Central Florida commuter rail - traffic solution or giant boondoggle?

Real Estate Agent with Sand Dollar Realty Group, Inc. BK627826

Commuter rail has been big talk around Orlando and Central Florida for several years.  Last year the Florida legislature came so close to approving the rail-line, but things broke down because the attorneys wouldn't tolerate giving CSX Transportation limited liability.  That's actually pretty bizarre considering the Tri-Rail in South Florida and most other similar projects around the country have this limited liability language as standard boiler plate contract language.  After all why would CSX be motivated to sell and leaseback their own rail-line if they didn't have this language built into the lease???  


Regardless, this is my big question "Is commuter rail really all it is cracked up to be?"  I certainly realize that in big cities like New York and Washington as well as many other countries that traveling by train is very commonplace.  The big difference between those places and Orlando is that here you can't put the trains underground because of the high water table.  So you end up with a main train line on existing train tracks above ground.  Tracks that have been in place since the day of the Florida cowboy (late 1800's) and don't necessarily represent existing traffic patterns that well.  Granted that much of the train tracks do partially mirror the Interstate-4 corridor, but that is about all.

In places like Deland, Sanford, Lake Mary, Altamonte Springs, and Orlando south of downtown the tracks get pretty far off of the main traffic corridor and do not pass through the main business or population areas of those cities.  Another big question is, "How do the people get from their homes to the train tracks?"  I've heard things like build big parking garages around the tracks - which still puts tons of cars of the road and costs additional hundreds of millions of dollars and thus may never get built.  I've also heard of building spur tracks which also costs additional hundreds of million of dollars and will cause existing businesses to get bulldozed to make way for new tracks.  The third is increasing bus lines to the tracks, but bus service has always been extremely unpopular in the Orlando area and I don't see that changing anytime soon.

So what is the answer to that question of how to get people to the actual rail stations?  I don't know.

The other $64 question is "Will it really reduce traffic and save infrastructure costs?"  The Tri-Rail line located on the CSX tracks in South Florida runs through Palm Beach, Broward, and Miami-Dade County and has been in existence since the 1980's.  It has been a huge money pit for the South Florida area for 20+ years now.  South Florida has 2 major limited access highways that run north to south through it, Interstate-95 and the Florida Turnpike and both of those roads are still jammed with cars every day.  So the Tri Rail only has had limited impact on traffic even though I am sure there are plenty of riders now-a-days with the way the economy has gotten. Some people even called the Tri-Rail expansion a big boondoggle.

I know that commuter rail is definitely a wiser idea than putting more cars on the road, but I don't know if it is truly the answer to the traffic problems of Central Florida.  It will probably never make a profit in my lifetime, but maybe it isn't supposed to.  The money to buy the tracks supposedly has all been set aside by the State of Florida and federal government.  I think it is only a matter of "when" and not "if" commuter rail will come to Central Florida.  Hopefully something good will come of it, and it won't be another giant money boondoggle for the metro Orlando area.

Here are some links on the topic.  Official commuter rail website.         Orlando Sentinel story. 


(Copyright © 2008. Sand Dollar Realty Group, Inc. All rights reserved.)   Subscribe to my blog via RSS feed.

Rob Arnold - Your full service and investor friendly Realtor ® in Orlando and Central Florida.

ABR, CPL, CRB, CSP, GRI, Managing real estate broker, Notary Public

407-389-7318 / 1-877-389-7318 www.SDRhouses.com/ We Buy Houses Florida

We sell foreclosures, short sales, and bank owned REO properties throughout Central Florida. We sell and list Central Florida real estate and Orlando real estate. Free list of foreclosure and short sale houses available.

I also provide flat fee MLS listings, For Sale By Owner, and menu-based services in most parts of Central & South Florida, the Space Coast, and the Treasure Coast including Orlando, Winter Park, Maitland, Ocoee, Winter Garden, Apopka, Altamonte Springs, Casselberry, Longwood, Winter Springs, Oviedo, Lake Mary, Sanford, Deltona, Debary, Deland, Mount Dora, Eustis, Clermont, Kissimmee, Winter Haven, Lakeland, Tampa, Sarasota, Bradenton, Miami-Dade, Fort Lauderdale, West Palm Beach, Port Saint Lucie, Melbourne, Daytona Beach, Ocala, Gainesville, Volusia, Brevard, and more.   



This entry hasn't been re-blogged:

Re-Blogged By Re-Blogged At
Orlando Real Estate
Central Florida
Seminole County Florida
University Of Central Florida Knights Active Rainers
Seminole County Florida Pros
orlando commuter rail
central florida commuter rail
orlando traffic

Post a Comment
Spam prevention
Spam prevention
Show All Comments
Heather the Realtor Orlando, Lake Mary
LemonTree Realty - Orlando, FL
First Time Home Buyers, Bank Owned Homes

I think in order for them to have done it right it doesnt need to ride on already exsiting tracks. I think the only place that benefits is downtown O and winter park. But if they built new rails like disney monorails that would work a little better, but Im sure costs too much. If we have more buses or trolleys that picked up from the train stations say in Lake Mary that then made frequent round trip stops through major points of the area that may work.

Dec 17, 2008 10:55 PM #1
Russel Ray, San Diego Business & Marketing Consultant & Photographer
Russel Ray - San Diego State University, CA

Actually, Rob, you can put the trains underground even with a high water table. One needs only look at New York, San Francisco, and the "Chunnel" connecting England to France.

Since we have traffic problems, as well as dependence on oil and gas from foreign countries, the best thing we can do is invest in high-volume mass transit. It might be more expensive to build high-volume mass transit, but the benefits to the nation are much better than building 30-lane highways all over the place so people can continue to drive their high-polluting SUVs and give our money to the foreign oil countries.

Where there's a will, there's a way.

Dec 18, 2008 08:45 PM #2
Dine Nearby
DineNearby.com - Lake Mary, FL
Printable Restaurant Coupons

Boondoggle!  I don't see most people using it.  If I must drive to get the train, get to downtown Orlando and take a taxi to my office because it is 2 miles from the train stop, what is the point?  (I know, I could walk, but I'm lazy!) I just spent more money and time than I would have if I drove, even in our horriffic traffic.

Think Central Florida's version of "The Big Dig".

Apr 07, 2009 03:42 AM #3
Steve Edmonds
WE Home Inspections, Inc. - Serving Oviedo & Central FL - Oviedo, FL


I appreciate your concern for the environment, but one of the unfortunate facts of the big rail discussion that gets left out is that a majority of new track that will have to be built will need to go through protected areas to provide a contiguous line.  The concept of mass transit has never fully taken hold for Florida.  That is one of the things most people want to leave behind in the "big cities".  There used to be a proposal that was going to be a monorail that used bio fuels and of course was to be designed and partially funded (investment for profit) by Disney.  It died early in the debate over a decade ago.  Unfortunately, it was IMO the best solution all the way around.

WE Home Inspections, Inc.

Apr 15, 2009 05:52 AM #4
James "Jim" Vitale
Mighty Realty - Apopka, FL

If you build it they will come!  I just wonder how long it will take for people who have never used mass transit to come around and utilize the rail system.  It might be 20 years or more from now but eventually we will need it as we continue to grow.

Aug 03, 2009 08:13 AM #5
Post a Comment
Spam prevention
Show All Comments

What's the reason you're reporting this blog entry?

Are you sure you want to report this blog entry as spam?


Rob Arnold

Metro Orlando Full Service - Investor Friendly & F
Ask me a question
Spam prevention

Additional Information