, TX
Realtor - 2008 Rookie of the Year

I think this is a major integrity issue.  I would show it because the client requested it.  I would never push this on a client.  Wow!

 

Feb 07, 2008 12:02 PM
Carol Spengel
Prudential Rubloff - Wheaton, IL
Wheaton IL
If the home fit my client's criteria, I would show them the home.  I would really hope that they don't like it because it is just a headache waiting to happen.  If they go cheap on the Realtor/marketing, I can only imagine the inspection negotiation and the cheap lawyer they find.
Feb 07, 2008 01:12 PM
TheMillsTeam YourSebringRealtors
Advantage Realty #1 - Sebring, FL
863-212-5441

Thank you all for your comments.

Sharon, our MLS just joined a bigger MLS that is eventually going to be statewide, I guess. The seller's agent is located somewhere along the coast while the property is hundreds of miles away in Central FL. He is, without a doubt, one of these discount agents that offer MLS access and a sign in the yard for x amount and that's all he'll ever do. I have looked at the "listing history" of this particular listing. It was listed with a regular broker, then withdrawn after only a few days and went with the discount broker the day it was withdrawn. I wouldn't be surprised if I found more withdrawn listings that re-listed immediately with the discount agent and I'm sure it would just be a big co-incidence and the discount agent did not solicit listings of other agents. Btw, I have some beachfront property for sale in Arizona. Anyone interested?

I will keep that seller supplied with market updates, done by a real agent. 5% or not, he is not going to sell this home waving his money infront of agents. I'll be here when he gets tired of not selling his home. 

"The reason I'm paying the selling agent 5% is because that is quite a bit more than you will get if you split commission with another agent and agency and I want to get someone to come alive and get this place sold.  In case you haven't noticed, there are a LOT of places for sale and getting more every day and I don't intend to just get in line and wait like everyone else."

I would be willing to bet that the "coming alive" and "not getting in line" part was the discount agent's sale pitch and the seller took the bait.

Feb 07, 2008 08:50 PM