Special offer

Short Sales - Lots of Fun

By
Real Estate Broker/Owner with Cassidon Realty

Well from listening to several buyer agents and many of our own if anything comes out of this foreclosure, short sale boom for the real estate industry maybe it will have something to do with a standardized system for dealing with short sales. 

I have heard and experienced many nightmares for agents but more importantly buyers who actually do want to buy but are unable to do or just don't understand the process when making an offer on a property which is tagged with "short sale" or "bank approval required" as a label in mls.  I don't blame them, many times I don't understand the process either.

For the most part many banks have similar needs and requirements for instance the need for the property owners participation and cooperation as well as hardship letters and other explanations.  I think where the majority of the problems exist is the time frames 2-3 month approvals for an offer really aren't right and if the answer is no and the buyers rate lock expires is that at all fair!

My favorite short sale stories are the ones where I have watched our agents do very detailed due diligence and go over and above the call of duty to help the seller out of a jamb.  I have had agents who have prepared masterful and detailed cma's that not only detail the property, neighborhood trends but the entire market area with numerous comps, photos, graphs and blood types of the family.  In an attempt to send in the most complete short sale package as possible (knowing that one minor mistake will cost weeks) they have over documented their case, sent in all of the property owners documents, financial info, hardship letters and other proof of the clients desire to cooperate and plead for assistance.  They have checked their details twice had others review the same and received written confirmation from the short selling lender that all was in order. 

Guess what.... two weeks our agent is told NO to the short sale because the lender received a $50 drive by saying the property was worth more than what the seller owes and a short sale is not necessary.  Why... because the agent doing the drive by had visions of a listing!  Doesn't matter that the lender has our agents cma which is far better than the ten minute drive by.  Doesn't matter that the seller previous had the property on the market for nine months at a lower than drive by price and it didn't sell. 

This is just one of many I am speaking of but my favorites are when there has been a buyer patiently waiting for the answer.  I have many other stories that have arisen from this market and these conditions but it always amazes me how foolish institutions can be.  No wonder!!

Posted by

http://www.cassidonrealty.com/

Comments(3)

Cindy Crutcher
Lawrenceburg KY Foreclosures & Government Owned Properties - Lawrenceburg, KY
Real Estate Broker - Exit Realty Crutcher Lawrenceburg KY

Jack,

I have "been there, done that" so many times that I start to feel sick just thinking about it.  I do hope that these foolish institutions as you called them will start to streamline their processes and take note of what is not working.  Of course, if they receive another bail out for bad business, does it really matter to them?  Just my thoughts on the issue.  Thanks for sharing!

Feb 22, 2009 05:49 AM
Pacita Dimacali
Alain Pinel - Oakland, CA
Alameda/Contra Costa Counties CA

We had two listings slated for short sale. The lender requested BPOs which priced the listings at higher than what we listed them for.

  • In one case, the property is a major fixer listed at $300K. The BPO reviewed recent sales, but didn't go inside the property to determine the condition of the property. He priced it at $500K, whereas the cost to repair the property was around $250K.
  • In the second, the property had severe problems. It was listed at $265K, and the cost to repair was at around $100K. The BPO put the property at $325K.

So we produced inspections and estimates do dispute the drive by. We even offered to give copies of these reports to the BPO agents to document our case.

And in those cases, the BPOs were revised accordingly. The thing to remember is to challenge the BPOs if you think strongly enough about it, and if you can prove your case.

Feb 22, 2009 05:50 AM
Michael S. Mackey
CENTURY 21 All Islands - Mililani, HI
REALTOR ABR, CRS, GRI, RSPS

Jack, I feel your frustration! That's why so many agents just have to tell Buyer's that if they put in an offer on one of these short sales, don't hold your breath and keep on looking.

Feb 22, 2009 05:52 AM