Admin

87505 Listings Sit for 60 Days — But the Homes That Actually Sell Go Under Contract in 20

By
Real Estate Agent with Scarborough Realty LLC REC-2022-1099

Every month my team pulls the full dual-MLS dataset for ZIP 87505 — south-central Santa Fe — and this September's numbers expose a stale-inventory problem hiding inside an otherwise healthy market.

The active-listing median days-on-market right now is 60. Read that number alone and you'd think 87505 buyers are sitting on their hands. But look at the 296 homes that actually closed over the trailing 12 months: their median time to contract was just 20 days — a third of what the active-side number suggests. That gap is the story. A chunk of the 302 current listings are overpriced and parked; the correctly-priced homes are moving in three weeks.

The sold data backs it up: sellers captured a median 96.6% of their original asking price, and 98.1% of final list, across the last year. Only 13% sold over asking, but a healthy majority — 62% — sold at or under, meaning this isn't a bidding-war market; it's a priced-right-and-it-moves market. The 90-day median sale price, $690,000, is already tracking above the 12-month median of $675,000, so pricing power here hasn't softened.

Where the volume actually sits: 45% of all 87505 closings over the last year landed between $400K and $700K — not anywhere near the $950,000 median list price residential sellers are currently asking. That's close to a $300,000 gap between what's listed and what's actually trading hands, and it's worth knowing before you set a number.

The full breakdown — price bands, property-type splits, and days-on-market detail by segment — is in our 87505 September 2026 market report. Browse current inventory at Santa Fe homes for sale, or scan every area we track in our full library of monthly market reports.

— Matthew Scarborough, Scarborough Realty Group, Keller Williams Santa Fe

Posted by

Matthew Scarborough
Scarborough Realty Group | Keller Williams Santa Fe
130 Lincoln Ave, Suite K, Santa Fe, NM 87501
(505) 428-9547 | buysellnewmexico.com

Fresh monthly market data for 40+ Santa Fe & New Mexico neighborhoods: New Mexico Market Reports

Comments(6)

Show All Comments Sort:
Will Hamm
Hamm Homes - Aurora, CO
"Where There's a Will, There's a Way!"

Happy Monday Matthew and pricing and location I would have to say is the key for homes moving faster but interest rates slow down September sale I think.

 

Oct 05, 2026 06:47 AM
Ken Semler
ImpresaModular.com - Martinsburg, WV
Nationwide Custom Modular Home Builder

Matthew, comparing the homes still listed with those that actually closed shows why one market-wide days-on-market number can mislead a seller. I would also separate those comparisons by price band and property type before concluding that every older listing is overpriced. The useful question is which comparable homes earned a contract quickly and what buyers found more compelling about them.

Oct 05, 2026 06:52 AM
Matthew Scarborough
Scarborough Realty LLC - Santa Fe, NM
Local Market Expert

Happy Monday to you too! Pricing and location are definitely the top two, though in 87505 right now it's almost entirely pricing — the 296 homes that closed this past year had a median 20 days to contract, while the active-listing side is sitting at 60. Same location, same buyer pool, three times the wait when it's priced wrong. On rates: the 90-day median sale price ($690K) is still tracking above the 12-month median ($675K), so buyers haven't pulled back on what they're willing to pay for the right home — they've just gotten a lot less patient with overpriced ones. You can browse what's actually moving right now at Santa Fe homes for sale.

Oct 05, 2026 03:02 PM
Matthew Scarborough
Scarborough Realty LLC - Santa Fe, NM
Local Market Expert

That's exactly the segmentation question we built the report to answer, Ken. 45% of all 87505 closings over the trailing 12 months landed in the $400K–$700K band — nowhere near the $950K median list price residential sellers are currently asking, and that gap is most of the stale-inventory problem right there. On your "what buyers found more compelling" question: it wasn't bidding wars (only 13% sold over asking), it was pricing discipline — 62% sold at or under ask and still closed in a median 20 days. Full price-band and property-type splits are in the September 87505 market report if you want to dig into the segments.

Oct 05, 2026 03:03 PM
Joan Cox, Retired Broker/Owner
Denver, CO
Enjoying Every Day to Its Fullest!

Matthew, those home in a great location, priced at or below fair market value and in good condition will go quicker.

Oct 05, 2026 09:04 PM
Matthew Scarborough
Scarborough Realty LLC - Santa Fe, NM
Local Market Expert

Jon, that's exactly the mechanism hiding behind that 60-day number. 87505 isn't really one market right now — it's two: the correctly-priced group selling in a median 20 days, and an overpriced group sitting unsold and dragging the active-side average up. Location and condition absolutely matter, but the biggest lever is still the number on the sign — sellers who got it right still captured 96.6% of their original ask, and 62% sold at or under list rather than over, so there's no bidding-war cushion bailing out a bad price call this fall. Good instinct tying all three together. If you want to see how that same split shows up across other Santa Fe-area zips and neighborhoods, I track it monthly here: https://www.buysellnewmexico.com/neighborhoods/

Oct 06, 2026 03:02 PM