Battle of the AIs—Our Zoom Twilight Challenge
This week in our Zoom AI class (thanks, Praful Thakkar!), the homework task was one that every real estate agent and stager has wondered how to automate- taking a standard professional daytime photo of a listing and transforming it into a stunning twilight listing photo.
It sounds simple enough, but after testing four major platforms, I learned that not all AI is created equal. Here is how the competition stacked up:
- ChatGPT: A swing and a miss. The output was extremely dark and essentially unusable for marketing purposes.
- Claude: The result was technically a "twilight" picture, but it lacked depth. It was simply dark, though still visible.
- NightCafé: The wildcard. It generated a wildly gorgeous, architectural masterpiece... that looked nothing like the actual house I’m trying to sell!
Here are the AI platform products:
1. ChatGPT
2. Claude
3. NightCafé
The 'Clear' Winner: Gemini (Featured Photo)
I tried Gemini first (during the meeting, in fact). I was pleased with the image Gemini produced but, the program did omit the mulch from around one of the trees (for some strange reason)! I did give the system a prompt to add the mulch back but, it added it back to beneath the wrong tree (a small tree that didn't have any mulch under it to begin with).
All-in-all, the difference was night and day (pun intended😀). Gemini didn't darken the image or hallucinate a new structure; it understood the assignment. It kept the exact details of the listing photo (with the exception of the mulch) while perfectly capturing that high-end, "golden hour" aesthetic.
For this challenge, Gemini was the clear winner, proving that when you need precision alongside creativity, it is currently the top of the class, just as Praful said it was!
What will our next challenge be? You'll have to tune into our next Zoom call to find out. Stay tuned for George Souto's announcement on Sundays. THANK YOU, GEORGE! No matter the topic, we have a wonderful hour together each week and would love to have you join us!
Comments(7)