Special offer

To cut or not to cut - Is that really the question? Commentary on upcoming Fed Cut

By
Mortgage and Lending with YourPersonalMortgagePlanner.com

Here's a interesting read I got recently from someone I know, like and trust (hey, he's referable!)  I disagree with him about the recession.  I'll add my comments in (parenthesis).  Enjoy!

Friday's Jobs report was probably the straw (or brick!) that has now left the Fed asking as to just how deep the rate cut will be at the next FOMC meeting on September 18. Will the cut be 25bps or 50bps? Most likely the cut now seems to be a 50bp cut when the Fed members meet. Or will they call an emergency meeting between now and the 18th to halt plunging treasury yields? (Highly unlikely with cautious Ben)  As stated previously, the yield on the 10-Year Treasury Note was last seen hovering around the 4.38%, a level not seen since January of 2006. At that time the Federal Funds Rate was at 4.25%.

The "R" word or recession is now starting to loom its ugly head but those fears may be overblown. The Fed's Beige Book summary of economic conditions released earlier this week indicated that housing and credit problems have had little impact on the broader economy so far. Also last week, retailers reported better-than-expected sales for the August back-to-school shopping period. (Can you spell c-o-n-t-a-i-n-m-e-n-t-?  See my post from earlier today to see why I disagree)

However, William Poole, president of the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, said there is "no question" that recent market turmoil would worsen conditions in the U.S. housing market, but that the effect on the broader economy was less clear.

"I think the probability of recession is higher than it used to be," Mr. Poole said following a speech in London late last week. (Indeed, going from 1:5 odds to 1:3 overnight is definitely "higher"!) He added that there is anecdotal evidence and also some formal data suggesting there is a further leg down in the housing market. (Sorry guys and gals, but it's true!  I'll put up a post soon detailing how subprime ARM resets will reach all time highs in October and November of this year - a time after most subprime lenders have already been buried and guidelines as we once knew them in the lending world are GONE!  Who's going to refinance these 90%+ LTV folks w/sub 620 FICOs!?  You can see where this is going...)

Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia President Charles Plosser said that while the surprise loss of U.S. jobs in August was "not encouraging," it doesn't on its own justify lowering interest rates. "We want to be careful not to overweight one piece of information," he said in an interview late Saturday after a speech in Waikoloa, Hawaii. "I've not made up my mind at all on whether a rate cut is needed." Plosser doesn't vote until next year on interest rate decisions. (Ah, that's comforting!  He's got at least another 4 months before his opinion counts! :o)

Goldman Sachs is now expecting a 50 bp rate cut from the Fed on Sep 18 in wake of weak jobs report and Bear Stearns a 25 bp cut. Barclay's is looking for 75bps in cuts by year-end. (Report I read earlier today shows a 56% likelihood of 1% cuts by end of 07.  BUT, bare in mind that a Fed Funds rate cut does NOT equate LOWER long term mortgage rates!  Just as rates didn't go up 4.25% as the Fed marched on their steady parade up from 1% to 5.25%, they won't drop in step with the cuts either in all likelihood - ESPECIALLY if the language released in the Fed Minutes details continued concern about inflation!)

I registered www.MortgageMarketMeltdown.com recently and have not had the opportunity to throw the site up yet.  I'm inviting you to visit the site and if it's not up by midnight tonight (PST), please jab me with accountability!  Thanks!

PS - I'll also be posting great news links and list my "sources" there too.  AND, what I'm most excited about is starting a podcast!  I'll be interviewing nationally recognized experts, local experts (San Jose, CA), top producing Realtors, and industry trainers.  If you have any suggestions, please let me know! 

Charlie Ragonesi
AllMountainRealty.com - Big Canoe, GA
Homes - Big Canoe, Jasper, North Georgia Pros
What the fed and the media gloss over is the number one cause of inflation. That is Government spending more than it takes in. So while the fed cis punitive when they see inflation. The private sectors may not necessarily be the prime cause. I think the fed should cut rates and the govt should stop over spending.
Sep 10, 2007 12:54 PM
Sean Rafferty
YourPersonalMortgagePlanner.com - San Jose, CA

Uncle Sam, what a role model when it comes to personal finance, eh!?  :o)

Sep 10, 2007 01:19 PM
Lori Lincoln And Associates
Top Agent Serving Dighton Taunton, Rehoboth and more! - Taunton, MA
Top Agent Taunton,Dighton Rehoboth &more

Sean,

The mortgage meltdown site is depressing. I wanted to quit the business after reading it. I highly advise you not to get too caught up in it. The market is the market, keep working the smart way and overcome this. Call on more people, personal lunches with Realtors. etc..

Sep 10, 2007 01:24 PM
Amanda Evans
DFW Living - Fort Worth, TX
Real Estate Broker - Fort Worth Texas

The inverted yield curve spelled economic trouble as early as 18 months ago!  The ARM resets have been scheduled for some time and everybody pretended like the problem would go away somehow.  A recession seems inevitable. It's like one big frat party where you drink all night and wake up the next day continuing to drink in order to delay the hangover!  There will be REAL pain eventually but nothing like what happens in 2nd Qtr '08 when the hammer really drops and the foreclosures start to really pile on.  For now, rates are going to drop faster than NAR's membership #'s and even that won't be enough.

The bears are running this show. 

Looking forward to the reset post...

 

 

Sep 10, 2007 01:28 PM
Sean Rafferty
YourPersonalMortgagePlanner.com - San Jose, CA

Lori, not sure what you are referring to as I haven't even put up my first post (yet!) and yes, the market is the market but we can't be like ostriches and stick our heads in the sand and continue to do the same old thing irregardless of market conditions.  One must ascertain the market she finds herself in and access where client pain and potential gain is to be found and then devise a way to meet those needs - this is what I am doing and will help others do as well.

Sean

Sep 10, 2007 05:46 PM