Internet giants eyeing cheerleaders defamation lawsuit

By
Commercial Real Estate Agent with 602 CRE BR649708000

On Thursday an appeals court heard arguments over whether a gossip website known as The Dirty, and based right here in Scottsdale, AZ, should be immune from a defamation lawsuit brought on by former Cincinnati Bengals cheerleader, Sarah Jones.  Remember her, the one that had sex with one of her students, to whom she's now engaged, but who was married at the time?Sarah Jones defamation lawsuit

She sued the owner of The Dirty, Nik Richie, in December 2012 over posts about her and her ex-husband's sexual history.  In July, a federal Judge ruled that Richie (owner of The Dirty) should not be granted immunity for posts that were substantially false and that Richie had acted with malice or reckless disregard by publishing them.  The jury in that case awarded Jones $338,000.

The Dirty Nik Richie defamation lawsuitIn November, some of the Internets heaviest hitters said that if Judge Bertelsman's decision is upheld the case will "significantly chill online speech."  Google, Facebook, Yahoo, Microsoft, Twitter, Amazon, Gawker and numerous other large internet company's had attorney's file briefs and reiterated the magnitude of the case.  Their arguments centered on an FCC 1996 act known as the Federal Communications Decency Act, that gave websites immunity from liability for content posted by users.

The internet world is awaiting the ruling and think about the doors that'll be opened for lawsuits against "anonymous" posters to comments in threads.  Think about being exposed as a sock puppet commenting or writing completely false and malicious comments.  Can you say here come the lawsuits I know I've already paid my retainer to my attorney in anticipation of the ruling.  Don't let this happen to you.

Alex Popovic is founder of Semper Find My Home an OIF/OEF veteran and Marine Corps Force Reconnaissance Scout/Sniper.  

Posted by

This Active Rain post is by Alex Popovic, for all your real estate needs please call 602-290-4266.

Please click on the links below and follow me.

Add Me on Google+, Follow Me on Twitter, Connect with me on LinkedIn and view me on Facebook, Just click Give a review a simple Thank you message means alot

 

facebook   google plus   twitter   youtube   linkedin   

Alex Popovic Real Estate Agent Phoenix, AZ (602) 290-4266

Copyright ©, All rights reserved 2013

Comments (4)

Liz and Bill Spear
Transaction Alliance 513.520.5305 www.LizTour.com - Mason, OH
Transaction Alliance Cincinnati & Dayton suburbs

Alex, This issue has caught a lot of press because it's local to our area.  And while she may have had the issue with the student, that's well after the whole lawsuit with The Dirty, and really not relevant.  The whole thing about The Dirty is it's not some "innocent" website practicing free speech.  It's malicious and meant to be so.  Quite a ways from the typical anonymous comment on Yahoo, MSN or some other site.

May 01, 2014 11:25 AM
Alex Popovic
602 CRE - Phoenix, AZ
Alex Popovic Developer, Real Estate Broker

Liz and Bill,

This has caught alot of attention, this has nothing to do with what happened between her and the student.  What it is about is commenting on websites, posts and threads and opens the door to lawsuits against blog or website owners for malicious and defamatory "anonymous" comments etc.  It's a huge deal and why all the major internet players have invested millions of dollars and their attorneys fighting.  I've been privvy via a local attorney and friend who is closely assciated with the case.  This is absolutely about typical and anonymous commenting.  The implications are huge.  We'll see

May 01, 2014 11:59 AM
Liz and Bill Spear
Transaction Alliance 513.520.5305 www.LizTour.com - Mason, OH
Transaction Alliance Cincinnati & Dayton suburbs

And yet you felt the need to include that part of her history in the post, correct?  My opinion is judges will have enough common sense to see a significant difference in anonymous comments on a "normal" website vs. a site like The Dirty that was established to be little more than condoned slander.

May 01, 2014 01:08 PM
Alex Popovic
602 CRE - Phoenix, AZ
Alex Popovic Developer, Real Estate Broker

Liz and Bill,

Only to give perspective and background so people can place the parties involved.  Perhaps The Dirty is condoned slander, but what's at stake is huge and you can see how attorneys (if the ruling is in favor of her) will pounce to set precedence and the lawsuits will start flying.  I think all parties are waiting by baited breath

May 01, 2014 01:12 PM