Special offer

HGTV's SELLING NEW YORK - What Were Your Thoughts?

By
Home Stager with Dezigner Digz

The first episode of HGTV's Selling New York debuted in Canada Wednesday night.  I've been watching the trailers for it over the last couple of weeks, so I was really stoked to check it out.  I can't get enough of HGTV.

The show centres around two competing New York City real estate firms.  The daily "goings-on" of their brokers are followed as they work the real estate industry.  I get the impression from the first episode anyway, that the two firms chosen couldn't be any more different from one another in how they operate.  They're like night and day.  I guess that was a conscious choice in order to bring more interest and potential conflict to the show in episodes to follow.

"Firm #1" comes across to me as the more polished, professional group.  Not only are the brokers themselves polished, but so are their properties.  They showed a condo listing that was staged to perfection.  I'd LOVE to know who worked the magic on that one.  It was simply stunning!  This firm even goes so far as to wine and dine their clients and in fact, invited one of them to attend New York Fashion Week.  Who could resist that?  Hey, whatever it takes to get them to sign on the dotted line I guess.

"Firm #2" got off to a bad start right out of the shoot as far as I was concerned.  I mean yes, "reality" TV has to have a healthy dose of drama in it if they want to boost ratings and gain more viewers, but I'm thinking that this firm is going to be made out to look a little like ruthless, bad guys.  Case in point; upon hearing that a past client of theirs was going through a divorce, the mother of the mother and 2 daughter team was happy because this would mean more business transactions for them.  If I was a Realtor®, I wouldn't have been too thrilled to hear that little exchange on T.V.  It certainly didn't do much to portray the profession in a very good light to the public.  If that's where the show is going to head, then I guess I'll be watching my old recordings of Matthew Finlason on The Stagers instead.  Now that's entertainment!  

Back to Selling New York.  Putting aside the bad start, it was time for Firm #2 to "show us what they've got" as far as listings.  They had a new condo which was listed at $5 million and explained to viewers that homes at this price range take longer to sell; so true, especially in this economy.  They did find a client that was interested in purchasing a new property.  Obviously the listing price didn't scare her off, so a showing was booked.  I couldn't wait to see this one for myself.  Hey, a brand new $5 million condo in NYC.  It's going to really BE something right?  I had pretty high expectations; especially after seeing how Firm #1's property was presented.  I've got to say I was shocked.  The condo was empty.  That's right, empty!  I couldn't believe that it hadn't been staged; especially at this price point and in a cosmopolitan, highly competitive city like NYC.  What were they thinking? 

The potential buyer's reaction was just as I expected.  She stated that it was too austere.  That was a good way of describing it.  With nothing in it, that's exactly how it felt.  It's going to be tough to move that property if it remains empty.

Needless to say, their client ended up settling on another condo which was less money.  One that was furnished and although the wallcoverings were somewhat outdated, she chose it over the other.  Her reason for choosing this one you might ask?  She said that she felt more comfortable in it.  Was there a lesson to be learned from this for the firm?  I hope so.  Staging works! 

In another segment of this episode, Firm #2 was having their photographer shoot one of their new listings.  I was amused to find Mother running around behind the photographer "staging" the room as he shot it.  Obviously they don't have a Stager.  Perhaps it's time they look for one.  Something tells me that they are going to be inundated with phone calls from area Stagers now.  At least they used a Professional for the photos, that much I'll give them.  (I'm assuming this only because they didn't take the photos themselves). 

Will I watch the show again?  Sure I will.  I'm not giving up on it that easily and I'd encourage you to check it out too.  Did any of you watch the first episode?  If so, I'd love to hear your take on it. 

-------

Dezigner Digz is Burlington, Ontario's premier home staging, styling and redesign firm servicing Ancaster, Hamilton, Burlington, Waterdown, Stoney Creek, Oakville and surrounding areas.  The owner, Charlene Storozuk, is a member of the Real Estate Staging Association and currently serves on the Executive Committee as Regional Vice-President, Canada.  Her work has been featured in the book FabJob Guide to Become a Home Stager, 2009 edition.  Charlene has written several articles on home staging, some of which have been published by the International Business Times and the Women's Council of Realtors.  She is also a Contributing Blogger for REALTOR Magazine.  For more information about us, visit our website at www.dezignerdigz.com.

Maria Tobin
Staged For Success - Huntersville, NC
ASP, IAHSP

Charlene - I watch this show too.  I'm also amazed at the prices and then what you get for those prices!  Firm #1 is definitely more polished.  I'll definitely keep watching.

Sep 10, 2010 06:16 AM
Cathy Lee
CL Design Services Home Staging - Danville, CA
ASP, IAHSP, RESA Danville, CA

I did not see the show. I do have Matthew's show recorded and watch them for inspiration and relaxation.

Sep 10, 2010 06:32 AM
Kathy Streib
Cypress, TX
Home Stager/Redesign

Charlene- okay, you got me, I'm going to try to find this show on HGTV and Tivo it.  Sounds interesting and fun at the same time.  When I'm at my computer, I ususally have HGTV on in the back ground. 

