Special offer

Are We the Same Person All Our Lives, from Birth to Death?

By
Real Estate Broker/Owner with Dreamcatcher Realty / Greater Phoenix Area

seagulls - randy hooker - wonderingsFor those of you that know me, you'll recognize this as yet another of my 'wonderings'. For those of you that just stumbled across my blog, you will most likely enjoy this next article or you'll quickly judge me as being just another wacko on the internet.  Either way, all is well!   ;-)

The human population on our planet is predisposed to labeling each other with a “name.” Historically, it's for identification of the individual. For most of us, however, I suspect that it is simply a dominant cultural expectation that once assigned our “name,” it's to be used, honored, protected and defended.

An exception to this practice has been in the situation of marriage, wherein many cultures expect the wife to ‘assume’ the last/family name of her new husband. And there are at least a couple of cultures wherein the husband also assumes the last/family name of his new wife. And of course, in recent times we’ve seen more and more of the hyphenating of those names to create a hybrid dual-family name.

Another fairly commonly known and accepted exception to the practice is in “witness protection programs.” In those situations, the hiding person(s) are assigned entirely new names. And with this example, I will attempt to begin to make my point. Not only are such persons given new labels/names, they are forced to take on entirely new identities and completely new lives ~ all of which starts with a name change.

Most people seem to feel that such a taking on of a new identity/life is extreme, if not tragic, and something that should be done only in extreme circumstances. And yet, if that’s the case, then why is it that a spouse is expected to take on a new name when married? I wonder if it is not because ‘marriage’ has traditionally been one of life’s “changes” in which the individual’s role in life significantly changes.

whats in a name - randy hookerIn other words, isn’t it that we tend to accept that with a name change comes changes in choices, decisions, ideas, lifestyles, homes, environments, careers, families, education, religion and even culture? As such, then I’m also wondering about the possible advantages of a new model of naming.

For instance, if at the hypothetical age of 6 months, the parents of a child were to choose a ‘second’ name for their kid ~ a baby-name, if you will, that more accurately “fits” the personality and behavior of their 6-month-old. An example might be that the proud parents of a new baby girl named their tiny little 7-lb angel, at birth, “Mackenzie.” But as most parents could testify, the personality and behavior of an infant radically changes by the time s/he is 6 months old. My contention ~ why not assign that little person a new name?

In our example, what might happen if their little girl ~ who I would contend is NOT the same person as she was at the age of 2 days ~ were assigned a new name? I would wonder if in so-doing the parents of that kid might be invited to accept and perceive their child as a different person, complete with a different set of “allowable” behaviors, personality expressions, expectations, etc., etc., starting with changing her name, for example, to "Z"?

Continuing on with my hypothesis, what would happen then if the parents not only allowed and accepted but encouraged their little girl to “be” a new little butterfly at the age of 5 or 6, starting with ~ you guessed it ~ her name? But this time, rather than assigning her name to her, what if ";Z"; was given the opportunity to choose her own name?? So then, ";Z"; is gone, but ";Jessica"; appears on the scene. Get the picture?

The toughest philosophical question might be ~ is "Jessica" the same person as "Z" or "Mackenzie"? My contention is “No!” she is not. And not only is she not the same person, it’s good, right and acceptable that she is a work in progress with incredible opportunity and potential to “be” any number of “new butterflies” during her lifetime on this planet.

Adolescent age(s) is/are arguably other opportunities for new names, and identities, but let’s fast–forward a bit. "Jessica" has now graduated from High School and is “moving toward her future.” But by this time, she has become wise to the succession of names/butterflies/identities ~ so "Jessica" now becomes "Jesse-Livingston-Seagull" and decides she wants to fly with the wind! Choosing her own name, she also sets off on the flight of choosing her next set of behaviors, educational experiences, career, partner, goals and ambitions. With a little luck, encouragement and perseverance, maybe "Jesse-Livingston-Seagull" will actually fly thru the mountain. Maybe she won’t. Either way, she still gets to live the life of "Jesse-Livingston-Seagull".

Next question ~ has she now grown up and must now conform to the demands by the rest of us and forego her desire to BE "Jesse-Livingston-Seagull"? Our culture would be screaming at her and doing everything within its power to get "Jesse" to “think of her future” and make plans that will determine the course of her life for the rest of her life.

hello - randy hooker

But now it’s too late, for "Jesse-Livingston-Seagull" has learned to fly! And now she determines that her name is to be "Princess Jessica Mackenzie Seagull Z", complete with self-acceptance for her new choices, adventures, challenges, failures, disappointments and successes ~ but mostly an awareness that life is at the moment, in the moment, and if at any given moment ~ in the blink of an eye ~ she wants to become a new butterfly, or even a part of a butterfly that she once used to BE, she can actually choose a new name/life and BE that person!

So, are we indeed the same person all of our lives, from birth to death? Each of us has to decide. But since this is my wondering (or what some people may call delusion or heresy), I choose to believe that any ‘person’ is in reality a series of persons, connected only by a physical being we call a biological life. How many lives/names have you already lived? How many more will you live before you pass? What’s in your name? Life… I wish you well in the pursuit of your new name(s).

 

 

Randy-Livingston-Seagull  :)

 

Randy Hooker

Jen Olson
First Weber Group Realtors - Marshfield, WI

Randy,

Since I love quotes, here's one I have at my desk that I think is fitting.  " Happiness is the pursuit of a lifetime.  It is never too late to become who we wish to be."

Thanks for sharing!

