Home Buying Don't Get Hung Up On Dollars Per Square Foot

By
Real Estate Agent with Assoc. Broker/Broker ABR, CRS, SFR, e-Pro, @Homes Realty Group, @HomesBirmingham & Providence Property Mgmnt, LLC Huntsville AL

Home Buying Don't Get Hung Up On Dollars Per Square Foot

 Many times as a Realtor when I work with clients buying a home they will often compare dollars per square foot as aHome Buying Don't Get Hung Up On Dollars Per Square Foot measure of a homes value from one neighborhood to another and use that to guide them when making an offer.  While it makes sense to them and on the surface it makes sense to a lot of people, you really need to look at what is behind the numbers, when you can rely on the numbers and when you should not.

Comparing homes using dollars per square foot works well when comparing similar sized homes and lots in the same or similar community with similar amenities and levels of finish...it's even a good idea to include the same builder...you need to compare apples to apples.   If for example homes in the modest Potters Mill neighborhood of Madison Alabama sell for an average $96/square foot, that would make the average sale price around $155,900 for homes there with average trim packages and standard builders quality construction.  However, and this is an extreme example to make a point, if you compare the Potters Mill neighborhood to the more upscale Clifts Cove community in Madison Alabama where the average dollar per square foot is more in the range of $122/square foot and an average sale price of $577,380 the difference is obvious.  Different communities and builders command different $/square foot, granite and hardwoods cost more that laminate, crown molding and architectural shingles more than drywall corners & 3-tab shingles, etc.  The difference can be even more dramatic when comparing different upscale communities.  Do you think you can compare upscale Clifts Cove with the upscale Ledges in Huntsville Alabama community where the average price per square foot is $211 and an average sale price of $1,028,000?  Use the $/square foot averages within the community that produced those averages.

In my opinion your best guide about the value of a home or what to pay is to have your Realtor research the neighborhood and surrounding similar neighborhoods for recent comparable sales, preferably within the last 3 months.  Unless the home you are considering making an offer on is a foreclosure property then do not consider another foreclosure as a comparable.  To come up with a reasonable estimate of value, your Realtor also needs to research the age of homes, level of finish, updates and pay attention to seller concessions as they also can reflect on a final sales price.  Bottom line...you cannot apply dollars per square foot across the board to determine a homes value or what you should offer.  You can use dollars per square foot in specific communities with comparable homes having similar amenities and levels of finish.  

Content originally published at....http://nicktpappas.com/?p=2239 

Nick T Pappas

Visit Your Huntsville Real Estate Resource

Image courtesy ddpavumba/freedigitalphotos.net

Serving: Anslee FarmsBell Tower, Bishop Farms, Bradford Farms, BridgefieldCanebrakeChase Shadow, Cherokee Ridge, Clifts Cove, Edgewater, Emerald Forest Condo, Foxfield, Greystone Estates, Hampton Cove, Harvest, Highland Lakes, Jones Valley Estates, Kelly Plantation, Knox Creek, Lake ForestLedges of Huntsville Mountain, Mandolin, Maxwell Place, MidTowne on the Park, Newby Plantation, Olde Cobblestone, Overland Trace, Pebble Brook, Rainbow Landing, Rock Creek, Shadow Brook, Spencer Green, Stavemill Estates, The Bridges on the River, The Villas at Madison, Towne Lakes, Villas at Jones Valley, Walden Preserve, West Highlands, Whitehall, Village of Providence and more.

Posted by


Comments (19)

Praful Thakkar
LAER Realty Partners - Andover, MA
Andover, MA: Andover Luxury Homes For Sale

Nick, people do that. In fact, even when the interest rates are so low, buyers look at price and not the affordability!

Jun 29, 2014 09:08 AM
Joan Whitebook
BHG The Masiello Group - Nashua, NH
Consumer Focused Real Estate Services

It is very confusing for the consumers.  I think you did a great job of outlining why relying on price per square foot alone can be very mistleading.

