A Hard Truth in Real Estate
Every Seller wants the most money in the shortest amount of time. Most believe their home is “different.” Maybe it’s the mountain view. Maybe it’s that gleaming kitchen remodel. Maybe it’s the fact that you raised your kids under that roof and every corner tells a story. Maybe it's because you "need" a certain amount of money. And while all of that may (or may not) matter, here’s the truth that's often hard for Sellers to face:
It's always about price
Think of price as the steering wheel. Location, condition, and market trends? They’re in the car, and they're probably commenting from the back seat. But they're not driving. I've been in Colorado Springs real estate for over three decades. My family has been in real estate for five generations. Through it all, I’ve learned that when a home doesn’t sell, it’s usually not because of “bad luck” or “picky Buyers.” It’s because the price is telling the wrong story.
A concept that's often hard for a Seller to grasp is: The Buyer ultimately sets the price. The market - not emotions or need - decides what Buyers are willing to pay. Let me tell you a few quick tales from the trenches.
The $15,000 Smell Test
Once upon a time, there was a picture-perfect home. Fresh paint, manicured yard, spacious rooms - and a lingering pet odor. The Sellers waved it off. “It’s the carpet! We've had it cleaned. Buyers can replace it.”
Buyers came. Buyers sniffed. Buyers left. (In 'Realtor-speak' there's an expression: If it smells, it won't sell.)
After twenty-two showings, the Sellers reluctantly agreed to drop the price $15,000 because, for some reason, they weren't willing to replace the carpet (which would have been much cheaper). Suddenly, Buyers overlooked the smell. They didn’t mind the carpet so much now, they saw a good deal and bought the house. At the right price, Buyers will overlook "condition" flaws and quirks.
Three Listings - It Was About the Price
Three homes hit the market within days in the same area. Similar floor plan, similar age, similar updates. Neighbors watched like it was a reality show. I even had my Seller explain to me that his was worth $20,000 more than his neighbors' because he had installed new toilets! He was serious. (I talked him down, but not low enough.)
Guess which one sold first? Not the house with the best landscaping. Not the one with the new toilets. The similar one priced lower. Once it went under contract, the others had to chase the market down with price cuts. Price doesn’t just attract Buyers, it creates momentum.
Or a Seller will say, "What if we install granite countertops?" That may make a Buyer pick yours over a similar listing, but it won't win over a home that's priced too high.
When Location Isn’t Enough
Sellers often tell me that location matters. There's a reason Location, Location, Location is an adage. One of my clients had a charming rancher on the west side. Sellers often believe address alone justifies a high price. They thought Buyers would fall in love instantly. But crickets. Week after week, showings came and went with polite feedback but no offers. After some soul searching, the Sellers agreed to adjust the price.
That gorgeous, tree-lined street couldn’t save the listing from sitting. Once the price aligned with reality, multiple offers arrived within three days. It wasn't that the house wasn't beautiful. It's that the price didn't line up with what Buyers were willing to pay in that moment in that market. Buyers still measure value with price.
The Parade of Buyers Who Walked Away
Here’s another common scenario: the house with endless showings but zero offers. Sellers get excited. “So much traffic! Someone will bite!” But heavy foot traffic with no offers is classic overpricing. Even when all the feedback is "Great house!" but you don't get any offers, it's about price.
My rule of thumb in real estate? If the home doesn't have serious interest or an offer after ten showings, it's the market’s polite way of saying, “Your price is too high.” If Buyers love the home but won’t commit, price is the problem.
Buyers shop by comparison. Your home is positioned next to every other current listing in their price range. The best marketing in the world can't fix an overpriced home.
So often a Seller will tell me, "We're willing to negotiate." But in this market, most Buyers will not even offer on an overpriced home. Even a few thousand dollars can put you out of the running.
Nail the Right Price from the Start
Because of my business model, I often start working with Sellers months before their home actually hits the market. The tricky part is that what Buyers were willing to pay when we first discussed a price may look different by the time the home goes ‘live.’ Unfortunately, that is the name of the game this year. That shift can feel discouraging, and I never enjoy being the one to deliver that news. But my job is to help you succeed, and that means keeping a close eye on the market so we can adjust and position your home for the best possible result.
If prices are adjusting, waiting too long to align with reality can cost you more in time and dollars. If Buyers are saying, "Nice home, but we chose another," the market is speaking. A price adjustment in the first few weeks is far less painful than months of sitting stale. If you have showings but no offers, adjust sooner rather than later.
So often I've sold quirky homes - homes with shag carpet, an avocado-green bathtub, and wallpaper that might have been fashionable in 1972. But Buyers bought because the price was right.
Buyers are remarkably forgiving when they feel they’re getting value. A good deal covers a multitude of sins. Condition matters less than you think when the price tells the right story.
If you're thinking of selling your Colorado Springs home, I'd love to walk you through the latest local market data. I'll run the numbers. We can help you find your "just right" price. Let's chat (no pressure, no obligation) and get your home on the path to SOLD.
Originally published as It's Always Price: What CO Springs Sellers Need to Know
Comments(6)