Admin

To Paint or NOT to Paint your rental

By
Real Estate Broker/Owner with Crown Key Realty, Inc; Tracy & Mountain House Sales and Property Management 01490605

To Paint or Not to Paint? That Is the Question asked by a housing provider in Tracy, CA.  He reached out to as property managers at Crown Key Realty,Inc (CKRPM)

For seasoned investors, this one’s easy:
You paint when you turn a unit. Period.

But when you’re managing a large portfolio (like we do at Crown Key Realty), it’s not always black and white. Wall condition, age, texture, color, square footage, trim details—it all varies. Add to that a wide range of investor goals and budgets, and suddenly, painting becomes one of the most subjective decisions we make during a turnover.

So, how do we handle it?

Here’s our philosophy—simple, strategic, and effective:

Paint condition directly impacts rent and time on market.
If the walls look tired, the unit sits. If they shine, it rents faster—and often for more.

We assign a quality rating to walls during every turnover.
"A" means like-new. No action needed.
"B" might be acceptable depending on the owner’s long-term goals.
Anything below a "B"? We paint—no hesitation.

We ask: does this wall take up visual space?
If a wall is front-and-center in a showing and it makes a bad impression, we paint it. People rarely re-tour rentals. First impressions are everything.

No patchwork jobs.
We don’t spot paint. Ever. It’s all or nothing—corner to corner. Slapping paint on one section often makes things worse. We do it right or we don’t do it at all.

We invest in quality paint.
Cheap paint costs more in the long run. We use durable, high-end paint that holds up to wear and extends the time between future paint jobs.

No flat matte in kitchens or baths.
That’s just asking for mold and microbial buildup. We use washable, mold-resistant finishes in all wet areas. Health and durability matter.

Bottom line? Paint is an investment—not an expense. It influences value, rentability, and perception. And when done right, it pays off every time.

Got questions about turnover strategy or want a walkthrough of how we rate walls? Let’s talk. At Crown Key Realty, we don’t guess—we guide.

 

 

Comments(3)

Show All Comments Sort:
Michael Jacobs
Pasadena, CA
Pasadena And Southern California 818.516.4393

Hello Susan - while I am no longer active, it seems you go beyond the state of California requirements for painting of rental properties.  I think that's a wise move as first impressions of property for rent can often elevate a landlord's choice of tenants.  

Jul 11, 2025 02:55 AM
Sham Reddy CRS
Howard Hanna RE Services, Dayton, OH - Dayton, OH
CRS

Thanks for sharing Susan!!! Great information, I had many rentals for long time!

Paint is an investment—not an expense. It influences value, rentability, and perception. And when done right, it pays off every time.

Jul 11, 2025 04:24 AM
Wayne Martin
Wayne M Martin - Oswego, IL
Real Estate Broker - Retired

Good morning Susan. As an asset manager for a large portfolio at one time, my philosophy was paint it using quality paint. It may not be new but it is new to the new occupant. The unit needs to be occupied to produce income. Enjoy your day.

Jul 11, 2025 05:41 AM