Admin

🏡 MYTH-BUSTING TUESDAY: More Inventory Means Buyers Can Lowball Every Seller?

By
Real Estate Agent with Savvy + Company (704) 491-3310 228209

🏡 MYTH-BUSTING TUESDAY: More Inventory Means Buyers Can Lowball Every Seller?

 

Buyers are finally seeing more choices in the Charlotte region—and after years of fighting over nearly every decent listing, that feels like a very welcome change. But more homes on the market does not mean every seller is standing at the front door waving a white flag!

 

THE MYTH

“More inventory means buyers can lowball every seller.”

 

THE REALITY

More inventory gives buyers breathing room. They may have time to compare homes, negotiate thoughtfully and include protections that were harder to keep during the frenzy. What it does not create is a universal clearance sale.

According to Canopy Realtor® Association’s latest weekly market update, Charlotte-region inventory was up 9% for the week ending August 22. Yet July sellers still received an average of 95.9% of their original list price. That tells us buyers have gained choices and some leverage—but well-priced, well-prepared homes are still attracting serious offers.

Every property has its own little market. Condition, location, price, competition and days on market all matter. A home that has been sitting for weeks with multiple price reductions may invite a more aggressive offer. A beautifully presented new listing priced correctly in a popular neighborhood may not.

MY TAKE

The smartest offer is not automatically the lowest one. It is the offer supported by the home’s value, current competition and the buyer’s goals.

I love seeing buyers regain the ability to think instead of sprint. But there is a big difference between negotiating from evidence and tossing out a number simply because inventory has increased. One can open a productive conversation. The other may end it before it begins.


“More choices create opportunity—not permission to ignore value.” — Debe Maxwell


Are buyers in your market negotiating more confidently—or simply testing how low sellers will go?

Posted by

DEBE MAXWELL, CRS*
Broker | Savvy + Company

 (704) 491-3310
CALL OR TEXT

Email Me

OFFICE
(704) 330-8326
1920 E 7th Street
Charlotte, NC 28204

My Blog  |  About Me

iCharlotteHomes.com

        

Search Homes  |  Testimonials
Free Home Valuation

*Certified Residential Specialist (CRS) is the highest credential awarded to residential sales agents, managers and brokers.

   

 

Comments(10)

Show All Comments Sort:
Nina Hollander, Broker
Coldwell Banker Realty - Charlotte, NC
Your Greater Charlotte Real Estate Broker

Debe Maxwell, CRS amen to that, sister! I can't tell you how often I have this conversation with people who think more inventory and more days on market are an automatic invitation to low ball a seller.

Sep 08, 2026 04:19 AM
Debe Maxwell, CRS

It's frustrating--especially when clients submit one of those 'low ball' Offers and then someone else swoops in with a full-price Offer, winning the property, Nina Hollander, Broker!

Sep 08, 2026 08:38 AM
Nina Hollander, Broker

Debe Maxwell, CRS fortunately, I've found it doesn't take more than once losing a property for low ball bidding for a buyer to get the message... although there's that occasional one who needs to be slapped up side the head twice before they get it. :)

Sep 08, 2026 08:53 AM
Debe Maxwell, CRS

Yes, it sometimes takes a time or two--especially with high-finance folks; they tend to think they know more than we do, Nina Hollander, Broker! 

Sep 08, 2026 09:19 AM
Brian England
Ambrose Realty Management LLC - Gilbert, AZ
MBA, GRI, REALTOR® Real Estate in East Valley AZ

It seems that those who like to make lowball offers are just fishing for a steal, and I don't enjoy dealing with them on either side of the transaction, haha.

Sep 08, 2026 04:37 AM
Debe Maxwell, CRS

No matter the data you share with them, they are hard core STUCK on those lowballs, Brian England! It sometimes takes a time or two but, they eventually get with the program!

Sep 08, 2026 08:39 AM
Roy Kelley
Retired - Gaithersburg, MD

Good Tuesday morning, Debe. This is good information to share with prospective home buyers. There will never be a shortage of unrealistic prospects.

Sep 08, 2026 04:57 AM
Debe Maxwell, CRS

Oh, so true, Roy Kelley! Some things never change, even when the market does!

