Special offer

Is Print Advertising Dead?

By
Real Estate Agent with Re/max Results

color homes adAs an Agent for Coldwell Banker Gundaker one of our major points of differentiation has been the large amount of print advertising that we have each week. We have had major advertising in the St. Louis Post Dispatch. A double page spread of color homes ads in the middle of the real estate section of the Sunday paper, the back page on the real estate section had color pictures of our more expensive listings, and the front 2 pages had a list of all of our open houses for that day.

Unfortunately due to the continued rising costs of the advertising, even as the circulation numbers go down and recent unfounded and biased attacks against full service real estate companies by the St. Louis Post Dispatch, Coldwell Banker Gundaker has decided to greatly reduce the advertising. No more lists of all the open houses, ads only 3 weeks a month, and most ads Black and White instead of color.Open House ads

One of the explanations given to the agents about this reduction is that 80% of advertising budget was going to print advertising, a medium that is producing less and less results compared to internet advertising. I do have to agree, I usually had a home listed in the coor post ad every week and I almost never received a call from this ad. On the other hand, I receive lots of calls from my listings on the internet.

The main purpose for the Ads in my opinion was to show them to sellers and make them feel good. This is with out a doubt what I used the color Ads for. My sellers loved to see them and they felt that they were getting a service that other companies in our area did not offer. I will greatly miss these ads and I feel that it will hurt my listing presentation, but I do understand why our industry is moving away from these incredibly expensive print ads that are exposed to less and less people, and are less and less effective.

 

 

 

Please visit me at http://www.stlouisliving.net/

Chuck Deiss
Re/max Results - Arnold, MO

Karen - I have had good luck with postcards. I think that the most important factor is repeated mailing. I think you would have had better luck mailing to 1000 people 5 times, or even 500 people 10 times. I get most of business from expired listings. I send an initial letter and then follow up with 12 postcards over the next 6 weeks. I use a bright yellow card stock for all of the postcards. For every 100 prospects I use this with I normally get 10 to 20 calls and out of those 5 to 10 listings.

Mar 29, 2007 11:33 AM
Chuck Deiss
Re/max Results - Arnold, MO
Heather - That is great, I know lots of people in their late fifties on up that have never used the internet. many of those people will be selling homes either to downsize or to move closer to other family. We ARE hurting ourselves if we reduce print advertising too much in favor of the internet.
Mar 29, 2007 11:44 AM
Sharon Simms
Coastal Properties Group International - Christie's International - Saint Petersburg, FL
St. Petersburg FL - CRS CIPS CLHMS RSPS
While Sellers DO like to see their home in print, most of them do recognize statistics. If you keep track of where your calls and inquiries come from, it's easy for them to see why you want to switch your advertising from print to the Internet. Just have facts to back it up. We tell our Sellers from the first marketing presentation that  we're NOT advertising in the newspaper or the real estate magazines and that we ARE exposing their property heavily on the Internet, and why.
Mar 29, 2007 12:17 PM
John Novak
Keller Williams Realty The Marketplace - Las Vegas, NV
Henderson, Las Vegas and Summerlin Real Estate
Our team was just discussing this issue a couple of weeks ago. Print advertising for specific homes is definitely on the decline. Rather than taking multiple pages to show all of our listings, we've moved featuring just a few and then prominently saying "Visit us online to see other great homes".
Mar 29, 2007 12:19 PM
Jen Walker
Realty Executives of Mid Missouri - Jefferson City, MO
Jefferson City, MO Real Estate

Chuck,

I've had success when I show sellers NAR stats of how many consumers look for homes online vs. compared to how many look in the paper, etc. Usually (not always) they are receptive and understand that alot of print ads are wasted money. 

Mar 29, 2007 01:29 PM
Tim Maitski
Atlanta Communities Real Estate Brokerage - Atlanta, GA
Truth, Excellence and a Good Deal

If something doesn't show results, why keep doing it?  If buyers stopped going to open houses, would you still waste time doing them just because sellers think it's still worthwhile and other agents refuse to give up on a dead strategy. 

Is a doctor going to prescribe a medicine just because the patient heard about it on a TV ad?  Ah, never mind. :)

Mar 29, 2007 01:45 PM
Tim Tanz
Platinum Realty - Saint Louis, MO
St Louis Real Estate

I feel advertising in the newspapers is a waste of money.  And it's so very expensive for what you receive back.  My last "Picture Perfect' ad in the post cost me $152, and that was a discounted rate.  It did have a pic of the house and ran on Friday and Sunday.  I used them to advertise my open houses.  Not one phone call resulted from them.  Also, the reqular classifieds are very expensive for what little comes from them.  Our office does use the STL Today website.  I usually used print advertising to appease the sellers, but I am learning that I have to educate them to the fact that the odds are very slim that there home will sell because I've advertised it in the paper.  Cooperating with other realtors, and getting them to show the home is what is going to sell the home.  Having it priced correctly is imperative.

