Admin

Please prepare your clients for Fannie Mae's Risk Based Pricing!

By
Mortgage and Lending with Caliber Home Loans CHL NMLS# 15622 CHL NMLS# 15622

One of my clients asked today after reading my forum post on my site about how much their rate can be effected now with Fannie Mae's new risked based scoring model. This table above is for a purchase transaction, if you are interested in a cash out refinance, then there is yet another table in addition to this one, so it can make a huge impact the lower your score. What does this table mean?

Well lets assume you are purchasing a new home and you are rolling over a 20% down payment from the sale of your current home and you need an 80% loan on the new home. If you have had a dispute with your credit card company and they did not remove a blemish and your score dropped to 659, from 721, you can expect to pay an additional 1.750% in fee! Meaning, if your new loan amount is $300,000, you have to pay 1.75% of that amount or $5,250 more in fees to get the same rate you would have been offered had your credit score remained above 720.

The choice in this case is either pay the fee at closing to get the lower rate or add the fee into the rate and expect your rate to jump .375 to .50%, a very significant jump.

I have had the unfortunate but bitter sweet blessing of gaining new clients from panicked realtors that were shocked, surprised and angered by their mortgage broker or loan officer advising them at the closing table that their rate or fees had jumped considerably due to their credit score and a "new" penalty Fannie Mae has imposed. This is nothing new and has been out since the first of the year. It is malpractice and frustrating for the professionals that are preparing their clients upfront. Another part of the problem is LO's locking in rates prior to pre-approving a client or even pulling their credit. In the scenario above, the LO assumes the client has a 720 or above credit score or is running their business based on old information and quotes the client their locked rate only to find out there is a 1.75% fee penalty because as in the scenario above, they had a 659 not a 720.

This is why upfront planning with your mortgage professional is imperative when considering listing your home or making an offer on a new home. There are quick steps we can take to jump a credit score 20 to 40 points in a matter of weeks just by adjusting some balances on some credit cards possibly, so I strongly suggest having your credit pulled so you can plan properly with no unfortunate surprises.

Comments(5)

Show All Comments Sort:
Susan Hilton
CENTURY 21 Beal, Inc. - College Station, TX
Texas Aggie Real Estate, College Station Bryan Texas Real Estate

Isn't it right that the people who pay their bills on time and keep their credit scores up, should get the best rates? Life isn't fair -

 

Jun 10, 2008 02:57 PM
Doris Freeman
Zach Taylor Real Estate - Gallatin, TN
Broker/Agent, 615-961-7799

Great information, I may print out your blog and give it to the clients that wonder, WHY ME?

Have A Great Day

Jun 10, 2008 03:02 PM
Chuck Carstensen
RE/MAX Results - Elk River, MN
Minnesota/Wisconsin Real Estate Expert

Thats for the reminder. I sort of forgot about this.

Jun 10, 2008 03:06 PM
Lynda Eisenmann
Preferred Home Brokers - Brea, CA
Broker Associate ,CRS,GRI,SRES, Brea,CA, Orange Co

Hi Travis,

This is great information for home buyers, sellers and agents alike. When people call a lender to "shop " rates I don't think they have any idea how much goes into it.

I was talking with a lender friend a week ago about the same thing. He says when people call to ask about rates he says it depends, it's based on a series of 28 questions you need to answer.

Jun 10, 2008 03:08 PM
Travis Neliton
Caliber Home Loans CHL NMLS# 15622 - Portland, OR
Travis Neliton NMLS 283894

Susan,

Sorry if I made that confusing, if you or a client does pay their bills on time, that will certainly help them get a higher score, unfortunately, if they are paying their bills on time which include several maxed out credit cards, balance to limits on the cards will have a big impact on the score as it makes up 30% of the total score.

So paying on time or your payment history is only 35% of the score unfortunately so in a way, it is not fair if a person can manage bad debt properly, if there is such a thing.

Jun 11, 2008 03:39 AM