Special offer

What if you won a small lottery?

By
Services for Real Estate Pros with Greene Notes, LLC

Let's say that someone at work approached you with some lottery tickets they were selling.  This person has been your friend for a couple of years and you felt obligated to buy two tickets at $5 each just to show your support.  You didn't pay much attention to what was written on the ticket beyond the "Grand Prize of $200,000!" at the top and didn't figure the odds would be in your favor in any case - this was only a courtesy purchase.

Two months later you are contacted and told that you have won the grand prize!  That's $200,000!  But, since you didn't select the box that stipulates that you would like to be paid in one lump sum, you will be receiving the money in monthly payments over the next twenty years instead.  That's $833.33/month for the next 240 months.  Sounds good! 

But, after receiving the first two years of payments you begin to wish that you had taken the lump sum instead.  There has been a great investment opportunity that you had to turn down because you didn't have the money at hand, and you were thinking about going back to college and changing careers, too - but, again not enough cash at hand.  What if someone offered you a lump sum cash payout for that monthly income?  Would you be willing to take $140,000 now for that last 18 years of monthly payments?

John Morrison
Buyer's Choice Realty - Ipswich, MA
Exclusive Buyernulls Agent, CBR - Boston Area Real Estate

So did you win the lottery? Sweet!

Aug 29, 2008 07:29 AM
Shan Greene
Greene Notes, LLC - Hartland, MI

No, no.  Just a hypothetical question I'm posing for comments.  I spend time thinking about these sorts of things and just wanted to include everyone else in my musings, while my kids are screaming and fighting in the background.

Aug 29, 2008 07:37 AM
June Piper-Brandon
Coldwell Banker Realty - Columbia, MD
Creating Generational Wealth Through Homeownership

I would take the $140,000, since you would have already received about $20,000 and you would be taking a $40,000 cut, but in terms of an annuity, that is probably fair.  So, inquiring minds want to know if you really won?

Aug 29, 2008 07:37 AM
Lori Isaacson
Credit Restoration Consultants - Plantation, FL

If you win and don't want the money, no matter how big or small, you can send it my way.lol.....

Aug 29, 2008 07:52 AM
Betina Foreman
WJK Realty - Austin, TX
Realtor, C.N.E., with WJK REALTY

I would take it all now, you could get hit by lightening or a truck tomorrow. Be here now!

;)

Aug 29, 2008 07:54 AM
Ken Tracy
Coldwell Banker Residential - Naperville, IL
Helping clients buy and sell since 2005

Hi Shan.  Thanks for musing.  I would take the cash now.

Now get a picture in there!!

Ken

Aug 29, 2008 07:57 AM
Ted Komenda
Dunhill Group - Osterville, MA

Always take the money otherwise someone else will be making the interest off of the larger amount

Aug 29, 2008 08:21 AM
John Morrison
Buyer's Choice Realty - Ipswich, MA
Exclusive Buyernulls Agent, CBR - Boston Area Real Estate

Dang Shan, I was ready to congratulate you. Now tell your kids to shut their collective yappers. And conventional wisdom says to take the lump sum no matter what. The interest the recipient could make, along with shrewd investing (or any investing most likely), will cause them to come out way ahead of the person who chooses monthly payments. Inflation, value of the dollar, etc. all work to harm the monthly payments' 'true value' over time.

Aug 29, 2008 08:30 AM
Jimmy McCall
JimmyMcCall.com - Cunningham, TN
The Ex-Mortgage Consultant

Shan,  I will almost always take the cash option.   Who is to say you will continue receiving the monthly payment?

Aug 29, 2008 09:10 AM
Shan Greene
Greene Notes, LLC - Hartland, MI

Thanks for all of the responses!  Well, if any of you win the lottery (or are receiving structured payments of any kind, including on real estate) and would like to get that lump sum instead, that's what I do and I am very glad to see that so many of you recognize the benefits.  Contact me at cs3greene@msn.com, I also have a website at www.GreeneNotesLLC.net that you can visit.

And, I will gladly assist any clients that you send my way, I work nationwide.

KEN, I will get that picture in there ASAP  ;)  Just a little more time.

Aug 29, 2008 10:46 AM
Anonymous
hopeyoudie

you suck

May 29, 2019 06:50 PM
#11