Special offer

The Effects of A Stolen Photograph

By
Real Estate Agent with Cherimie Crane & Associates

At least once a week I read the warnings from agents about copying photographs. Honestly, I haven't given it much thought until today. Like most experiences, it seems a bit pronounced when the effect hits home. The words in the endless warnings never mentioned the emotional side of a stolen photograph.

In the middle of my busy, hectic, Monday-all-over-again day, I received an email from a friend who had recognized one of my photographs. Anyone who knows me, and even those who have only read one or two of my ramblings know that I lost a very dear friend not too long ago.

His name was Jackson. He was my sidekick, my foot warmer, my best friend, and my comfort. Jackson was a quirky cocker spaniel who for 14 lovely years never once left my side. We were inseparable. Inseparable until tainted peanut butter in a toy caused his painful, untimely death. He died just as he lived, right by my side.

Anyone who has had the priviledge of being loved by such a soul can understand; time does not heal all wounds.

 

My memory had been stolen. Not only had it been stolen but had been photo shopped and commercialized. It took my breath away. To keep from humiliating myself, I had to actually step outside of my office to gather my thoughts and my emotions. This particular photo was taken only days before I had to say goodbye to Jackson. It has much value to me in so many ways.

An art student had copied my photo and submitted it for the cover of the Marine Corps Air Station Air Show. The worst part is she "edited" out my Jackson's ears, my favorite of his features.

It wasn't pride nor possession that hurt so deeply, it was having my memory changed. That day was so perfect, so beautiful. I was on the boat with my two favorite people in the world and captured a moment that I will cherish for the rest of my life. She copied that moment and changed it.

I contacted her directly and eventually she responded. She didn't seem to understand why I was so upset. She simply said she thought it was a good picture and felt she could make it better. Well, she can't make it better; no one can.

So before you Google an image, think about the moment, the memory, and the story behind it. What may seem as so general, so normal, so easy, may actually be anything but general.

My moment was posted all over someone else's social networks and commercial sites. Comments about my "moment" were everywhere.

Please think twice.

 

Posted by

 

Whether you are buying or selling Real Estate in Beaufort South Carolina, We know Beaufort. Our little coastal town has something for everyone.

 

843-812-2090

 

Comments(103)

Cherimie Crane
Cherimie Crane & Associates - Beaufort, SC

hi Joseph, Thanks for commenting. I appreciate your perspective. This is a real estate blog, and this is the first place the photo was ever published in a blog I wrote about my town. I have done nothing other than writing this blog, contacting the Air Station, and contacting the young lady. I have asked her to call me. I have not in anyway hurt her education, I haven't even said who it was. The original photo is in a very safe and secure place, it is sitting next to my dog's ashes in a wooden chest. I was hurt, extremely hurt when I saw the photo. I was at work at it was completely unexpected. Again, I appreciate your perspective and have no desire to destroy anything.

Nov 18, 2010 06:03 AM
Dean Carver
United Brokers Group/Carver Home Team - Ahwatukee, AZ

I think she missed the memo on the picture was never hers to change in the first place. We lost our 15 year old Cricket dog a few months ago and know how you feel.

Nov 18, 2010 06:05 AM
Kathy Quinn
The Nines Team Realty - Lodi, CA
The Nines Team in Lodi - Team Administrator

Cherimie, My heart aches for you.  Your post came a week after I lost my D.J., my best friend who literally walked out of a cold rainy parking lot into my life as a stray kitten 16 years ago and firmly planted himself in my heart.  People who do not love animals, will not "get it."  I agree, you should call the Air Show contest and report this insensitive piece of inhumanity.  She might just "get it" if they disqualify her.  She didn't just steal a photograph, she stole a piece of your soul.  The good thing is that you will always have the joy in your heart that only belongs to Jackson.  She cannot steal that from you.

Nov 18, 2010 06:14 AM
Margaret Woda
Long & Foster Real Estate, Inc. - Crofton, MD
Maryland Real Estate & Military Relocation

Cherimie - I respect your decision not to seek legal recourse against the person who used your photo without permission, since it probably was an act of ignorance.  However, I believe that anyone who runs such a contest (and even the event) should require a signed affidavit that the submission is original work.  Signing such a document would, indeed, be fraud, and then it's a completely different issue. 