Jan 31, 2009 08:37 AM
Randy Hooker
Dreamcatcher Realty / Greater Phoenix Area - Gilbert, AZ
Gilbert, Chandler, Mesa, Queen Creek

Hey Jen ~ I totally LOVE that quote!  THank YOU for sharing.   :)

Randy Hooker

Jan 31, 2009 08:48 AM
Michael Murphy
Bienvenidos Real Estate - Parksville, BC

Hi Randy,

I believe we continually evolve, change and grow if we choose to or we can be a drunk or a drug addict or someone who stays stuck in a unhappy situation. We have the power to choose. People are always reinventing themselves and trying to morph into someone new. I believe we basically stay the same but we can give up bad habits and we can improve and create good new habits. We decide. Good luck on your journey.

Jan 31, 2009 08:53 AM
Jen Olson
First Weber Group Realtors - Marshfield, WI

Michael is so right!  We have the power and the given ability to choose and change!

Jan 31, 2009 09:23 AM
Myrl Jeffcoat
Sacramento, CA
Greater Sacramento Realtor - Retired

We change and evolve because we are the sum total of our experiences!

Jan 31, 2009 10:01 AM
Randy Hooker
Dreamcatcher Realty / Greater Phoenix Area - Gilbert, AZ
Gilbert, Chandler, Mesa, Queen Creek

Michael ~ So like a caterpillar 'morphs' into a butterfly, you believe we, too, can become a new butterfly?  See, even the butterfly gets a new name - I never saw anybody say, "Wow, look at that beautiful caterpillar flying from plant to plant!"   ;-)

Jen ~ So it's all about making the right choices?   :)

Myrl ~ So we are the same, but different?  Is that kinda like adding lemon and sugar to water,and becoming lemonade?

I wish you all the best in your journeys, too!

Randy Hooker

 

Jan 31, 2009 10:46 AM
Vicki Burton
Southport Realty-Southport, North Carolina - Southport, NC
A local Buyer's Agent - Southport NC Real Estate

Hi Randy, interesting blog. My name is Vicki...short for Victoria (my great grandmother) I've never felt much like a Vicki...randomly people have told me numerous times in my life that I don't look like a Vicki...whatever that means. My Mom says she wanted to call me Tori but my older brother and sister thought it was dumb. Would I have turned out differently if my name was Tori? Or any other name. Maybe... It's at least food for thought! I'd have to think about what I would change my name to if I could.

Jan 31, 2009 02:36 PM
Randy Hooker
Dreamcatcher Realty / Greater Phoenix Area - Gilbert, AZ
Gilbert, Chandler, Mesa, Queen Creek

Hey Vicki a/k/a Victoria a/k/a Tori ~ Believe it or not, I've heard that a lot in my life - from folks who felt like they had the wrong name.  And it's interesting that as I read your comment, and your names, each of them elicited a different response from within me.  And I'll confess that I also immediately went to your profile to see your photo.  Victoria doesn't fit; neither does Vicki.  Tori might work, with a stretch.  Have you ever considerd the name Emily?  Or Mary?  Or Nancy?  I know... I'm one weird dude.  No matter what name you choose, I wish you nothing but the greatest of happiness!  And thanks for stopping by!!   :)

Randy Hooker

Jan 31, 2009 04:47 PM
Jen Olson
First Weber Group Realtors - Marshfield, WI

Randy,

Maybe not always making the right choices, because sometimes those not so right choices are a big part of who we are today. (Not that I have any personal experience in making a not so great choice!:) )  It's about always having the ability and the choice to do and be whomever we want.  It's never too late as long as we can take in a breath, right?  Wow, some deep thinking you have made me do!  Thanks for the post! 

Feb 01, 2009 06:48 AM
Randy Hooker
Dreamcatcher Realty / Greater Phoenix Area - Gilbert, AZ
Gilbert, Chandler, Mesa, Queen Creek

Hey Jen... My pleasure!  As the Bicentennial Man would have said, "One is glad to be of service."  ;-)   Seriously, thanks for accepting my invitation to do a little 'deep thinking' about who you are.  Have a wonderful journey!   :)

Randy Hooker

Feb 01, 2009 07:50 AM
Not a real person
San Diego, CA

A direct answer is a definitive NO! I'm an individual and I developed individually outside of the brainwashing that schools and religions tried to force upon me. I was a rebel. Still am. My wise old grandmother adopted me when I was 10 and gave me the love AND discipline that all children need. When she died in 2003, my uncles "disinvited" me to the funeral. Now stupid me never knew that one had to have an invitation to a funeral. I decided that if they didn't need me, I didn't need them. So I shortened my name, legally, from Russel Ray Kirk to just Russel Ray to give me a complete break from them.

As the self-help author Louis Hay wrote (loosely quoted): "You can't choose which family you are born into, but you can certainly choose which family is in your life."

Feb 03, 2009 12:17 AM
Randy Hooker
Dreamcatcher Realty / Greater Phoenix Area - Gilbert, AZ
Gilbert, Chandler, Mesa, Queen Creek

Zoweeeeeee, Russel!  You're my PERFECT example!  And I gotta tell ya, I absolutely LOVE it that you actually changed your name.  I'm sure it was a difficult, if not painful experience for you; but you had the guts to go for it.  Also, I'm actually familiar with Louise Hay, and that's a GREAT quote!  But it definitely slaps the dominant cultural story right in the face.  Thanks for reading, Russel, and for self-disclosing your story.   :)

Randy Hooker

Feb 03, 2009 03:38 AM
Anonymous
no

no

Oct 22, 2018 04:36 AM
#13