This is my entry into the October Challenge "Historical Stories About Your Location."
As the area of the Massachusetts Bay Colony I live in is part of the, Rowley Plantation, established in 1639 by Ezekiel Rogers & 20 other families, there are plenty of historical stories to share. Our area is where the Puritans primarily colonized, as opposed to the Pilgrims of Plymouth Rock fame, which is the South Shore. We are the North Shore.
Byfield Parish Church is the oldest independent Congregational Church in the United States of America, founded in 1702 by Mehetable (Sewall) Moody, sister of Judge Samual Sewall and 18 other families. We are an evangelical, Bible believing, teaching & preaching church.
Sidenote: Judge Samuel Sewall was one of the "Salem Witch Trial" judges in 1692. But that's another story for another day.
The Byfield Parish Church was founded by nineteen families in the western parts of Rowley and Newbury, Massachusetts (part of the Rowley Plantation). They were tired of the weekly travel of three miles or more each way from their homes to the churches established by the first settlers. In 1701, these people successfully petitioned their town meetings for an abatement of one-half of the taxes which they were required to pay to support the first churches. The abated half of the tax they levied on themselves to support their new church, and after the parish was formally incorporated in 1710, all property within it was taxed for church purposes by the parish, not the town meeting.
By 1702, the founders had bought the land where the present “old” church stands, built a meetinghouse, laid out a cemetery, and engaged one Moses Hale, a grandson of a Newbury first settler, as their pastor. By 1704, Rev. Hale had been installed in a newly built parsonage, and in that same year, it was voted to name the new parish, previously known as Rowlberry and even thereafter, as Newbury Falls, in honor of Judge Nathaniel Byfield. Judge Byfield, a prominent and wealthy lawyer, lived in Rhode Island. It was hoped that he would be inspired to share his wealth with his namesake parish, and ten years later, he did, to the extent of donating a bell for the meetinghouse. Whether or not the parishioners felt that the bell was worth the name is not recorded.
Judge Samuel Sewall

From 1702 until 1825, Byfield Parish Church had only three pastors, each of whom contributed mightily to its growth and strength. There are no known renderings of Reverend Moses Parsons.
Reverend John Hale Reverend George Whitefield
Rev. Hale, who laid the foundation, died in 1744 and was succeeded by Rev. Moses Parsons, who, among other things, saw the Church through the Great Awakening led by George Whitefield and through the Revolutionary War. From 1787 to 1825, the pastor was Elijah Parish, who was noted beyond the parish as a preacher, author, geographer and historian. During his ministry, the Church survived an attempt by some unhappy parishioners to start a rival church. Also, during this period, a choir and a Sunday School were established. A stove was installed in the meetinghouse. Ashes from the stove were stored under the pulpit, and in 1833, ashes, still hot, started a fire, which destroyed the meetinghouse.
In that same year, the Massachusetts legislature decreed that parishes could no longer levy taxes to support their churches. From this point on, finance became a central theme in the history of the Byfield Parish Church. Pastorates became shorter because the church, although there were periods of very satisfactory growth and stability, was not consistently able to pay its ministers a living wage.
However, a new meetinghouse replaced the old one destroyed in 1833. It was financed by the Proprietors of the Meetinghouse, a corporation which raised so much money by selling pews that the stockholders received a dividend!
During its second century, the Byfield Parish Church settled into the position of a country church in a thoroughly settled community. There were times when it seemed that it would be forced to close, but a new parson or perhaps sheer dedication on the part of the parishioners to keep it going. Ebb and flow continued right on up through World War II, with a real crisis having been survived when in 1930 the 1833 meetinghouse was struck by lightning and destroyed by the resulting fire. The small, underfinanced but determined congregation took a step of faith in contributing and borrowed the funds to build the present “old” meetinghouse. Note: Pam & I started attending in 1979.
The old church still stands and has been turned into a residence.
During the early World War II years, the Church was able to finance only a student minister, and in 1943, agreed with the Rowley Congregational Church that they would jointly call a minister to serve both Churches. Rev. Richard J. Schaper was called. He started a new era for the Byfield Church. He stirred interest by organizing a mortgage burning and a ceremony of dedication of the 1932 meetinghouse. He persuaded the Church to incorporate as an organization separate from the parish and to handle its own funds. He united the Ladies Benevolent Association and the Helen Noyes Missionary Band, two women’s groups whose functions and whose members were practically identical, into a Ladies Guild. The influx of new residents, which occurred after World War II, contributed to the momentum that he established and which his successor, Rev. Robert G. Morris, maintained.
By 1954, both the Byfield and the Rowley Churches felt ministers of their own would better serve them. Byfield went to student ministers for the next four years, but by 1958, it had started a new parsonage for its first full-time pastor in twenty years. Four ministers, two interim and two residents, led the Church from 1958 to 1969. Although their terms of office were short, each left the Church growing stronger.
![]()
Rev. William Boylan, a native of Ipswich, MA was called to the pastorate in 1969. A man of strong biblical faith, his leadership resulted in unprecedented growth and strength. Numerous programs were developed, both in the church and in its outreach. Building programs resulted in a much larger meetinghouse, a new parsonage and an expanded Parish House. After 49 years of faithful ministry, Pastor Boylan transitioned to Pastor Emeritus.

Since 2017, Byfield Parish Church has been pastored by Brent Fugate. The church continues to operate as a vibrant Christian community. Recent years have seen continual growth in many areas. Note: The youth ministry has a population of over 60 youths from around the area's towns
This is my church's history. Much of the information was compiled by our former church historian, John Witherspoon.

Comments(12)