I do think you should be contacting and perhaps seeking recourse against the people who published her entry (i.e., your photo) without your explicit written permission.

Nov 18, 2010 06:16 AM
Patricia Kennedy
RLAH@properties - Washington, DC
Home in the Capital

Cherimie, it's bad enough that she stole the photo.  What I find even more offensive is her no-big-deal reaction when she got caught.  I would reconsider legal recourse.  It might be only a way to send a message, and you could donate anything you got from it to your favorite no-kill shelter or rescue group. 

Nov 18, 2010 06:26 AM
Michael Setunsky
Woodbridge, VA
Your Commercial Real Estate Link to Northern VA

Chermie, as a dog lover I can feel your pain. The magazine publisher should ask for verification that it is in fact the submitters photo or it is being used with permission. You still have the original photo with the memories.

Nov 18, 2010 06:31 AM
Cherimie Crane
Cherimie Crane & Associates - Beaufort, SC

I have no intention of harming this young lady's career. I have made mistakes, we all have. She removed the photo from her social network. All I have asked from the beginning was it be removed from the network and other websites. I respect the advice to seek legal action, but again I don't think this was malicious. I have a littlesister, and I wouldn't want anyone harming her career. I have not once mentioned her name in a public forum, and will not do so.

Nov 18, 2010 06:36 AM
Louis Snitkin
Halstead Property - Manhattan, NY
"Results That Will Move You"

Active Rain is a Social Media site.  We are here to exchange real estate information and opinions, and to develop our businesses and professional networks.  Effective networking involves getting to know other professionals on a personal, as well as a business, level so that you are comfortable referring them to other people.  Active Rain is my first stop if someone asks me if I know anyone in Anywhere, USA.  This is an excerpt from the Community Guidelines section: "We built ActiveRain as a place for real estate professionals to network and create a sense of community. This is your community! It is our members that make ActiveRain such a special place."

As a member of the community, I care about the friends that I've made here; and feel it's perfectly OK to share in Cherimie's loss.  I do understand that there are folks who don't want the personal interaction. Remember: No one is forced to read anything that they feel is not relevant.

OK, I'll get off of my soap box now. Sorry for temporarily hijacking your post.

Nov 18, 2010 06:49 AM
Laura Barron
www.RealFamilyRealEstate.com - McKinney, TX
D + B Real Estate - Collin County Texas & Beyond

Thank you for sharing and I am deeply sorry for your loss!

Nov 18, 2010 07:01 AM
Anonymous
chris

 I know Cherimie, and she wouldn't harm a fly even if the fly stole from her. This student is pretty lucky that she is the way she is. Man (assuming the name is correct), if you only knew how she felt about that dog, I think your comment would have been a bit less harsh. You obviously don't know her at all, she certainly isn't 40. Any other person would have posted the student's name all over the place, just as the student posted Cherimie's photo.

Nov 18, 2010 07:15 AM
#94
Nick Tukmanian
RealWorks Residential - Colts Neck, NJ

Sorry about your loss Cherimie, I lost my best friend this Summer. It was painful. As far as unauthorized use of images, I think people assume that everything on the Internet is free, just because it's easy to access. And with tools like Photoshop, there is no limit to what one can do with an image. That being said, it's not fair taking other people's images without their written consent. It's a personal possession just like anything else you have.

Nov 18, 2010 08:03 AM
Sarah Moore
Southern Homes of the Carolinas - Charlotte, NC
We Open More Doors!

Sorry for your loss, thank you for sharing, you are right, it was a perfectly beautiful picture just the way it was.

Nov 18, 2010 08:49 AM
Leslie Ebersole
Swanepoel T3 Group - Saint Charles, IL
I help brokers build businesses they love.

Joseph, who ever you are, I hope you will reconsider your opinions and think about appropriately experssing them in public.

Yes, this is a real estate site and yes, this post belongs here. Those of us who practice real estate know that every day we will be jumping smack dab into a few people's lives. We deal in the personal and the emotional, the best highs and worst lows people ever experience. Houses are sold at time of transition -- new babies, sick parents, divorces, deaths and weddings...it's what we do.

So a real estate blog site of community members is a place to share ideas, thoughts and experiences. This post is a perfect example of the tightropes we walk when we mix commercialism and people.

