Admin

Disappointed in FHA Secure

By
Mortgage and Lending with Texana Bank

So, with all the horror stories of people losing their homes, rates adjusting, astronomical mortgage payments, job loss etc..., the government decides to formulate a new FHA program aimed at helpig borrowers who are 'facing foreclosure'.

 

The short version of the program is this: Borrower has an adjustable rate mortgage. Rate adjusts. They are late on some credit card payments and some mortgage payments, but want to keep the house. The idea would be, FHA would refi the loan to a lower, fixed rate and help keep that borrower from losing the house, which is supposedly a lose-lose situation.

First round of pickiness states that the borrower can have no late payments PRIOR TO the adjustable rate hike. Meaning, no irresponsible loan hog will get a new deal. Fine. I can grasp that. You don't want to 'bail' out someone who is reckless with their spending, and not responsible with their debts.

But the second round is really bothering me. See, they won't help if the house is IN foreclosure. So, if you miss one or two payments, and your lender has not filed foreclosure paperwork yet, you're fine and can get approved. BUT, if they have, you're disqualified.

 

Who does this help? The people will lose the house, the banks will have another property they don't care about, and sales prices continue to plummet because no one has confidence in the lending system, and therefore won't buy at any price.

If the program is supposed to help those 'facing' foreclosure, why do they leave out the biggest group- people who are IN foreclosure?

 

I just don't get it. Has anyone had any experiences with this program yet? Positive experiences, I mean. So far, I've just heard of a lot of turned down applications, and a lot of disappointment.

Comments(4)

Show All Comments Sort:
Tim Bradford
Cleveland, OH
NMLS 250013

Jennifer, I have done a few 95% Cash out or Steamline Refinances to get people out of the Adjustable Rate Loans.  I used the standard FHA program instead of the FHA Secure.  Like you, I believe FHA Secure is more hype than reality.   I am interested in see the options that is suppose to come out in Oct.   Being slighly skepitical I believe it is again more hype than reality.   The option is suppose to have Future Equity Sharing by the government.   It requires the current lender to write down a portion of the balance due on the loan and the borrower will still need to verify enough income was reported to IRS to qualify for the loan.  The biggest issue as I see it is that so many of the ARM's were written Stated or No Income Loans.   Some over extention of the borrower with monthly payments because the credit markets were accepting TRUST LOANS - (Trust me I will Make the PAYMENT). 

I look forward to Hearing any comments from other Rainers...  

PS:   Did you post this to Localism???   I consider this a Members ONLY Post.   Posts to Localism in my opinion should be more positive.    Just my opinion. 

Aug 11, 2008 01:20 PM
James Monastero
Texana Bank - Fuquay Varina, NC
The Matchmaker

Tim- thanks for the comments. I think you are right, that it is more hype than anything else, and it is a show of 'we're here to help the consumer, not just bail out the big banks!'. Again, if someone is IN foreclosure, they need the help more than anyone, and yet cannot get it. It's sad.

As far as posting in Localism, I did consider making it a more private post- however, a lot of people are going through this right now, and I hate to dash hopes, but also don't want to hear of people getting taken advantage of.

Aug 11, 2008 01:40 PM
Tim Bradford
Cleveland, OH
NMLS 250013

If you want case and point.  I had a client call today that wanted to get a mortgage for a home.   They needed to move because the current home is in foreclosure, because they have not made any payments since Feb 2007.   Of course these people had no cash for downpayment.  They also had a couple of car REPO's since they purchased the home in 2005.   I wish someone could explain to me why these people believe they deserve to be Homeowners...   Home ownership is a privilege that is earned not a right. 

On My soap box, Personally, I would like to see IRS audit the Tax Returns of anyone taking out a Stated Income loan.   

Aug 11, 2008 02:11 PM
James Monastero
Texana Bank - Fuquay Varina, NC
The Matchmaker

Tim- at the same time, you must realize that unless you OWN a home outright, you are basically renting anyway. 'Ownership' is a very loose term when it comes to homes for some reason. No one 'owns' anything except the banks that are holding the note and title.

Aug 12, 2008 06:47 AM