Most Tallahassee buyers spend weeks on the mortgage rate and about ten minutes on the insurance quote. That habit made sense once. It does not anymore.
With a fixed-rate loan, principal and interest never change. Property taxes and insurance can, and since 2008 insurance has climbed fast.
In 2008 the average Florida homeowners premium was $1,390. By 2022 it was $2,677. That is close to a doubling in fourteen years, and the climb was not steady. Premiums held nearly flat from 2012 through 2019, then rose fastest of all from 2020 through 2022.
The dashed line starts from our 2026 estimate of about $2,968 and asks one question: what if premiums climb at the pace they set from 2008 to 2022? At that pace, the average would reach $5,716 by 2040. That assumes the past repeats. It is not a forecast.
The number is a statewide average, and a Tallahassee house is not an average. The roof, the plumbing, the year it was built and where it sits on the flood map decide much of your own premium, and you can check all of them before your inspection period ends.
The full report sorts which insurance rules come from Florida law and which belong to one company, with five graphs.
If you are weighing a move in Tallahassee, tell us what you are considering and we will give you a straight read on your price range.


Comments(1)