Those of you who read my most recent post know that I am going to be purchasing a puppy this year. It occurred to me while doing my research that the process of selecting a breeder is similar to the process of Basket of Puppieschoosing a real estate agent. Here are the similarities:

  • I asked people I know for recommendations
  • I searched the internet and breeder websites for more information
  • I looked for a breeder that provides service before, during and after the sale of the puppy
  • I read references/testimonials from past puppy purchasers
  • I have spoken with the breeder many times and asked tons of questions

Most buyers or sellers of real estate will go through a similar process:

  • They will ask friends, neighbors or colleagues for recommendations
  • They will search the internet and real estate websites for more information
  • They will look for an agent who provides service before, during and after the sale
  • They will read references/testimonials from past clients
  • They will speak or meet with an agent in person and ask tons of questions

During my research, one thing became very clear. I would not, under any circumstances, purchase my puppy from a puppy mill. For those who don't know what a puppy mill is, it is defined as "a large scale dog breeding facility that operates under substandard breeding conditions." Dogs who are bred in puppy mills are usually "kept in overcrowded and unsanitary conditions and do not receive adequate food, water or veterinary care."

Puppies acquired from puppy mills tend to have issues not typically found in puppies acquired from reputable breeders, such as genetic health problems, behavior problems and socialization issues. In addition, the puppy may be sold as a purebred dog, when in fact it is not. You are paying a high price (have you seen the prices of puppies these days?) and not getting what you paid for. Finally, there are no guarantees...you buy the puppy and you never hear from the so-called breeder again.

In real estate, there are plenty of agents who deal either in very high volume and/or provide substandard service. Buyers and sellers who don't do the research or ask enough questions before they choose an agent run the risk of choosing someone who will not properly represent them. The agent or company may treat them like a number because they deal in volume; selling many properties each year. As a result, the client may not receive adequate service before, during or after the sale. In short, the client may not get what they paid for...a "healthy" transaction and quality representation.

Don't take risks with your new best friend!Are high volume agents and discount real estate brokers the puppy mills of the real estate business? That's not for me to say. It is certainly possible to have a good experience with both high volume agents and discount real estate brokers just as it is possible to purchase a healthy puppy from a puppy mill.

Buying a puppy, and purchasing or selling a home, are very important decisions that you will have to live with for many years. Are you willing to take that risk?

I'm not a high volume agent and I'm not a discount broker. You can rely on me for quality, personal and professional representation before, during and after the sale...in Lake Zurich and throughout the Northwest Suburbs of Illinois.

Kelly Sibilsky

 

 

 

24 Comments on Would you buy a puppy from a puppy mill?

JAN
07
2008
696,451 Points 72 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Kelly, having tried to find a dog breeder on the Internet when I got Willie the hyperactive-Labradoodle puppy, I think it's safe to say that it can be difficult to make the distinctions online between a reputable breeder (this place was) and a puppy mill.  And I thing the same can be said of looking for a Realtor online.  I checked out a bunch of Labradoodle sites then called people I knew who were plugged into the doggie thing.  Willie came from a huge farm where he spent his first six months chasing squirrels and cats.  Some of my neighbors had dealt with them.  They had a good reputation.  I found their web site after talking to some other people.

Most of my clients find me the same way - word of mouth, then I send them to my site.  It's working pretty well! 

12:01pm • #1
I'm going to have to steal your analogy when I'm up against the celebrity agents we have here.  LOVE it!
12:07pm • #2
147,548 Points 6 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Here in Missouri, one of the states best or worst known for the puppy mills, I got duped!  I bought a puppy from a place that to all visual appearances appeared like a legitimate business.  It was brightly lit, clean, etc.  I only found out later from a vet that it was a front for a group of puppy mills. 

I should have done my research better...

 

Bob Mitchell

ValueList Real Estate Services, Inc. 

12:21pm • #3
658,366 Points 108 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog
Kelly - This is a great analogy.  I hadn't heard of a puppy mill, but the comparison is certainly an apt one.  Keep up the good work!
12:27pm • #4
135,744 Points 19 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Patricia: I totally agree. I've been driving myself crazy with all the research...because it is a very important decision. Recommendations are very important as web sites can be misleading; and that's where I started my search. I never thought it would be so difficult.

