Admin

What History Tells Us: Home Prices & Mortgage Rates During a Recession

By
Real Estate Broker/Owner with Expert Real Estate Team 5561

Every time the word "recession" starts popping up in headlines, it brings a wave of uncertainty—especially for anyone thinking about buying or selling a home.

You might be wondering:

  • Are home prices going to crash?
  • Will mortgage rates skyrocket?
  • Should I wait to make a move?

Totally fair questions—and you’re not alone in asking them. The good news is we can look to history to get some real answers.

Let’s break it down.

A Recession Doesn’t Automatically Mean Home Prices Will Drop

First, let’s clear up a common myth:

A recession is not the same as a housing crash.

Data shows that in 4 of the last 6 U.S. recessions, home prices actually went up, and in one, home prices dropped less than 2%. The exception was 2008—and that was a very specific situation involving risky loans, overbuilding, and a financial system that was already on the brink.

 

So, what usually happens?

  • Home prices tend to stay on track or slow down gradually.
  • Fewer buyers may jump into the market, but that doesn’t always mean prices will plummet.
  • Every local market reacts differently, depending on how many homes are available and how many buyers are looking.

Mortgage Rates Tend to Go Down During a Recession

Here’s something most buyers love to hear: Mortgage rates usually drop during a recession.

Freddie Mac data shows rates declined in all six of the last U.S. recessions:

 

That’s because the Federal Reserve often lowers interest rates to help the economy, and that can make borrowing cheaper.

Now, we’re probably not heading back to the super-low 3% rates we saw in 2020, but even a slight dip in rates can make a big difference in your monthly payment. 

Today's Homeowners Have Strong Equity Positions

One of the biggest differences between now and the 2008 housing crisis is homeowner equity. Years of solid price appreciation have created substantial equity cushions for most property owners.

Realtor.com’s analysis of Federal Reserve data shows:

  • Even if home prices dropped 10%, homeowner equity would still be at 69.5% of total value (similar to 2021)
  • A 20% drop would bring equity levels back to what we saw in 2019
  • More than half of homeowners (54%) have mortgage rates below 4%, which means they’re not likely to be forced into selling

This strong equity position means we're unlikely to see waves of distressed sales flooding the market, which helps maintain price stability even during challenging economic times.

Final Thoughts

Economic downturns often bring up uncertainty and fear. But historical data shows that home prices tend to hold steady (or increase) and mortgage rates usually go down. And today, homeowners are in an incredibly strong position. 

If you’re wondering how this might impact your own plans to buy or sell, let’s chat. I’m here to help you make the best decision for your future—not the headlines.

 

Comments(3)

Show All Comments Sort:
Will Hamm
Hamm Homes - Aurora, CO
"Where There's a Will, There's a Way!"

Hello LeAnne and thank you for sharing this great information with us here in the Rain.  Always good to learn from others here.

Apr 18, 2025 09:25 AM
GilbertRealtor BillSalvatore
Arizona Elite Properties - Chandler, AZ
Realtor - 602-999-0952 / em: golfArizona@cox.net

Thanks for sharing and enjoy your Blessed Good Friday and enjoy your Easter Holiday weekend!

Bill Salvatore, Realtor- Arizona Elite Properties

Apr 18, 2025 09:37 AM
Adam Feinberg
Elegran - Manhattan, NY
NYC Condo, Co-op, and Townhouse Advisor

I spent 16+ years in capital markets before changing careers into real estate. My client base was always internal to the firm- but those external facing had a well known disclaimer "Past performance does not guarantee future results".

There are two important points to consider beyond the recurring trend. 

Yes, the trend of what occurs in past recessions is important though it should be approached with caution- especially this time where there there has been a government approach to help in the past that may not be an option this time around.  Ignoring the equities market for a moment (which is what most people pay attention to) - I am paying more attention to Treasuries and also, not weighted as heavily, on Gold. The equities market has always had a little bit of a positive bias (which gives rise to situations like a dead cat bounce) and is also subject to the whims of automated trading systems. Treasuries on the other hand is different. Any college student taking a Finance 101 course will tell you that U.S. Treasuries represent the risk free rate of return. As such, the returns are far from sexy- but considering the near zero level of risk- they represent stability with some interest for lending the government some cash. It's also well known in real estate circles that the 10 year Treasury is tied closely to the 30 year fixed rate mortgage. What happens when investors lose faith that the US Government will be able to or has the desire to pay that money back? This is what started happening with Trump's tariff's. Whether it's a short term negotiating tactic or a new form of expected revenue matters less than the fact that the world is now spooked whether we are going to honor the Treasuries and pay back the debt. Our word is our bond- and Trump's approach is not one that gives anyone comfort that our word means anything. This is indeed what happened the other week.   

Second- Housing prices in much of the nation have had a massive run up in the last several years. If you review the median house price in the US from FRED (Federal Reserve of St. Louis) and track home prices over the long term- you will certainly see a general stability over the long term- but not the crazy run up in recent years. Just a quick and dirty review of the chart shows that the median is likely about $100k too high.  

I do believe that this time we might not (as a nation) follow the historic norms of home prices in a recession but I don't see a crash either. Even if prices decline, first off- everyone needs a place to live in. Secondly, enough time passes, and price movements in the short to medium term seem irrelevant because in the long term prices will rise. Even at 7% interest rates- a 30 year fixed rate mortgage is a great hedge against inflation.  Finally, an investment in a home is relatively stable during turbulent times- this is not like 2008, when buyers/owners had little to no equity in their homes.

Apr 18, 2025 10:01 AM