Jun 29, 2014 11:37 AM
George Souto
George Souto NMLS #65149 FHA, CHFA, VA Mortgages - Middletown, CT
Your Connecticut Mortgage Expert

Nick I agree with Joan, you did an excellent job of show why comparing square footage is not reliable unless you are comparing similar homes in a similar location, and even then it can be tricky.

Jun 29, 2014 11:51 AM
Lynn B. Friedman CRS Atlanta GA 404-939-2727
Atlanta Homes ODAT Realty - Buckhead - Midtown - Westside ... Love our City - Love our Clients! - Atlanta, GA
Concierge Service for Our Atlanta Sellers & Buyers

Dear Nick,

Nice complete explanation. The issue for me is matching up what one source says with what another source says. Atlanta has a history of lawsuits over square footage. In our FMLS, the source is cited to protect the real estate agent.

Have a happy day -
Lynn

Jun 29, 2014 11:57 AM
Kathy Lakowitz
New Rochelle, NY

In New York City's suburbs it's 10x worse which is why Millionaire Listing New York TV show is a fantasy.  I just heard new licensed agents at a training meeting mention about pricing per square foot and our office manager/broker told them we don't do that here.  They were stunned and wondering why not.  Here's the reason:  

1.  school districts vary widely in the suburbs.

2.  25% of homes have recent upgrades, 50% of homes have no recent upgrades but are move in ready (no major repairs), 25% of homes need repairs.

3.  Housing stock varies widely.  Ex: we have single family, multi family, farms, condos, co-ops.

4.  Neighborhoods vary widely due to incomes.  We have everybody from bilionaires to welfare.  Yes, you can buy a waterfront mansion for $25 million and live a few miles from a low income housing project.

Jun 29, 2014 08:06 PM
Joe Petrowsky
Mortgage Consultant, Right Trac Financial Group, Inc. NMLS # 2709 - Manchester, CT
Your Mortgage Consultant for Life

Good morning Nick. The dollars per square foot may make sense to an appraiser, but will do more to confuse a prospective home buyer.

Make it a great week!

Jun 29, 2014 08:58 PM
Nick T Pappas
Assoc. Broker/Broker ABR, CRS, SFR, e-Pro, @Homes Realty Group, @HomesBirmingham & Providence Property Mgmnt, LLC Hun... - Huntsville, AL
Madison & Huntsville Alabama Real Estate Resource

Praful-agreed!  It's just not an accurate way to compare pricing across the board.

Joan-thanks.  Not always easy to get this point across to buyers.

George-there are a lot of hidden factors in pricing per square foot.

Lynn-Birmingham also had numerous lawsuits for the same reason and didn't until recently allow square feet to be listed in the MLS.

Kathy-those are all great points and thanks for adding them to the conversation.

Joe-they do make sense to an appraiser particularly when using the cost approach to appraisal.

Jun 29, 2014 10:54 PM
Richie Alan Naggar
people first...then business Ran Right Realty - Riverside, CA
agent & author

Nick...good posting. Sq foot is just one of the tools that pro agents yield...Assembling data is one thing...knowing what it means is another

Jun 29, 2014 11:11 PM
Debbie Nieman
Keller Williams Sonoran Living - Ahwatukee, AZ
Let Me Dive into Your Real Estate Needs

Good article- I believe price per sq ft is a tool that belongs in the tool box and other factors, location, upgrades, number if needs vs wants on their list are all factors along with the current market they are purchasing in.

 

If you're looking for a realtor to add to your tool box for the Phoenix area, here I am.

 

Debbie

Jun 29, 2014 11:52 PM
Kate McQueen
Realty Associates Texas - Cypress, TX
Tailored service for your real estate needs!

I had a buyer that was doing that recently, and didn't actually say it out loud until we had looked at quite a few  homes.  I explained that it's usually not a good idea to follow price per sq ft as an indicator of value.  Two story homes are less expensive to build, so don't try comparing this with a one story, etc.  

