Special offer

“People Pleasers” and Happiness

By
Real Estate Broker/Owner with Cimpler Real Estate, Inc. CA BRE# 01330941

                              

While taking my kids to soccer practice or to a doctor, I make sure to have my PC with me. Phones are banned in most of lobbies, so returning your calls is not an option. Yesterday, I forgot to take my PC and as a result I was sentenced to scanning through the magazines available in the lobby of my son’s doctor. I got my hands on the June issue of the Parenting Magazine and I started to read an article "about raising happy, confident kids”.

Before I could read the entire article, I got stuck on the fragment stating that "raising confident and happy and confident kids” is opposite to raising “people pleasers”. The difference in our approach to raising girls and boys was given as a “proof”. Authors gave the advice to discourage “maternal” instincts of girls to help them to become more confident and thus happier in their lives. I have to say that I was stun by the assertion that being too much of a “people pleaser” might prevent you from becoming happy. Do we have to shape our kids to become self confident jerks to enable them to become happy? I have a huge problem with this, I have to say.

So, I have a question to all of you. Do you think that being “kind” and “personable” makes it more difficult to be happy in life? Would you want your parents to discourage your “maternal” and “kind” instincts to help you become more confident? Do you think that it would make you happier today? Are these two features so completely opposite? I am really curious your thoughts on the subject. Is there a “golden” mix of “self-confidence” and “people pleasing” behavior that could make us happier?

TODD PICCONI INLANDEMPIRE & SOUTH ORANGE COUNTY, CA
TODD PICCONI REAL ESTATE - Dana Point, CA
Personal Engagement,Precision, and Professionalism

I believe that raising "people pleasers" may be looked upon as not doing a good job at parenting in general......However,it's important to try to instill confidence, and hopefully happiness by helping your kids see that they can be an individual and don't need to always be "pleasing" others, but more please themselves.  Obviously the challenge is to not have the pendulum sway too much in one direction or the other....at least that's my preference. 

When it comes to pleasing, there is a time and place.  When it comes to bucking the system and just doing what makes you happy, there is also a time and place.  I believe teaching them the differences may help.

Jun 12, 2008 08:47 PM
Tom Braatz Waukesha County Real Estate 262-377-1459
Coldwell Banker - Oconomowoc, WI
Waukesha County Realtor Real Estate agent. SOLD!

Artur

Good luck with that one, and happy Fathers day to you

Tom Braatz

Jun 12, 2008 08:50 PM
Brandon Weber
Weber Property Group - Sacramento, CA

I guess it all depends upon how one would describe a "people pleaser."  If it means a person who cares for others and tries to make a positive impact on those he/she comes into contact with each day... we need more of those!  If it means a person who cares so much what others think and want so much to make them happy that they are willing make compromises so as to please people... no.  If it means somebody who is so lacking in confidence, that they allow others to use them as a doormat (much like in the previous example)... no.

As for training woman to be less maternal... Hogwash! (wow... I can honestly say I have never used that word before)  I think women actually have some distinct advantages over men (in business and in life) precisely because they are different.  Perhaps we men need to become more like them!

Anyway, happy Father's Day. I can't wait to spend it with my pregnant wife and 5 year old boy!

Jun 12, 2008 09:15 PM
Artur Urbanski
Cimpler Real Estate, Inc. - Burlingame, CA
Helping property owners to maximize property value

Thanks Tom.  The same to you, assuming that you are father too, aren't you?

Todd, this is exactly what bothers me. What is wrong about being polite and trying to please (serve) people, especially in our profession.  I am taken by surprise by the negative connotation of being "people pleaser". I think that you easily be both, self-confident and a"people pleaser"  Thank you for sharing your comments.

Jun 12, 2008 09:17 PM
Artur Urbanski
Cimpler Real Estate, Inc. - Burlingame, CA
Helping property owners to maximize property value

Brandon, thank for your great comments and have a great Father Day! I like your "categorizing" of "people pleasers" to those who care for others versus those who please because they lack the confidence. Regarding the differences between men and women, my wife and I differ in just about everything (and often disagree as well). We are happily married for 22 years now!

Jun 12, 2008 09:25 PM
Karen Anne Stone
New Home Hunters of Fort Worth and Tarrant County - Fort Worth, TX
Fort Worth Real Estate

Artur:  What a great and thought-provoking post.  I imagine I could go on for pages about this.  I, like most folks, I guess, am a combination of people pleaser and confident person.  I think growing up I never quite got enough of the feeling that I was "pleasing" my parents, especially my father.  So... it appears that in many of my personal relationships... I tried to "please" as much as I could... the people I sought out to be with.  Somehow, I never could quite make it happen.  It's like picking out people it was quite impossible to please, and then never quite being able to please them.

As far as being confident, I think I feel I have many areas about which I am very confident... and some other ares less-so.  I could probably improve on my on personal confidence level... although I am not quie sure on how to do that. 

By the way, Artur... Happy Fathers Day to you !

Jun 12, 2008 09:49 PM
Artur Urbanski
Cimpler Real Estate, Inc. - Burlingame, CA
Helping property owners to maximize property value

Thank you Karen very much for your comments and Happy Father wishes. I really like what you said.  I think this is what we should encourage - a ceratain combination of both, self - confidence and caring - as Brandon pointed it out (again a question - what would be the golden ratio of both features?).

Jun 12, 2008 10:08 PM