House of the Future? Builders Show Off Ideas at Trade Show

Home Inspector with Florida Healthy Home Inspections
House of the Future? Builders
Show Off Ideas at Trade Show

By June Fletcher

What sort of lessons can a so-called "concept" house teach us?

At the International Builders Show, the country's largest trade event for the housing industry, it's hard to tell -- at least when it comes to the two major concept houses debuting at the Orlando, Fla., event.

Related Links

Sneak Peek: New Offerings For Your Kitchen and Bath

Co-sponsored by Builder magazine and the National Council of the Housing Industry/Supplier 100, a building products manufacturing group, the two houses sit side-by-side in downtown Orlando and showcase what's trendy in both new and remodeled homes. The sponsors and the local builders who produced them say that the houses are meant to be showcases of new products and building techniques. Visiting builders are encouraged to try building these homes in their own markets.

Both of these houses are so fantastical, and their stories so idiosyncratic, that it's hard to know what lessons can be taken away. In fact, after touring them, I was left with more questions than answers.

Take, for instance, their price tags. The Renewed American Home -- a remodel of a 1909 bungalow -- is currently on the market for $2.9 million, while the New American Home is for sale at $3.15

The remodel of the 1909 bungalow -- on the market for $2.9 million.
million. Both houses were constructed with hundreds of thousands of dollars of donated materials, fixtures and appliances, so their prices don't reflect their true market value. How is a builder supposed to figure out how to reproduce a look if he doesn't know what it costs?

Then there's the question of questionable design. The New American Home, a blend of Craftsman and urban-chic styling, is glitzy, with metallic glass tiles, walls that slide on tracks, and steel-cable stair railings. But the floor plan is puzzling: The living room and dining room are on the third floor, the master suite is on the second, and the two secondary bedrooms, office, home theater, wet bar and laundry are on the first (thank goodness there's an elevator). Why is this inverted plan better than a more traditional one? Would anyone want to drag groceries up three floors to the kitchen or have an office next to a theater? And who really wants to take a shower in a glass-walled room overlooking an open balcony, directly facing the windows of the building across the street?

And finally, there's the question of originality -- or lack thereof. The 1909 bungalow was moved to a lot two doors down from its original spot to make room for the New American Home. The bungalow's space was expanded from 2,460 to 5,439 square feet, and its interior was gutted to make room for a wider staircase, wheelchair-accessible bath, new staircase and other features. Older materials were replaced with new: engineered wood for the floors, solid surfacing for the countertops, laminate for the cabinetry. Can such a thoroughly revised house really be called "renewed?" And if it was in such bad shape to begin with, and not worth preserving for its historical or architectural significance, why not just tear it down and start afresh?

Questions, questions: And I always thought the point of show houses was to provide answers.

Comments (6)

Laurie Manny
Long Beach CA Real Estate - Long Beach, CA

I am cracking up at those price tags.  I think we need to send Nick the appraiser in there right away.


Feb 13, 2007 04:37 AM
Roberta Lee
Century 21 Olde Tyme - Norco, CA
Norco Corona Riversid Homes For Sale


I have always taught my children that " just because you CAN doesn't mean you SHOULD."  It seems that may be the case with the house you just discribed.  Would I want a houst with a design where my kitchen was on the second floor?  It depends.  I had one once, but...even though being two story, the first flor (second) was at street level.  By the looks of the picture that's not the case with the one you were talking about.  Also why take all of the historic value out of a house.  Either "restore" or tear down.  I have to agree I think I would walk away with more questions than answers.

Very good post, thanks.

Feb 13, 2007 04:39 AM
Eileen Landau

I read a review of some of the latest and newest ideas to come out of the show.

And, for the life of me, I can't imagine why I'd want a frig with a built-in TV...just seems redundant.

Would make more sense to build affordable homes with renewal products. How 'bout more bamboo?

Feb 13, 2007 05:06 AM
Dena Stevens
Rocky Mountain Realty - Canon City, CO
Putting The Real Into Realtor Since 2004
Ok, I'm all for recycling but really........common sense can go a long way.
Feb 13, 2007 05:20 AM
Christy Powers
Keller Williams Coastal Area Partners - Pooler, GA
Pooler, Savannah Real Estate Agent
I read this article. I can't believe the prices. The layout of the new one was a little crazy. I agree with not wanting to travel up even by elevator 3 flights to get to the kitchen....
Feb 13, 2007 01:09 PM
Sharon Simms
Coastal Properties Group International - Christie's International - Saint Petersburg, FL
It would be nice to see show homes and idea homes that are under $1,000,000.  Those people who build homes over $1,000,000 have lots of ideas and often travel a lot to see things.
Feb 13, 2007 11:04 PM