Has Google Just Nullified Our Copyrights?

Real Estate Agent with Florida Property Experts

googleThis post contains what could be a blogger's worst nightmare. If you've never paid any attention to Google's business tactics, this post will give you the briefest, yet easieast synopsis of the Google giant, and just may scare the pants off you. (Please put them back on as soon as possible.)

I don't know how many of you have previously heard about Google's 2002, attempted launch of it's venture called "Book Search". Basically, Google wanted to create a huge online library of sorts. But this plan led them to one huge roadblock: thousands, if not millions of copyrights, for which Google would have to pay tens of millions of dollars, for the rights to scan/digitize every book into their "Book Search".

Well, during the last 6 years, while the copyright battle has continued to wage between Google and the publishing houses, all along, Google has continued to scan/digitize these copyrighted materials, long before any resolution was reached. But just last week Google finally decided to settle on this massive copyright copyright case, by agreeing to pay astronomical amounts of money to the publishers. Sounds like a win for the publishers, right? Read the details more closely!

Now many of you may have seen in my comments, how frequently I mention my dislike of Google. Not the products, but the conglomerate and their "bully" tactics. Before I continue with my copyright post, here's a bit more Google history...

  • To my knowledge, only one other time, has Google actually backed down from a battle (sort of). That occurrence happened when Google tried to force eBay to use "Google Checkout"; when eBay already had it's own payment plan, Paypal, and refused to comply with Google.(Yay!) Fortunately, eBay and Paypal had the money to stand toe-to-toe against Google. So in a truly petty fashion, Google then decided to have a little party in Boston that just happened to be during the same week of the annual eBay Live user conference, when the eBay "power sellers" get to rub elbows with the powers-that-be at eBay. But the real clincher was the shuttle service that Google was offering, to bring eBay's power sellers from the eBay party, to Google's party, where they could introduce "Checkout" to them. So  eBay's counterstrike was to pull ALL of their ads from Google! (I loved it!) This was a truly shocking move, since Google relies heavily on it's "AdWords" and "AdSense" revenue. And they've done their job at convincing many people that they can't survive without paying the Google monster. But eBay's final move did the trick. Google quietly cancelen their party. And eBay eventually began advertising on Google again, but on a much smaller scale. And interestingly enough, eBay lost very little revenue during the boycott! (Hah!) However, Google still launched one more bomb against eBay, with their "programmable search", which WE have all been using for over a year now! (And as usual, all the internet users care about is the convenience of the Google products.)eBay

Now back to the topic at hand. When you look beyond the surface, and consider the long-term ramifications of Googles' "copyright settlement", and the continued digitization (Is that a word?) of millions of books, I wonder if we may eventually, all be at risk of losing the rights to our automatically copyrighted works. After all, if we wrote it, we own it, right? I'm not so sure. It looks to me like Google has back-doored us, and changed the laws as we know them. As we continue to face an ongoing battle to stop the scum suckers who steal the hard work of others, has Google just laid the groundwork for laws to be changed? 

Read this article about Google's Alleged Settlement in the amount of tens of millions of dollars to the publishing houses that own the rights to the books that will now be digitized. Be sure you read all the way to the end. Then compare it to the results of the "programmable search" slam that they used on eBay.

Google has an alleged history of repeatedly stomping all over the rights of smaller companies, and even laws, by taking their battles all the way to the supreme court, while allegedly bleeding all the money out of their adversaries. (I personally see Google as a corporate giant that represents the stereotypical U.S. Conglomerate... read between the lines on that one.) It has always been my opinion that Google is a corporate bully. I don't deny that they have some excellent products. I use many of them myself. But I despise their tactics. Do your own homework on Google. They have great products, so of course nobody wants to think poorly of them, or make waves. But does the end justify the means? folderHow would you feel if you were up against them? With this copyright settlement, you very well may be!

OK. I'll stop my tangent now. Follow the links, then after reading the article(s), let me know if you think this settlement just drilled a huge hole in our own personal ownership of what we place online. I've seen many blog posts, expressing concern about losing their work to the owner of the platform to which they're posting. Before Active Rain was sold, there were MANY of these types of posts... all questioning if we owned our own works. And Active Rains repeatedly said that yes, our work is indeed our own!

