Another 9th Circuit WACKO Decision

Education & Training with RealtyU

From Inman News comes the following: LLC, a company that operates a Web site that matches people with rooms to rent with tenants, may have violated fair housing laws by requiring users to disclose their sex, sexual orientation and whether they had children who would live them, an appeals court has ruled.

In a ruling that sends a lawsuit against the company back down to a district court, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit overturned the lower court's ruling that was protected by the Communications Decency Act if users of the company's Web site used it in ways that violated fair housing laws.

In a precedent-setting decision, the appeals court said that although was not responsible for answers provided by users in open-ended questions, it became more than a passive participant in the process when it created online forms that asked users for information that could be used to discriminate against them -- namely, their sex, family status and sexual orientation.

"By requiring subscribers to provide the information as a condition of accessing its service, and by providing a limited set of pre-populated answers, Roommate becomes much more than a passive transmitter of information provided by others; it becomes the developer, at least in part, of that information," the appeals court ruled.

This is a terrible ruling against  As a renter of a room you are inviting someone into your home to live as a roommate, not renting the entire property to the person.  To screen for matches it is appropriate to screen for sex, sexual orientation and presence of children.

What is the 9th Circuit going to rule next ... that dating sites cannot ask those questions either.

How Absurd!!!!

Comments (3)

Tony & Darcy Cannon
Aubrey and Associates Realty - Layton, UT
The C Team

And they wonder where all the lawyer jokes come from!  That is awful!

Apr 04, 2008 09:28 AM
Allen C. Wright
RealtyU - Aliso Viejo, CA
If you ever wonder why things are so expensive, it is lawsuits like this that just keep adding to the cost of doing business.
Apr 04, 2008 09:44 AM
Team Thayer Key Realty Group Inc
Key Realty Group Inc. - Eugene, OR
We will sell your house faster for more money

Thanks for the info! This really helps me understand it a little better!

Justin Thayer

Keller Williams (Eugene Springfield)

For all things Real Estate in Lane county Oregon go to:

Apr 04, 2008 09:46 AM