Jun 30, 2014 01:57 AM
Kate McQueen
Realty Associates Texas - Cypress, TX
Tailored service for your real estate needs!

Wil re-blog this, it's a common problem.

Jun 30, 2014 01:58 AM
Nick T Pappas
Assoc. Broker/Broker ABR, CRS, SFR, e-Pro, @Homes Realty Group, @HomesBirmingham & Providence Property Mgmnt, LLC Hun... - Huntsville, AL
Madison & Huntsville Alabama Real Estate Resource

Richie-great point...it's not as cut and dry as using that one measure of a homes value.

Debbie-too many unknowns packed into $/sf!

Kate-another great point...a two story home on the same footprint as a rancher will typically show a smaller $/sf.  And thanks.

Jun 30, 2014 02:16 AM
Noah Seidenberg
Coldwell Banker - Evanston, IL
Chicagoland and Suburbs (800) 858-7917

I get the question sometimes Nick, It's like comparing apples to oranges. Not always an accurate way to figure out true value.

Jun 30, 2014 10:00 AM
Norma Toering Broker for Palos Verdes and Beach Cities
Charlemagne International Properties - Rancho Palos Verdes, CA
Palos Verdes Luxury Homes in L.A.

Price per square ft. simply does not work in my area.  A view can skew it and location play into it as well as quality and condition--too many factors to quote a blanket cost per sq. ft. in the one-of-a kind custom homes found in Palos Verdes and along the South Bay coast.

Jun 30, 2014 11:57 AM
Maria Gilda Racelis
Home Buyers Realty, LLC-Manchester, Bolton. Vernon,Ellington - Manchester, CT
Home Ownership is w/in Reach. We Make it Happen!

Good Morning Nick. What do they say about you can't compare apples from oranges? Unless the homes are clones, then a price-per-square foot barometer in gauging the value would be right on the money.

I could not agree more to all the valid points.

Jun 30, 2014 09:41 PM
Brian Olsen
Portland, Lake Oswego, West Linn & Dunthorpe Neighborhoods, Waterfront, Luxury & Floating Homes - Lake Oswego, OR
Cooper Jacobs Real Estate Group | Keller Williams

Great BLOG Nick. I appreciate your point on price per square foot and encourage buyers and sellers to use this baseline information as a guide and consider all the other facts when making final decisions. There can be more to property then just an equation. 

Jun 30, 2014 10:43 PM
Nick T Pappas
Assoc. Broker/Broker ABR, CRS, SFR, e-Pro, @Homes Realty Group, @HomesBirmingham & Providence Property Mgmnt, LLC Hun... - Huntsville, AL
Madison & Huntsville Alabama Real Estate Resource

Noah-it would be like buyers or sellers for that matter comparing Kenilworth, Illinois to Rogers Park, Illinois $/sf...both nice areas, but totally different $/sf.

Norma-it work spotting a trend in average pricing over time or great for appraisers using the cost approach.

Maria-absolutely!  When comparing properties they have to use comparable measures.

Brian-bottom line is that we have several tools to help us value property...right tool for the right job!

Jun 30, 2014 11:05 PM
Ted Glover
Alderman Classic Realty, LLC - Moultrie, GA
ABR in Moultrie, Georgia 229-854-5422

There are some great points made and comments throughout the article. If it is used as a guide to determine a homes value then use it that way. But get all of the facts about the home as you can. Each component to the value of a home plays a big part to the estimated value we perceive to be correct. It you try to break it down in the features of the property with all you start to see the structure of the cost. Similar to that of an appraiser and there determination of value. And bottom line is that it is different in most states whether they use it primarily or now. Good selling out there. Have a great 4th of July to all.

Jun 30, 2014 11:55 PM
Ana Hitzel
AccentPositives Home Staging - Corona, CA
Professional Home Stager Inland Empire

This is all good info and great advice Nick. Always dig below the surface:)

Jul 11, 2014 02:12 PM

What's the reason you're reporting this blog entry?

Are you sure you want to report this blog entry as spam?