All that said, do you know what moral relativism means? Do people "just starting out" get to break the law, which presumably the young lady knows about and understands?  She must have been instructed by her art school teachers in the use of other's work. I asked my teenagers if they knew about this and they said they'd been hearing about copyright protection and use of internet materials since the 5th grade.

Sorry to jump your post, Cherimie, but I had to say this.

Nov 18, 2010 10:59 AM
Akil Walker
Bennett Realty Solutions - Bowie, MD

Cherimie,

 

I am sorry for your loss and the altering of the picture. As a pet owner myself,they are big part of your family and they don't talk back! :)

 

Your post definitely brings to light the concerns of using a photo without permission. i am glad to read you were able to resolve the issue & 14 years of memory.

Nov 18, 2010 01:26 PM
Cherimie Crane
Cherimie Crane & Associates - Beaufort, SC

I really have read each and every comment, thank you all so very much. I know I have learned something from this. I believe that education is key; Lenn Harley has written so much about this, yet I never really "got it". I grew up with the internet and can see how the lines can get a bit blurry. I am trying to remind myself that this young lady saw something in my photo. After all there are 1000's out there. She must have seen something special. I doubt that she at any moment thought she was doing something wrong. Had she called me, sent an email, anything...I may have said yes, but I would have asked her not to change it. I have hundreds of photos online that I have taken of my beautiful town, my friends, and my dog; unfortunately this would be the only 1 that even the simplest change would bother me.

This town is so small, (one of the things I love most about it) that it only took moments for someone to recognize my dog. The funny thing is, my dog was recognized before my boyfriend:). Jackson was quite the social creature.

I am thankful that she took the photos down. I have no hard feelings whatsoever. This is a photo of my new friend. He has big shoes to fill, but somehow is completely up for the job!

Nov 19, 2010 12:20 AM
Devona Garrigus
Garrigus Real Estate - Redlands, CA
REALTORĀ® / Short Sale Specialist

Cherimie - That's awful. I am very sorry to hear of your loss and the theft of your picture. EVERYONE, especially an graphic art student, needs to know that pictures are property just like a wallet, or house, or copy of a song. I've re-blogged your post.

Nov 19, 2010 04:36 AM
The Elise Bickel Team
ReMax Select Realty - Pittsburgh, PA
Leasing, Property Management and Sales

Still so sorry for you loss. My puppies are more important to me then just about anything in the world. I know if that happened to me I would have been seeking blood. The only positive is that your puppy is now a celebrity. How many times can you say that your best friend was on the cover of a magazine? I wish you the best!

Nov 19, 2010 10:20 AM
Claude Labbe
RLAH / @properties - Washington, DC
Realty for Your Busy Life

Hi Cherimie,

I like the new favorite photos too.  It does seem like your resolution is one which doesn't seek to torch the world.  Perhaps Jackson was the kind of dog who also would have preferred this resolution, rather than you become hostile & vindictive.

Fully agree, my neighbors know my dog better than they know me.  They even recognize when he's with a dog walker, so of course, Jackson's photo was quickly identified.  That's the pull animals have on us, and that makes us gentle souls too.

You gotta believe the artist has also learned a lesson for life.

-Claude

Nov 19, 2010 05:29 PM
Fred Cope
Reliant Realty in Nashville, TN - Nashville, TN
Looking For Homes With A Smile

With Cherimie's permission, may I  re-echo Leslie Ebersole"s (#96) remarks to Joseph (#83).  Remove the care, compassion and personal from the REALTOR®'s being and you have mail-order marketing.  All the things that make a REALTOR® valuable to the client are captured in Cherimie's devotion to Jackson.  Were I looking for a REALTOR® in Beaufort, SC, I would welcome someone with her qualities--I would have confidence in what she said, and assurance that she would be devoted to her task.

Leslie, thank you--I know you posses qualities a client would welcome and find rewarding.  Remember this truth: "People don't care what you know until they know you care."  It is obvious that many do care.

Nov 19, 2010 05:39 PM
Louis Snitkin
Halstead Property - Manhattan, NY
"Results That Will Move You"

The new baby is beautiful! I speak from experience (I've had a total of more than a dozen dogs over the years) when I say that each one has their own personality. Don't get caught up in the comparison game, just love him for his unique nature.  I have a feeling that won't be a problem........

Nov 23, 2010 05:56 AM