Special offer

Top 6 Reasons to Stay away from New Construction Right Now!

By
Real Estate Sales Representative with Keller Williams Realty

 

#1 Prices are falling and Builders don't like refunding deposits!  Putting a deposit down on a home that is scheduled to be completed 6 months or even 3 months from now can be sticky.  With prices falling, appraisals are getting harder to come by.  Builders don't like dropping their contract prices because it makes them less profit and it also puts them into a sticky situation with people that have already purchased at the higher level. If a buyer has a substantial amount of money down, the builder can actually force the buyer to close or forfeit their deposit.

#2 Builders and Developers aren't following through with their promises.  Many buyers have purchased in large communities where construction has come to a stand still and they are left looking at tall weeds!

#3 Builders and Developers are pulling fast ones.  A home I just sold last month was in a community where there was a pending lawsuit against the developer.  Apparently the developer, in an effort to raise additional capital, decided to sell off the very profitable club house of a very large community in Clermont.  The only problem is that the H.O.A. was supposed to have first Dibs!  Ooops.

#4 Construction has gotten even worse! Profits are down, layoffs are high, as a result quality suffers

#5 New and upcoming areas are not growing anymore.  Times are tough.

#6 Property Taxes!! Need I say more

Christine Bohn
RE/MAX Professionals - Gainesville, FL
The Bohn Team, Gainesville FL
One other issue - developers have spec homes done and in inventory - they have stopped any new construction, and existing homeowners are upset that the developer have YET to put in the POOL or Tennis Courts for community amenities......that has happened here in my area.....kinda scary!
Aug 28, 2007 09:39 AM
Kate Bourland
Marketing with Kate - Redding, CA
Onlilne Marketing Mobile Marketing

Wow - I'm not sure that I agree with this advise.  Builders need to move inventory to help the market absorb and correct itself.  When this happens it will help the resale market improve too.  Certainly I agree, be cautious of buying a home that is 6 months out but there is nothing wrong with buying standing inventory.

 Also, deposits are held in an escrow account.  They are not the property of the builder - the escrow company would be required to return it to the homebuyer in case the builder goes out of business.  I think that better advise would be to make sure that the homebuyer has an open escrow and a receipt showing that the deposit was made into the escrow account.

This is not a them against us situation - we are all in this together.

Aug 28, 2007 09:45 AM
Kory Benken
Keller Williams Realty - Lake Mary, FL
REALTOR, G.R.I.

Kate,

Good points all. But have you had the experience with builders that require the buyer keep their deposit in the Builders account?  They give the buyers the option of keeping their deposit in an escrow account but they charge them a fee for doing so.  I tried my best to talk my buyers out of this, but he didn't want to pay the extra $300 the builder wanted to charge him for keeping in an "escrow" account.

I didn't think this was legal, but I guess if they disclose to all parties it is.  I've had builders actually try and get MY CLIENTS to sign a Single Agent Disclosure!!!

I'm not saying that no one should buy new construction, that would be a problem.  But we need to stop them from building any more right now. 

Also, Once a buyer goes past a certain point in the contract their deposit usually is at risk. It's written in the contract.  I know they're long but you should read them

Aug 28, 2007 02:53 PM
Terry Haugen STAGE it RIGHT! 321-956-2495
Stage it Right! - Melbourne, FL
Kory, the market here in Brevard County is dead, builders have hundreds of spec homes they can't unload, they keep reducing the prices and still no takers, YET they still continue to start developing new communities.  I don't understand that mentality.  If they can't unload what they;ve already built, why are they still building?  Their excess inventory is the main reason private home sellers can't get their homes sold.  Who can compete with 2% financing and free granite countertops?
Aug 28, 2007 03:18 PM
Frank Harris
Keller Williams Realty Centre - Columbia, MD
Here in Maryland the market is somewhat stable. Homes under $500k are still selling. The more expensive homes are very slow. Building communities of 350k or less are selling quickly. The incentive are incredible but I am not sure how many builders are holding true to their word on these incentives.
Aug 28, 2007 03:30 PM
Kory Benken
Keller Williams Realty - Lake Mary, FL
REALTOR, G.R.I.

Terry, Frank and Kate (if your still with us)

Thanks for your comments.  I just got off the phone with an Atty who is handling a lot of cases dealing with this issue of new specs not appraising and builders not wanting to budge. Fortunately, She has been able to find some loopholes in some of these contracts but everyone needs to be real careful.

In my experience, recently some builders have been open to "addendums", and I recommend that everyone protect their clients.

 

Aug 30, 2007 01:49 PM
Candy Henthorne
Results Realty - Spring, TX
Spring Texas Real Estate

New home starts are slowing down some, but I haven't had any builders not wanting to return the deposits as yet here, but I will be keeping my eyes out.

Aug 30, 2007 04:47 PM
Susan Peters
Dove Realty Inc. - Seattle, WA
The Better it Looks the Better it Sells

Kory,

I agree! The problem I see in Seattle is construction flaws. There doesn't seem to be a project in town that makes it through the 1st 5 years intact. This place looks like Shrink Wrap City. When it comes to condos I advise my my clients to buy a unit in an older, solid building and the redo the surfaces with the money they saved.

 

 

Aug 30, 2007 05:46 PM
Kory Benken
Keller Williams Realty - Lake Mary, FL
REALTOR, G.R.I.

Susan,

That is probalby sound advice to give your clients, unless you can find a builder who is "Realistic".  The couple on new construction deals that I have done in the past year have resembled existing homes sales more than new home sales.  But.....we had to look around for a while before we found a builder who was flexible.

