Special offer

Mastering the San Mateo Real Estate Market: Guide for Buyers in 2024

Services for Real Estate Pros with InboundREM

San Mateo, CA, nestled in the San Francisco Bay Area, is a thriving and diverse city featuring a rich array of neighborhoods, each with its own unique charm and character. In 2024, the San Mateo real estate market remains a dynamic landscape, reflecting both the competitive nature of the Bay Area housing market and the unique opportunities this locality presents. From luxurious estates in San Mateo Park to more affordable options in Downtown San Mateo, the city caters to a wide range of tastes and budgets. This guide delves deep into the San Mateo Real Estate Market and why it's a sought-after destination for homeowners!

San Mateo Real Estate Market Overview

The San Mateo real estate market in 2024 showcases a spectrum of housing options, with properties ranging from modestly priced homes to multimillion-dollar estates. As of February, the median sale price of homes in San Mateo stands at $1.5 million, marking a 14.3% increase from the previous year. This rise reflects the area's growing desirability and the overall strength of the market. Properties in San Mateo generally sell after an average of 12 days on the market, often receiving multiple offers, which is indicative of a highly competitive market environment.

Key Market Trends:

  • Median Listing Price: Homes in San Mateo Park, the most expensive neighborhood, have a median listing price of $3.6 million.
  • Affordability: In contrast, Downtown San Mateo offers more affordable living options with a median listing price of $499,000.
  • Price Per Square Foot: The median sale price per square foot in San Mateo has reached $995, an 8.9% increase from the previous year, highlighting the premium on space in this sought-after area.

This section of the market is critical for potential buyers to understand, as it sets the stage for what they can expect in terms of investment and the pace at which they need to act due to the quick turnover of properties.

Top Neighborhoods in San Mateo for Homebuyers

San Mateo boasts several neighborhoods that cater to diverse lifestyles and preferences. Here's a closer look at some of the most popular areas:

Downtown San Mateo

Downtown San Mateo is a vibrant mix of commercial and residential spaces, creating a lively urban environment without sacrificing the comforts of suburban living. The west side of Downtown is predominantly commercial, hosting a bustling shopping district, while the east side offers a quieter, residential atmosphere. Homes here are mostly detached, single-family residences, with architectural styles ranging from California bungalows and ranch houses to Craftsman and Tudor homes. The median listing home price in this neighborhood makes it an attractive option for those seeking affordability in a dynamic setting.

Baywood Park

Located just three miles from the city center, Baywood Park provides a tranquil suburban atmosphere along with convenient access to major highways, making it perfect for commuters. The community boasts a variety of housing choices, from townhouses to expansive single-family homes. These properties typically offer between 1,500 and 3,000 square feet of living space and sit on large lots of 7,000 to 9,000 square feet. Architecturally, many homes in Baywood Park reflect the post-war California rancher style, often with four to five bedrooms, catering to families looking for room to grow.

Hayward Park

Historic Hayward Park adds a touch of charm with its array of vintage homes built in the early 20th century. This neighborhood is known for its walkability and proximity to San Mateo’s downtown and the Caltrain station, making it perfect for those who value convenience. Architectural styles in Hayward Park are diverse, including Craftsman, Tudor, Mediterranean, and English cottages. Central Park, a highlight of the community, offers lush greenery, a Japanese tea garden, playgrounds, and sports facilities, enhancing the quality of life for its residents.

These neighborhoods not only showcase the variety of housing options available in San Mateo but also highlight the community features that make each area unique. Whether you are a first-time homebuyer or looking to upgrade, San Mateo provides a neighborhood that can meet your needs.

Trends in Home Prices and Sales

As we delve deeper into 2024, the San Mateo real estate market continues to evolve. The median listing home price in San Mateo as of March was approximately $1.2 million, showing a slight decline of 4.6% year-over-year. This trend provides a nuanced view of the market, where certain areas may offer more competitive pricing due to various factors, including market saturation and economic shifts.