Compared to Google, Active Rain is hardly a blip on their radar. (Let's just hope AR never gets large enough to find themselves in Google's cross-hairs.) But aside from that, what if Google suddenly decided to take your work and place it elsewhere, as part of a huge compilation/blog database, or whatever they think of next? Could... or Would you even pay the first attorney's fee? And how many Google products do you use, thus feeding this corporate giant even more?

Here's a line from the first link in this post, about the Book Search settlement... "By settling the case, Google has made it much more difficult for others to compete with it's Book Search service." It sounds like Google had a lot of this planned, right from the beginning.

One last tidbit... Did you know that in Google's early days, their "statement" was... "Don't Be Evil". I'm not saying they are... I'll just let you read all the links I've found about Google and their business practices, (And you can find hundreds more) and let you draw your own conclusions. But as far as our own copyrighted materials go... in the face of Google's "copyright settlement", do you think your work is safely copyrighted? Or would you end up like so many of the publishers in the settlement, that can still say they own these copyrighted works, but have no real protection? At least the publishing houses received a settlement, (after 6 years) but I wonder if the settlement even covered their legal fees?


*P.S. I just received a very informative, yet long e-mail from someone who truly has the lowdown on Google. I'm going to ask for permission from this individual, to post some of his e-mail here. If you think what I posted is surprising, or if you don't think it's a big deal, you'll be truly shocked by what I know now! This goes WAY beyond what even I had ever imagined!

Lisa Hill real estate agent

Lisa Hill is a Daytona Beach Native, selling real estate in the Daytona Beach area. Contact Lisa Hill for all your real estate needs.

View Daytona Beach MLS Real Estate Listings

View Daytona Beach MLS Real Estate Listing Video Tours


Page copy protected against web site content infringement by Copyscape 


This entry hasn't been re-blogged:

Re-Blogged By Re-Blogged At
Real Estate Technology & Tools
Almost Anything Goes
Club Chaos
Dedicated Bloggers
Misfits, losers and loners
Tech Talk
copyright laws
book search
google sucks
lisa hill
daytona beach real estate agent

Spam prevention
Show All Comments
Elizabeth Nieves
The Elizabeth Nieves Realty Group - Durham, NC
Bilingual Raleigh - Durham North Carolina Real Estate Team

VERY INTERESTING! I feel like I've been hiding under a rock, because I was totally unaware of any of this. You are soooooo smart! I'm gonna read your links thoroughly. Inquiring minds want to know. And...I want to make sure that MY work is protected. GBU!

Nov 06, 2008 05:39 AM #1
Lisa Hill
Florida Property Experts - Daytona Beach, FL
Daytona Beach Real Estate

Elizabeth- There's a lot more than this! Most people choose to ignore my warnings about Google. But they have infiltrated and undermined much more than public wants to know about!

Nov 06, 2008 08:14 AM #2
Alexander Harb
Knights Investing - Mesquite, TX
Dallas, Texas Real Estate Investing

Google is just a SHADOW of what the end time government for this planet is going to be like...they "will tread down their adversaries....and stomp on what remains....."

If you think GOOGLE is BAD...just think about what this end time world wide government is going to be like.....

It is coming...as sure as we exist right now.....

BUT...AFTER that happens...THEN the RIGHTFUL owner is going to appear....hehehe!!


Nov 06, 2008 08:38 AM #3
Lisa Hill
Florida Property Experts - Daytona Beach, FL
Daytona Beach Real Estate

Don't hold back now Alex. Why don't you tell us what you really believe. =P

Nov 06, 2008 11:46 AM #4
Thesa Chambers
Fred Real Estate Group - Bend, OR
Principal Broker - Licensed in Oregon

wow that was a great lesson - I had no idea of most of the info you provided - thanks so much

Nov 06, 2008 12:04 PM #5
Alexander Harb
Knights Investing - Mesquite, TX
Dallas, Texas Real Estate Investing

I had no idea my comment would bring such a response from you, Lisa...did I offend you in some way?

If you want I will erase it....



Nov 06, 2008 01:06 PM #6
Connie Betz
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Ambassador Real Estate - Omaha, NE
Top Omaha Realtor - Omaha Homes for Sale

I had no idea! I've bookmarked this for when/if your friend allows you to share the email.