Sep 01, 2007 06:49 AM
Carol Verhelle
Coldwell Banker Professionals - Fenton, MI

Kory,  I work for a builder and we are looking at weeds!  We have a couple of model homes, but nothing is moving...typical right now for Michigan. A couple of builders have gone owt of business lately. I feel like I am spinning my wheels here, going nowhere soon.

Sep 01, 2007 07:19 AM
Kathleen Garvey
HomeSmart Cherry Creek - Denver - Denver, CO
Denver's Neighborhood Expert - Listings & Sales
I AGREE!!  Here is SW FLorida it has become scary for new homebuyers and builders.  A really bad time financially and too much money has been shuffled around trying to keep things afloat....egads! Regards-Kathleen G.
Sep 01, 2007 09:23 AM
Claudia Clausen
Keller Williams Elite Realtors - Metuchen, NJ
Middlesex County Real Estate
Thanks for the warning. Although I haven't personally experienced that here in NJ I will certainly watch out for it.
Sep 01, 2007 10:20 AM
Ilyce N. Powell
Financial Revitalize - Baltimore, MD
CMPS- Certified Mortgage Planning Specialist
Hey Kory. You're bringing me down, dude. Why is this listed under AR Comedy Club group? Good info, otherwise.
Sep 01, 2007 01:49 PM
Dan Norton
Sand Dollar Realty & Sand Dollar Referrals - Orlando, FL

Kory, I especially agree with #2 -- a community we both know well had nearly shut down operations for quite a while, and the home that I was once under contract for myself (at $275k) and schedule to close in Nov 2006 has just recently been started, should close this month finally, and was re-contracted to someone else for $220k.

Meanwhile, the neighborhood gets to look at an empty dirt patch across the street where the 'other' side of the road is supposed to be full of homes by now. 

...but I'm sure they're not charging HOA dues to these poor homeowners, right?   ...right?   (ahem)

---With that said, I'd be careful to not steer anyone away from new construction for a couple of reasons, so long as your buyer understands that it may take much longer for that community to fill out than they have once expected.  The quality of most big builders is the same as it was years ago (for better or worse!), and many of them are realizing that the fast market is gone, so many of them are taking more time on the homes than they were during the boom.  With prices dropping, you can take advantage and load up on incentives like you could never expect to do in resales, and then there's the huge commissions some of them offer to agents, too!  Keep those options in mind when searching for a home...

Sep 01, 2007 05:50 PM
Heather the Realtor Orlando, Lake Mary
LemonTree Realty - Orlando, FL
First Time Home Buyers, Bank Owned Homes

I love new home construction, I advise my customers not to build or do preconstruction in this market. Getting in one the last model or two in a community is key. Close usually in 15 days and get the losest price in the community. There is always a way to get the deposit back. I even received my $29,000 deposit on a deal with a builder that I personally had, some are harder then others and some require lawyers but it can be done. Also builders are allowed to hold the money where ever they want they are not part of the real estate board and do not have to abid by our rules so buyer beware with that aspect.

Property taxes are always low in the first year when new home construction is purchased until the property is reassesed so they enjoy a tax break at first.

Sep 03, 2007 02:53 PM
Kory Benken
Keller Williams Realty - Lake Mary, FL
REALTOR, G.R.I.

Heather,

thank for your comments. I would be careful about saying there is "ALWAYS" a way to get the deposit back. I'm glad you've recieved your deposit back and I agree that an attorney should be consulted however the contract between the builder and the buyer is the key factor and probably the main reason for this blog. I wanted to stir emotions and create awareness about whats going on.

Sep 04, 2007 10:56 AM
Lee Walsh
SecurityNational Mortgage - Lake Mary, FL
Executive Talent Scout for Mortgage Professionals
We had the same "deposit" problem with some builders when prices were climbing, a few were looking for any reason to  kill the deal so they could sell to someone else at a higher price.  In Florida the builder can collect and hold the deposit we do not have the escrow system that some other states have. I would bet it's the same few builders now trying to force a buyer to stay in an over priced contract.  Take a sellers agent with you if you are buying from the developer to help write the contract or have an attorney. Most builders would not stoop to those types of practices.  
Feb 16, 2008 04:24 PM
Maureen G. Zea
APPLE REALTY PROPERTIES, JACKSONVILLE, FL. - Jacksonville Beach, FL
Broker, CIPS, Realtor, AHWD

HI,

I WOULD LIKE TO AGREE YOU HAVE VALID CONCERNS TO NEW CONSTRUCTION PROBLEMS.

I THINK THERE IS NO BETTER TIME FOR CUSTOMER TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF BUILDER CLOSE OUTS!  MANY OF THE CONCERNS RAISED IN YOUR COMMENTS CAN BE OVERCOME WITH FUNDS BEING ESCROWED AND/OR BOND BEING OBTAINED.

THIS TIME IS A RARE OPPORTUNITY FOR THE CUSTOMERS TO SCOUP UP THE SAVINGS AND FOR REALTORS TO LOOK TO A GREAT 2008! REMEMBER! WE ARE THE PROFESSIONALS WHO SET THE TONE FOR THE SALE! ATTITUDE TO OVER COME ANY ADVERSITY IS THE KEY TO SUCCESS. ATTITUDE IS EVERYTHING!

BEST TO ALL! MAUREEN

Feb 16, 2008 04:51 PM
Roland Woodworth
Blue Cord Realty - Clarksville, TN
Blue Cord Realty
Clarksville, TN is still a good area to buy a home.... We are down alittle, but not like other areas......
Feb 16, 2008 05:56 PM
Jay Beckingham
Christensen Financial Mortgage - Port St Lucie, FL
Seniors ROCK!
in my marketplace new construction very often means homes built within the last 12 months which have yet to sell, but have never been occupied. they are sold at market or less and can be a very good buy.
Feb 16, 2008 10:11 PM