"We Don't Need Gutters"

By
Home Inspector with Safe@Home Inspections, LLC in SE Washington 215

In addition to being a home inspector, I am also an infrared thermographer - the two don't always meet in the middle - and I have been keeping busy checking on wet basements for the last two weeks.

As many of you know, the Pacific Northwest has been getting hammered by snow.  That has caused all sorts of hazards on the roads and roof collapses and several deaths - one when the snow on a roof slide off and buried an elderly lady on her sidewalk.

But what you may not know is that we also had a brief warming trend, leading to flooding in ours waterways and streets.  Much of this water made it into homes as well with the usual results in wall and flooring damage, potential health hazards and additional expenses right when homeowners can least afford them.

After doing several houses, a theme emerged.  Now I'm going to digress for a second: the Inland Northwest is much drier than the coastal regions.  so much so, that when I did insurance inspections for Allstate, I actually received enormous criticism for writing up homes for a lack of gutters.

It seems that in dry regions, people consider gutters optional especially on older homes.

It is these same houses that are having major flooding issues.  Normally there are many homes in Moscow and Pullman that have dampness in the basement.  For years, I've encouraged homeowners to get a good drainage system installed. 

Sometimes, they listen.

The problem is simple.  The roof acts as a huge rain collector of several thousand square feet.  When it leaves the edge of the roof, it consolidates into a ribbon several inches wide.  In other words, an inch of rain on the roof could resemble a foot (or more) of rain flooding the foundational area of the home.

So when I have clients question the value of gutters (and keeping them clean - see Steven L Smith's post here), I take them through the process until they understand.

It's not a matter of how much rain hits our region; it's what happens when it does.

 

Comments (5)

Frank Torre
Torre Inspection Service, LLC 888-202-8869 - Hicksville, NY

Hi Paul, great post I ran into a gutter problem at a house the other day take a look at the following pictures.

 

 

Jan 21, 2009 01:44 PM
Paul Duffau
Safe@Home Inspections, LLC in SE Washington - Asotin, WA
Caring for People, Educating about Homes

It's that third picture that just kills me.  Bare copper on the exterior.  Please tell me it was turned off inside.  Looks like the deck is toenailed too.

Have you been borrowing builders from Idaho?

That iceberg might not thaw until July.

BTW, had to look up Hicksville on the map.  Don't think you have too many hicks there. :)

Jan 21, 2009 04:07 PM
Frank Torre
Torre Inspection Service, LLC 888-202-8869 - Hicksville, NY

There are thousands of us hicks living in Hicksville NY, I could not find any turn off inside the house for the water. The decks at the house have a lot of problem with poor construction techniques that were used.

Jan 21, 2009 11:22 PM
Jay Markanich
Jay Markanich Real Estate Inspections, LLC - Bristow, VA
Home Inspector - servicing all Northern Virginia

Great post Paul.  Gutters are just as essential to house health as grading and swales, even in dry areas.

Frank - yummie!  That third one looks like a home-owner addition so "she who rules" can have convenient water for deck plants.  No shut off?  It hasn't frozen and taught them a lesson yet?

Jan 22, 2009 12:30 AM
Jim Mushinsky
Centsable Inspection - Framingham, MA

Roof Drainage Systems are important, gotta get that water away from the foundation.  Personally, I prefer no gutters, a hard surface on the ground at the edge of the roof line, and grading to guide the water away from the foundation.  I don't like downspout erosion nor the gutter full of ice in the winter.

Jan 27, 2009 03:43 AM

What's the reason you're reporting this blog entry?

Are you sure you want to report this blog entry as spam?