Nov 06, 2008 02:53 PM #7
Susie Blackmon
Ocala, FL
Ocala, Horses, Western Wear, Horse Farms, Marketing

Lisa, are you going to be in Orlando this weekend?? I'm here in Orlando wondering! I read this post but have to admit I have too many fish to fry to worry about what Google is going to do with my 'stuff.'  It's all out there already anyway!

Nov 06, 2008 08:40 PM #8
Lisa Hill
Florida Property Experts - Daytona Beach, FL
Daytona Beach Real Estate

Alex- You should know me better than that by now. (you're officially reprimanded). I was joking... hence the tongue sticking out at you at the end =P

Nov 07, 2008 03:35 PM #9
Lisa Hill
Florida Property Experts - Daytona Beach, FL
Daytona Beach Real Estate

Susie- I SOOo wanted to attend the gathering tonight! But we've had some major turmoil here this week, I'm exhausted, and my daughter, who attends college in Kissimmee (beside Orlando) will be home this weekend. I'm really bummed out, but it just couldn't be done =(

Nov 07, 2008 03:37 PM #10
Jeff Belonger
Social Media - Infinity Home Mortgage Company, Inc - Cherry Hill, NJ
The FHA Expert - FHA Loans - FHA mortgages - USDA loans - VA Loans

Lisa... I need to read more into this... but from what I am reading, this could be scary. But I need to get a better grasp on this... thanks for bringing this up.

jeff belonger

Nov 09, 2008 06:29 AM #11
Endre Barath, Jr.
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices - Beverly Hills, CA
Realtor - Los Angeles Home Sales 310.486.1002

Lisa, what a great post. I was totally unaware of this until I read your post. (Ironically I go by Google Headquarters in Santa Monica on my way to the Dentist for cleanings) I always wondered Why is there a big sign on the door that you have to ring the Doorbell to be buzzed in...don't yank on the door.BTW it is a clear glass and people can see in as well as out. They are the only corporation that keeps their doors locked.Paranoid maybe???With good reason I guess. Thank you next I will read your links.

p.s.>: we have the same slogan visit my website when you get a chance:))

Nov 10, 2008 04:27 PM #12
Lenn Harley
Lenn Harley, Homefinders.com, MD & VA Homes and Real Estate - Leesburg, VA
Real Estate Broker - Virginia & Maryland

Interesting perspective.  I disagree, but then. . . . while Google will benefit from the content, so will millions of others. 

Putting the best light possible on the digitizing of millions of books, Google is bringing access to these publications to many millions of people around the world that would otherwise not have a prayer of access. 

Google will continue to pay for access to these documents and the world will continue to receive and enjoy. 




Nov 10, 2008 09:51 PM #13
Kathy Carson
Blanks Properties - Lynchburg, VA
Realtor, Lynchburg, VA, VA Homes - Lynchunberg,Bedford, Campbell

Lisa - thanks for the info.  BTW - EBAY tried to put Paypal out of business at the beginning.  How do I know because our account number is one of the firsts!  We started using Paypal from the beginning and I literally would watch the Paypal subscriber numbers go up by the hundreds each day!  Ebay realized this was a way to make money so they started E-Pay (I think it was called) but the Sellers on Ebay knew we had a good thing going with Paypal and would not leave so Ebay waited for a few years and then just bought Paypal.   I remember in the first days of Paypal it was cash in your account only - now it's everywhere!!

Have a great day!

Nov 11, 2008 04:45 AM #14
Not a real person
San Diego, CA

I'd like to see everything available to everyone because that's going to mean that many in Third World countries will be able to get lots of information that they currently cannot except by traveling to a foreign country and visiting libraries. I do think that the publisher's union needs to be involved just like the RIAA was with Napster.

Nov 11, 2008 01:28 PM #15
Everard Korthals
---Preferred Lifestyle Advisors--- - Lancaster, PA
Mountain Realty

Great Article. Google definetely seems to be a powerhouse right now as we all use it to search for terms online.  Like Microsoft, this monopoly will find itself in court against a larger entity one day and then the landscape will change once again. But for now, they hold the cards and apparently the influence too.

Dec 23, 2008 05:47 PM #16
Show All Comments

What's the reason you're reporting this blog entry?

Are you sure you want to report this blog entry as spam?


Lisa Hill

Daytona Beach Real Estate
Ask me a question

Additional Information