Michelle L. Mayo, ABR, SRES (RE/MAX on the Bay)

61 Pennsylvania Ave.

Niantic , CT 06357

Spam prevention

Helping homebuyers and home sellers, one house at a time. Southeastern Connecticut, New London County, East Lyme, Niantic, Waterford, New London, Groton, Uncasville, Ledyard

Get to know Michelle L. Mayo



Welcome to the shoreline! My name is Michelle L. Mayo, and I’ve been helping buyers and sellers in southeastern Connecticut since 2009. My career background includes working as a real estate paralegal, property manager and a relocation director for a national real estate company. Altogether, I’ve been working in the real estate industry for about 15 years!

My passion is helping people, and this is why I became specialized as an Accredited Buyer’s Representative® , Sellers Representative Specialist and as a Seniors Real Estate Specialist®. These are professional designations I earned so that I could provide extra counseling and guidance to first-time homebuyers and senior clients. I am also proud to be certified as a Military Relocation Professional®.

I am an experienced real estate advisor and negotiator who will take the time to truly listen to your needs. I will always provide you with excellent service and information, so that you can make the best real estate decisions. When you want friendly, expert real estate advice for the Connecticut shoreline, I’m your girl!

As a lifelong resident of the Waterford and East Lyme shoreline, I love the beaches and boardwalks along the Connecticut shoreline.  I enjoy showing off our charming communities and villages.  Come for the summer, and you’ll stay for a lifetime!

Michelle L. Mayo's Blog Posts


Areas of Specialty: Residential Homes First Time Homebuyers - If you can afford to rent, you can afford to buy! Distressed Homeowners Short Sales Active Adult Communities  Shoreline, Waterfront, Vacation Homes Military Relocation Rentals



Accredited Buyers Rep. (ABR)

Sellers Real Estate Specialist (SRS)

Seniors Real Estate Specialist (SRES)

Certified Distressed Property Expert (CDPE)

Military Relocation Specialist.

Member of the National Association of Realtors

Member of the Connecticut Association of Realtors Member of the Eastern Connecticut Association of Realtors


2014, 2015, 2016 & 2017 Connecticut Magazine Five Star Agent

Eastern CT Association Of Realtors Circle of Excellence Award Recipient

Testimonials for Michelle L. Mayo

  • Kayla Pfrommer

    Michelle was fantastic!! My boyfriend and I purchased our first house with the help of Michelle. As it was our first home purchase, naturally we had a lot of questions. We first met Michelle at an open house and she was so helpful even before we signed on with her as our realtor - she sold us! As our realtor, Michelle sent us suggestions for houses based on what she knew we were looking for. She was SUPER responsive and would email, text, or call back not only the same day, but within the hour. She was very knowledgable and helpful at showings, and once we found the house we wanted, she worked hard to help us get the best deal possible. Michelle was on top of everything, whether it was suggesting properties, negotiating with the seller's realtor, or communicating with our lender and attorney to keep everything on schedule for closing. I would absolutely recommend Michelle!

  • Christine Greico

    I would highly recommend Michelle to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. She is very knowledgeable and is quick to respond to any questions or concerns that come up during the process. She definitely makes you feel like you are the only client that she is working with even though she had many others at the time!

  • Leslie Mast

    Quite simply, Michelle is the best! We were long distance sellers and would have had a very difficult time managing all of the details - of which there were many - without Michelle's help and expertise. She ALWAYS got back to us very promptly when we had questions and gave us status reports and updates on a regular basis. She has a lovely professional demeanor and a fun sense of humor that made the entire selling process positive throughout. Michelle sold our house in just 4 days! I would highly recommend Michelle to anyone looking to buy or sell their home; she is the best realtor with whom I have worked in over 40 years!

  • Jeremy & Mallory Doyle

    Michelle was wonderful to work with! I can't compliment her enough, from her knowledge of the local area to her excellent, punctual communication. She kept our expectations within reason and helped to keep our spirits up when we thought we'd missed opportunities. She was very patient with us, and explained everything involved in the process very clearly. Michelle helped us find a tenant for our rental property while finding a new place for our growing family to call home. She even helped take care of our 6 month old daughter while we toured houses together! When looking for an agent on Zillow, Michelle really stood out because of all the positive reviews, and now I know why: she's a true professional, and always made us feel like we were her sole clients. Michelle, thank you for helping us find a wonderful house!

  • Jacob Dennis

    Michelle was simply amazing! This was my first time buying a property and I couldn't have asked for a better agent. She was available to immediately respond to every call text and email. She knew information regarding the market, the seller, and really took the time to get on a personal level with me and understand me as well as my needs and wants. I love my home and I knew everything I was getting into prior to closing. She also had information and references in regards to real estate attorneys and home inspectors. There is not a doubt in my mind that should I ever buy or sell a property again that I would choose her.

    Service Areas (7)
    • Niantic, CT
    • Niantic, CT
    • East Lyme, CT
    • Gales Ferry, CT
    • Ledyard, CT
    • Groton, CT
    • New London, CT
    • Old Lyme, CT
    Specialties (10)
    • Buyers
    • Condos/Townhomes
    • Military Relocation
    • Property Management
    • Relocation
    • Renters
    • Residential
    • Sellers
    • Seniors
    • Short Sales
    Languages (1)
    • English