Admin

Crane Collapse in NYC

By
Home Inspector with DRH Home Inspection Akron, Ohio Summit County Home Inspector

I would like to ask everyone to keep the victims of the recent NYC crane collapse in your prayers.  It appears that most where construction workers and a few residents/visiters that where in the adjacent buildings that where crushed.  This is a Huge tragedy, one that will be scrutinized, criticized, analyzed, investigated, inspected and throughly studied by the engineering and construction community.  The NYC Building Dept. is a very powerful force in NYC, and this will no doubt change some things in the near future.

Having been in the commercial construction business for 25 years, structural steel erection specifically, this touches my heart deeper than other things.  I worked in NYC last year for several months and it just so happened that I visited another project very close to this specific site.

This is a very rare and unique accident, one that has never been seen before that I am aware of.  Cranes have tipped over and/or collapsed many times before, but not quite like this case.

I also worked on a project called One Bryant Park in Midtown that had a tower crane 1150' tall.  I happened to have the pleasure to be on the open, unfinished 55th floor as well as the roof structure that has a 150' spire on top of it (very exciting for me anyways), doing quality control inspections of the structural steel.  What a fabulous view of NYC.  Manhattan and the other Borroughs are experiencing a construction BOOOOM currently.  There are many tower cranes up in NYC right now.  The WTC site is booming and has many cranes of all types on it currently, with several more tower cranes to go up yet.

With the continued high rise construction in NYC, I pray that no more crane collapses occur, ever again.  God be with the families.

Comments(5)

Show All Comments Sort:
Vincent McKamy
Samson Properties - Fredericksburg, VA
Realtor Fredericksburg Virginia
This is a very good posting - I know I have never heard of such a thing happening before in my life time and a pray should go out to all the people that where lost.  Thanks for the good reminder.
Mar 17, 2008 02:09 PM
Linda Lipscomb
Linda Lipscomb RE/MAX Lexington Henderson County TN - Lexington, TN
731-695-1118, Lexington TN Homes

Unbelievable.  Don't you hear more and more of unusual happenings in the world everywhere.  Scary, isn't it???  Thanks for reminding us all of the loss in NYC. 

 

Mar 17, 2008 02:21 PM
Kevin Corsa
H.I.S. Home Inspections (Summit, Stark Counties) - Canton, OH
H.I.S. Home Inspections, Stark & Summit County, OH Home Inspector
Well, the bridge collapse was worse I suppose. But You are right , you never hardly hear of anything like this. My prayers also go out to them.
Mar 20, 2008 07:08 AM
Gene Allen
Fathom Realty - Cary, NC
Realty Consultant for Cary Real Estate
It will probably come out that someone didn't do their job properly.  It may not have caused the accident but contributed to it.  More prayers.
Mar 21, 2008 11:58 AM
David Holden
DRH Home Inspection Akron, Ohio Summit County Home Inspector - Akron, OH
DRH Home Inspection Akron, Ohio Summit

Thanks to all for the comments.

The most recent info that has come out is not good.  First of all, it is my opinion that most of the cause is human error.  The Riggers that where "jumping" the crane, that is pushing it up higher, may have used insufficient capacity slings to support a 6 ton pieces (12,000#), and it broke away and slid down the tower section and took out the lower bracing members.  Second, I read today that a NYC Building Inspector has been arrested for "false documents", he reported that he inspected the crane, but actually never did.

Many changes is store for the Cranes and Derricks Div. in the NYC Building Dept. I would imagine.

Mar 21, 2008 12:50 PM