Sandra: Glad you liked it!

Bob: Appearances can be deceiving...you are absolutely right about doing the research. I don't want to be duped. Thanks for sharing your experience.

12:28pm • #5
135,744 Points 19 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Jason: Puppy mills are so sad and unfortunately it's rampant since puppies have become more expensive and disreputable people have realized they can make lots of money. I've been told never to buy from a puppy mill or pet store, but to choose a small breeder who raises the puppies underfoot with lots of love and attention.
12:31pm • #6
4 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor
Beautiful analogy, Kelly.  Research is important for any consumer when chooding an agent and service level.  It's even more important when it involves a little lovable life.  I've only had rescues and stray puppies for my dogs, and it has worked out for me.  I'm glad that you are pointing out what happens behind the scenes in many pet stores.  Good luck on your future little puppy.  Please post baby pictures when you get the little darling!
12:40pm • #7
Hi Kelly, I love your article, it's well written and holds your attention. Making the comparison with the puppy mills is very unique and original. Great job.
2:02pm • #8
2 Featured Posts

Kelly~ I agree 100% that you should not buy from a puppy mill, but you need to get references from a small breeder too. My girlfriend thought she had done her research properly but has had a terrible experience with the small breeder she went with.

Your analogy to real estate and volume agents is dead on.

3:38pm • #9
135,744 Points 19 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Elaine: I'll be sure to post pictures; but it may be a while since she has not even been born yet!

Vinnie: Thank you!

Lisa: You are absolutely correct. I'm sorry your friend had a terrible experience. I certainly hope all my research will pay off for me.

3:46pm • #10
186,430 Points 31 Featured Posts Outside Blog Hit Router

Kelly, you've chosen an interesting analogy and I think one which works well for our industry. There are agents who are only about "the next deal" much the way a puppy mill breeder sees nothing for $$$$ w/ a puppy. Both situations usually offer very inferior quality. (And on the puppy side I know of what I speak, having been a Vet tech in college)

-Colleen

6:52pm • #11
688,016 Points 145 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router

Good analogy, Kelly. I think it fits in lots of ways. Best of luck with your new puppy!

Jeff 

7:02pm • #12
577,499 Points 95 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router

Buying a puppy, and purchasing or selling a home, are very important decisions that you will have to live with for many years. Are you willing to take that risk?

Well that sums it up. Great analogy and the answer should be NO to both.  

7:13pm • #13
149,136 Points 8 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Kelly, since you did all the research, when my husband gives me the go ahead, Ill call you for the name of the breeder.  Would you mind if I come over to see your puppy when you get it?   On the other topic, I know you are a realtor who gives each and everyone of your clients 110%.  

7:34pm • #14

Oooh- I like how Missy Csulk summed it up.

I had to wait so long to be stable enough for a dog, I spent a LONG time looking for the right breeder. It was nice to find that match and I am so glad I did.

7:40pm • #15
135,744 Points 19 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Colleen: The good ones focus on getting repeat and referral business ~ in both cases!

Jeff: Thank you! I can't wait to get her!

Missy: I agree! All major decisions should be well thought out and researched carefully.

Judy: Of course you can, but it's going to be a while...so you have some time to work on that husband of yours. Mine caved easily. We need a little girl around here in testosterone land.

Sarah: I'm glad you found the right dog for you. Congratulations!

8:49pm • #16
203,920 Points 4 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Kelly - that is a great analogy!   I had never thought of it that way, but since I have never bought a puppy from  a breeder I have no experience with them.

But I would imagine it to be no different than any other service provider that you are going to entrust your business to.

Thanks for an enlightening post! 