Sep 08, 2026 08:42 AM
Gwen Fowler SC Lakes & Mountains 864-710-4518
Gwen Fowler Real Estate, Inc - Walhalla, SC
Gwen Fowler Real Estate, Inc.
Debe, you’ve tackled a classic misconception that pops up every single time inventory shifts! Pointing out that having more breathing room and choices doesn't turn the market into a universal clearance sale is such a vital reality check for buyers, especially when the data still shows sellers fetching nearly 96% of their list price. Thanks for sharing such a grounded perspective on how to negotiate with evidence rather than just tossing out lowball numbers!
Sep 08, 2026 05:03 AM
Debe Maxwell, CRS

There are communities still fetching 101% here and buyers who think sellers are desperate. That's when the second buyers swoop in with a full-price Offer and win the property, Gwen Fowler SC Lakes & Mountains 864-710-4518!

Sep 08, 2026 08:44 AM
Kat Palmiotti
Kalispell, MT
Retired from real estate; active in life!

It's much better when buyers have time to think and not rush into something!

Sep 08, 2026 05:18 AM
Debe Maxwell, CRS

I positively LOVE that buyers have time to sleep on it now too, Kat Palmiotti! I feel like they don't regret a decision; they were formerly forced to make an on-spot decision, sometimes regretting it.

Sep 08, 2026 08:45 AM
Leanne Smith
Dirt Road Real Estate - Golden Valley, AZ
The Grit and Gratitude Agent

The old adage everything is negotiable is somewhat true depending upon who is doing the negotiation.

Sep 08, 2026 06:07 AM
Debe Maxwell, CRS

This is still the bottom line...it's all a negotiation, Leanne Smith! I tell my clients who receive these lowball Offers that 'this was a good starting point for negotiations!'

Sep 08, 2026 08:49 AM
Ken Semler
ImpresaModular.com - Martinsburg, WV
Nationwide Custom Modular Home Builder

The 95.9% sale-to-original-list-price figure is the useful guardrail, Debe, because a 9% inventory increase changes the buyer’s menu but does not establish the discount on any individual house. The stronger offer strategy separates market-wide leverage from property-specific leverage by examining condition, competing listings, days on market, prior reductions, and seller timing. Evidence can support an aggressive offer; inventory headlines alone cannot. Hope Charlotte buyers use the new breathing room wisely.

Sep 08, 2026 06:25 AM
Debe Maxwell, CRS

Exactly! More inventory gives buyers choices and perhaps a little breathing room, but the facts surrounding each individual property—not a broad market headline—should determine the offer strategy, Ken Semler.

Sep 08, 2026 08:54 AM
Wayne Martin
Wayne M Martin - Oswego, IL
Real Estate Broker - Retired

Good morning Debe. More inventory, more potential options. The more unique a listing the less competition. The less competition the more urgency. Each property has its own value and market interest. Choose wisely or be too late. An experienced agent can be of great assistance. 

Sep 08, 2026 06:27 AM
Debe Maxwell, CRS

I agree 100% with your summary, Wayne Martin! And, you bet--an experienced agent makes all the difference. 

Sep 08, 2026 05:01 PM
George Souto
George Souto NMLS #65149 - Middletown, CT
Your Connecticut Mortgage Expert

Debe low ball offer can be a major mistake, even in a strong Buyers' Market.  Buyers would be wise in following their Realtors advice when it comes to setting the offer amount.

Sep 08, 2026 04:12 PM
Debe Maxwell, CRS

Such sage advice, George Souto! A good agent is worth their weight in gold!

Sep 08, 2026 05:03 PM
Dorie Dillard Austin TX
Coldwell Banker Apex Realtors, LLC ~ 512.750.6899 - Austin, TX
Educating. Encouraging. Serving.

Good evening Debe Maxwell, CRS ,

It is a myth that “More inventory means buyers can lowball every seller.” Sometimes it couldn't be further from the truth. Buyers need to work with an experienced buyer's agent to properly interpret the local market.

Sep 08, 2026 04:36 PM
Debe Maxwell, CRS

So true, Dorie Dillard Austin TX! I've seen them come in low and someone swoops in with a full-price Offer, leaving the low-ballers in the dust. Just because they submitted the Offer first, doesn't give them first dibs on the property!

Sep 08, 2026 05:07 PM