Current Market Dynamics:

  • Median Sold Price: Despite the decrease in listing prices, the median home sold price in San Mateo is notably higher at $1.7 million. This indicates a strong buyer's market, where the final sale price often exceeds the listing price due to competitive bidding.
  • Sales Speed: Homes continue to sell quickly, often within 12 days on the market, emphasizing the need for potential buyers to act swiftly and decisively.
  • Market Fluctuations: The slight decrease in median listing price might signal a temporary adjustment, providing a potential opportunity for buyers to enter the market before prices stabilize or climb again.

Understanding these trends is crucial for buyers to time their market entry and strategize their investments in San Mateo’s real estate. Keeping an eye on these shifts can help in making informed decisions, particularly in a market known for its rapid changes and high competitiveness.

Buyer's Guide to San Mateo Real Estate

Purchasing a home in San Mateo, CA, is not just about finding the right property; it's about navigating the market effectively to make the most informed and beneficial decisions. Here are essential steps every prospective buyer should consider:

Choosing the Right Realtor

Selecting an experienced realtor who understands the San Mateo market is crucial. A skilled realtor will navigate you through the complexities of the market, assist in finding properties that align with your requirements, and represent your interests effectively. Discuss your needs, preferences, and budget clearly with your realtor to ensure they can represent you effectively throughout the buying process.

Selecting Your Ideal Neighborhood

San Mateo offers diverse neighborhoods, each with its unique character and amenities. Consider what is important to you—proximity to work, schools, parks, or public transport—and choose a neighborhood that aligns with your lifestyle needs. Each settlement, from the bustling streets of Downtown San Mateo to the serene lanes of Baywood Park, presents different opportunities and atmospheres.

Mortgage Pre-Approval Process

Securing pre-approval for a mortgage not only defines your budget but also enhances your credibility as a buyer in a competitive market. Approach multiple lenders to compare terms and find the best rates and conditions that suit your financial situation. Pre-approval will enable you to move quickly when you find the right property.

Starting Your Home Search

With your realtor’s help, start exploring listings that fit your criteria and preferences. San Mateo’s market can be fast-moving, so be prepared to visit properties soon after they list. Use your realtor’s expertise to access up-to-date listings and possibly even off-market opportunities.

Making an Offer

Once you find a property that meets your needs, work with your realtor to craft a competitive offer based on current market conditions. Your offer should include not only the price but also attractive terms, like flexible move-in dates or a few contingencies.

Understanding Reports and Disclosures

Review the seller’s disclosure package carefully. This includes the home inspection report, pest inspection report, and any Homeowners Association (HOA) documents. These disclosures provide a deeper insight into the property's condition and can influence your decision or negotiation strategy.

Negotiating With Sellers

Negotiation is a critical step in the home buying process. Your realtor will play an important role in negotiating terms that are in your best interest, ensuring that you get the best deal while also making your offer appealing to the seller.

This strategy provides a detailed roadmap for purchasing a home in San Mateo, arming you with essential tools to effectively traverse the market and make informed decisions that culminate in a successful acquisition.


San Mateo, with its blend of dynamic urban centers and tranquil suburban neighborhoods, offers a compelling array of real estate opportunities for prospective homeowners. The diverse market conditions in San Mateo, ranging from luxury homes in San Mateo Park to more accessible options in Downtown San Mateo, cater to a variety of preferences and budgets. 
As the market changes, it's crucial to grasp the trends and adequately prepare for the buying process to make a wise investment in this dynamic region of the San Francisco Bay Area.

Owning a property in San Mateo not only means investing in real estate but also investing in a lifestyle supported by excellent amenities, strong community ties, and a strategic location. Whether you are a first-time buyer or looking to upgrade, San Mateo's real estate market offers solid opportunities for both living and investment.

Visit the original blog post at https://teamtapper.com/san-mateo-real-estate-market/.  

If you would like to receive a FREE Competitive Market Analysis, contact me today. Let us help you find your perfect home!

If you require a Buyer's Agent to represent you during your transaction, please feel free to contact our office at 650-629-9898. We would be glad to work with you to get the best deal possible for your transaction.



David Tapper


1427 Chapin Ave

Burlingame, CA 94010


Debe Maxwell, CRS
Savvy + Company (704) 491-3310 - Charlotte, NC

Great information for both potential buyers & residents in the area. Thanks for sharing this data with us in the Rain!


May 15, 2024 11:46 AM