9:25pm • #17
JAN
08
2008
408,703 Points 74 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Honestly...when we bought our Jack Russel 18 yrs ago we did a lot of research first...we traveled 5 hours to get him...breeding is an issue for health reasons on how many times they breed in a year and puppy mills are usually abusive in their practices of breeding and most health issues will come up if they are bread too many times without rest in between. This is what we were told and read but never actually have seen other than from news reports. Find a reputable breeder and have them answer the proper questions. Our dog thankfully is still alive and kicking...he is now starting to have problems but all in all has been pretty healthy and not many problems at all.
6:50am • #18
135,744 Points 19 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Carol: I don't do anything without thinking it over carefully, so this was no exception. I even surprised myself by how much research I did; and it was all about trust. Who can I entrust this important part of my life to? That's when I realized how similar my process was to choosing an agent.

Neal: I've been told I'm crazy for doing so much research because I'm not buying a purebred, but a hybrid. But it is still extremely important to know who the puppy parents are and to make sure they are purebred and treated/bred humanely. And to know (see for myself) how the puppies are born and raised/socialized until I get mine. There will always be that element of "mother nature" but it is my responsibility to do what I can to have a healthy puppy. Not just for the sake of my family...but for the puppy as well.

8:24am • #19
1 Featured Post
Thanks for the tips Kelly and a great analogy!  Buying a puppy is like finding an agent.  I'll be looking for my new puppy this spring one our fence is finished, now I have a better idea of where to start.
12:28pm • #20
JAN
09
2008
135,744 Points 19 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Jen: Good luck with your new puppy & thanks for your comments.
10:10am • #21
JAN
19
2008

Kelly,

First off, I must say that is a beautiful analogy and an exceedingly relevant one at that!  After visiting an operation which I did not even realize before today was in service, a puppy mill, I STILL can not overcome the shock I had upon witnessing such an establishment.  I myself, have a 2-year old pomeranian which I purchased from a well-known family friend whom also realizes the importance of "quality, personal and professional representation" in making such an important decision.  Needless to say she is nothing short of the best companion and greatest purchase I have ever made!  I did some venturing out today in search of a brother or sister for Precious (that is my dog's name) since I just recently moved away from home where she had the pleasure of playing with her sister (my sister's dog whom was also purchased from the same breeder).  I did not realize the sad and inhumanness which lies upon entering the doors of a puppy mill or that of which even existed!

Being in a graduate program which solely relies on research research reasearch, I also get a little carried away and have been told I am crazy with all the research that I do :) However, I could not agree more with you on how important it is ESPECIALLY when making such a decision that you have to live with for many years.

I am actually moving forward with all the research that I have gathered about puppy mills and proposing it to my professor as a potential practicuum project.  If you have found any articles/resources that you consider extremely relevant and useful please let me know.

Good luck with your new family member! I hope he/she is every bit of joy and happiness that my Precy is :)

Brooke Walker- Carbondale, IL SIU Graduate Student
8:40pm • #22
125,809 Points 3 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog
Hi Kelly,  You can't go wrong with a boxer! Great dog with kids and so cute!
9:05pm • #23
135,744 Points 19 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Brooke: What a great idea for a project! One of my good friends made the mistake of purchasing a puppy from a pet store...and later found out that pet stores usually get their puppies from puppy mills. Well, to make a long story short, her puppy has had nothing but health problems. Very expensive health problems. If she knew then what she knows now, she would have never purchased him from that store. Many people feel like they are "saving" the puppy but what they are doing is allowing the puppy mill business to continue. It's so sad. I can't wait to get my puppy and good luck finding your new one, too! Thanks for taking the time to read and comment, I really appreciate it!

LaNita: One of my good friends has a boxer...he is very cute...but too big for me! I'm after a little furball! Have a wonderful evening!

9:20pm • #24

Leave a response…



(optional)
What does the graphic say?
 
Rainmaker_large

Kelly Sibilsky

Lake Zurich, IL

More about me…

Licensed Through Referral Connection, LTD.

Cell Phone: (847) 909-2337

Email Me

"Referring to top agents locally and across the country"

My take on the local real estate market, as well as my favorite people, places and things to do in Lake Zurich and the surrounding communities of Barrington, Deer Park, Hawthorn Woods, Kildeer and Long Grove.



Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog

Find IL real estate agents and Lake Zurich real estate on ActiveRain.