Little Gull Island Lighthouse: Gavel fell at Auction for $381,000

Managing Real Estate Broker with Town and Country Real Estate of the North Fork


Yet another sign of an improving Real Estate Market in the East End:

Little Gull Island & LighthouseLittle Gull Island & Lighthouse

The gavel finally fell on a historic landmark known to any LI Sound Sailor. According to the GSA, (General Services Administration) the 1-acre rocky Little Gull Island (some 8 miles east of Orient Point) and its 450 Ft2 1869 built Lighthouse sold for $381,000 on October 25th 2012.

Little Gull Lighthouse InteriorLittle Gull Lighthouse Interior

According to Newsday, the new owner (who was in competition with the New London Maritime Society which owns New London Harbor Lighthouse) is Mr. Fred Plum, owner of Plumb products machine tool company in Woodbury, CT.

According to WIKIPEDIA The US Coast Guard has identified Little Gull Island Light as one of its Historic Light Stations in New York.[7] In 2009 Little Gull Island Light was put up for sale under the National Historic Lighthouse Preservation Act.[8]

Manana Island Signal StationBut for all of you who missed this one and still cherish the dream of owning on of this country's historic maritime relics not all is lost: the Manana Island Signal Station is up for auction by the GSA and bidding stands at a mere $30,000 - and all you need is a $5,000 deposit to participate...

The following can be your's according to the GSA website:

On top of Manana Island, 10 miles off the coast of Maine, is the former Coast Guard Signal Station. This maritime setting is picturesque with panoramic views of the ocean, rolling fields and Smutty Nose Island. A short boat ride across the bay is Monhegan Island which is home to fisherman, artist & writers.

Manana Island Signal Station - MaineManana Island Signal Station - Maine

The buildings on this site are in need of restoration work to preserve their historic value to the Monhegan Historical District, This includes a two story, white, wooden, clapboarded, four bedroom former Keeper’s quarters(1855) on a brick foundation with a brick cistern in the basement and an attached deck. Also included is a brick Sound Signal/Engine House(1855) with a wooden tower and a shed-like attachment to the north of the tower, The lot is approximately 6400sf +/-.Just bring your sweater this time of year... and as always - feel free to call any of your friends at Town and Country Real Estate for professional information on this or any other Real Estate matter!

Happy 2013.

Posted by

Joan H. Bischoff van Heemskerck, Managing Director, North Fork and Shelter Island, Town & Country real estate Tel 631 948 0234 or

Comments (2)

Li Read
Sea to Sky Premier Properties (Salt Spring) - Salt Spring Island, BC
Caring expertise...knowledge for you!

Loved your an island resident, it's fun to read about other opportunities.

Dec 28, 2012 02:58 AM
Kevin J. May
Florida Supreme Realty - Hobe Sound, FL
Serving the Treasure & Paradise Coasts of Florida

The granite there has to be worth at least that much.  I wonder if the Historical Sociiety would allow it's dismantling?  LOL

Dec 28, 2012 03:01 AM