 

Mar 29, 2007 01:46 PM
Scott Gormley
Oak Valley Mortgage-California Home Loans and Refinancing - Chico, CA

I like writing articles in the newspaper...Content for them and free for me :)

Scott

Mar 29, 2007 03:11 PM
Travis Chatwin
Aaron Roth Real Estate - Solana Beach, CA
Your San Diego Real Estate Resource

I agree with some of the responses that have been made.  I have spent a lot of money on print with not much success.  I look forward to the internet for coverage more so this year than ever!

I just think there are not too many people taking the print that seriously anymore though is does make good reading in the bathroom!

HA
Travis

Mar 29, 2007 04:08 PM
Irina Netchaev
Pasadena Views Real Estate Team, Inc. - Pasadena, CA
Pasadena CA Real Estate

Dan, I think the point is that CB takes a franchise fee and a split from every sale you make.  They justified doing that by offering to do MORE for their agents like Newspaper advertising and other advertising plus stationary, etc.

I used to be with Prudential John Aaroe which had the same philosophy.  Take a piece ($) of everything I sell and provide the additional support, advertising dollars, etc.

As the market is getting tougher, these companies are cutting back where they can.  They do NOT however consider offering their agents more commissions.

You might want to check into other alternatives like Keller Williams (I am prejudiced - just love the company) where you get to make the decisions on how to spend your marketing dollars.

Good luck!

Irina, Pasadena CA

Mar 29, 2007 05:10 PM
Harper Team
J Rockcliff Realtors - San Ramon, CA
Mar 29, 2007 05:52 PM
Daniel Lowery
1st Choice Real Estate - Jefferson City, MO
e-PRO, Broker - Owner
Chuck Thanks for posting, this post pretty much answered my question I had on print ads, Thanks
Mar 29, 2007 06:08 PM
Anonymous
Scott & Barbara Bullard
Great post.  We had also felt that advertising in the local paper was more for the benefit of the seller and future lising prospects.  However, our feelings have changed.  We have a top quality webiste that allows prospects to search for homes online with access to the entire MLS database of ALL homes listed by every company.  When we advertise our listings in the paper, we include the mls number and our website address.  While we do not get very many calls from our ads, our website does recieve a great deal of increased traffic from the ad.  We have found that many prospective buyers will not call, but will go to our website to check out the listing.  Once they feel comfortable with our website, they will call us for more information.
Mar 29, 2007 06:11 PM
#36
Real Estate Guy in Madison, Wisconsin
Powered by: Real Broker LLC - Madison, WI
Real Estate Guy

We had a great seminar about this today.

 The NAR Stat is that 80% of buyers start their search on the Internet.

 

So I tell sellers that I spend 80% of my marketing dollars driving prospects to my sites. 

 

Since doing this I have had no complaints from my sellers and my paper ad bill is down considerably.

 

 

Mar 29, 2007 06:18 PM
Byron Lewis
Landmark Real Estate - Manhattan, KS
Realtor, e-PRO, ABR, CRS, Manhattan Kansas Real Es
Great post.  The only reason we still invest as large of portion of advertising to print is because our competitors do. We too, rarely receive buyer leads from printed advertising.  However, in almost every listing interview the seller asks about our printed advertising.  Sellers also look at local printed advertising before contacting agencies for possibly listing.  We usually have no problem convincing a seller to list with a presentation of marketing strategy but those printed ads are deemed important enough in most sellers minds that they will not approach you if you do not have a high presence in print.  I guess you chuck it up to self promotion and not listing promotion.
Mar 29, 2007 07:26 PM
Rusty Armstrong
ERA Henley Real Estate - Little Rock, AR
I agree completely. Talk to buyers the go the the internet because there is much more information. Advertising is for Sellers that do not understand todays market. We must educate them on what is working in todays market.
Mar 30, 2007 03:15 AM
Craig Schiller
Trempealeau, WI

CHUCK...

I was in the PRINT advertising industry for YEARS... years ago before the net. I sure am glad I am out... because it is SO old school.

There are MANY alternatives that are MUCH more effective. ESPECIALLY for small business people.

Me

Mar 30, 2007 06:38 AM
Anthony Carollo
Carollo Real Estate Inc. - Bayside, NY
Print Advertising is definetly important to sellers however it seems the Internet is now the place for most real estate advertising
Mar 30, 2007 09:02 AM
Craig Smith
Re/Max Achievers - Frederick, MD
Frederick MD Real Estate

Occasionally yes. I try not to spend more than 10-20% of my advertising budget on print ads. I rarely get calls off them but feel the need to cater to buyers that don't use the internet (for example my parents). I also do it to please my sellers.

Hopefully one day soon I can eliminate all my print ads. 

Mar 30, 2007 09:27 AM
Ryan Hukill - Edmond
405home @ ERA Courtyard - Edmond, OK
Realtor, Team Lead
Chuck, I liken print advertising to Open Houses. They still serve a purpose but that purpose isn't to actually sell the house. It's more to satisfy the seller and help us pick up other buyers. While online advertising is what's getting the results, there are still those old-schoolers out there who read the print advertising and have nothing to do with online ads. OHs don't usually sell the house I may be showing, but they do help the sellers feel good and they help me get in front of more buyers & sellers. Print ads do the same thing. They don't usually sell the house I'm advertising but they help get my face in front of more people and help the sellers feel better about the process.
Mar 30, 2007 04:55 PM