Sep 10, 2010 07:50 AM
Sally Weatherley
EXIT STAGE RIGHT - Vancouver, BC
Vancouver Home Staging, Home Stager Vancouver, B.C

Charlene - I watched portions of this show - the US Open tennis was on at the same time, so I was surfing back and forth between the two.  I did catch the photo shoot of the apartment for sale, and the Mother Realtor® running around and moving cushions for the shoot.  I was absolutely shocked that such a high end property wasn't properly staged.  The first thing I would have done was remove all those busy rugs on the floor.  Yes, I'll probably watch this show again, too.  There's something fascinating about watching a train wreck about to happen...

Sep 10, 2010 08:38 AM
Ginger Foust
Certified Staging Professional - Oakhurst, CA
Home Stager Oakhurst CA, Dream Interior Redesign & Staging

Charlene that show has been on in the US for quite some time and it's OK, IMO.  I like seeing how the NY market is so vastly different from many markets and it's interesting to see how far these companies go to market their listings. 

Sep 10, 2010 08:56 AM
Marte Cliff
Marte Cliff Copywriting - Priest River, ID
Your real estate writer

I don't see much TV, so haven't seen this. But I assume the producers are showing the "good and bad" in real estate.

After all, any good story has to have some "conflict" to keep people interested.

Sep 10, 2010 09:12 AM
Julia Maher
Nestings: Connecticut Home Staging and Model Homes - Fairfield, CT
Connecticut Home Stager

Charlene:  Love your TV show downloads!  I've seen most of this show's episodes.  In retrospect, I found them boring.  After the first $5 million property, the thrill was gone...(sigh).  Clients and agents alike seemed unrealistic and NONE had a compelling story to tell.  If I see one more Birkin bag, I'll hurl vom, I swear.  Julie

Sep 11, 2010 04:42 AM
Maureen Bray Portland OR Home Stager ~ Room Solutions Staging
Room Solutions Staging, Portland OR - Portland, OR
"Staging Consultations that Sell Portland Homes"

Charlene -- I watched all of the Selling New York episodes this year, since I TIVO'd them and could watch when I had time.  I agree that one firm comes across as more professional ... but that's because the other firm is definitely a family firm, with the parents and two daughters involved.  One thing I know for sure is that I'd hate working in NYC staging anything ... WAY too much hassle with parking, elevators, loading and unloading, etc.  However they have some fab buildings which you'll see in future episodes.

Sep 11, 2010 10:54 AM
Diana Young
Staging Seattle, King & Snohomish Counties - Edmonds, WA

I agree with Maureen - I'd be a nervous wreck if I had to stage in NYC!  Way too much pressure and too much hassel with parking, elevators and the like. 

Sep 12, 2010 01:21 PM
Charlene Storozuk
Dezigner Digz - Burlington, ON
Home Stager - Burlington Ontario

Maria - The prices are amazing, aren't they?

Cathy - I certainly know what you mean about getting inspiration from watching Matthew.  Relaxation from watching him?  Not so much.  The man is a fireball of energy. :-)  LOL!

Kathy - Check it out.

Sally - I know what you mean :-)

Ginger - I'm glad you're enjoying the show.  Yes, it looks like they go to great lengths - it's funny though that staging isn't one of them, since it's so mainstream now.  I'll be watching the show again.

Marte - You're so right.  There has to be some conflict in order to keep an audience.

Julia - Thank you!  I'll have to keep an eye out for those Birkin bags :-)

Maureen - That's for sure, I wouldn't want to be a Stager in NYC either.  I had one experience in my city with a condo that was at the busiest intersection in the area.  The setup for unloading/loading was terrible and you were only given 15 minutes before you risked getting a ticket.  I've promised myself that I'll never do another job in that one particular building.  I imagine that they're all like that in NYC.

Diana - You're right.  It would be way too stressful.  It would take all the fun out of it.  (Not that every moment of staging is fun) :-)

Sep 13, 2010 05:29 AM
Anonymous
LaVerne

Simply put, Selling New York is one of the most boring shows on HGTV. I can't complete a program, so I don't even try any more. How HGTV comes up with some of it's programming is beyond me. This show is geared to the filthy RICH audience, being from the Midwest, I think a more down-to-earth is much m9ore entertaining. Also, what's with taking John Gidding's Curb Appeal: The Block on Saturday nights off for Cash for Cari ? John Gidding's show was a well done and gave some people a lovely hone and landscaping and very enjoyable. What is enjoyable about Cash and Cari ? Nothing that I've been able to see. The Saturday night line-up used to be my favorite night of the week....I like House Hunters, but I'm also growing very weary of House Hunters International. Too many !! Go back with what you had.......someone said , if it's not broke, don't fix it. I think this is very good advice for HGTV to follow. The thing is, I may seem to be bashing HGTV, but I'd say that between TLC and HGTV is about 99% of what I watch on TV period. I do watch Survivor on another network when it's on, but MY channels are as stated above. It's a channel that one can watch and be taken away from the usual media coverage. I certainly hope that this channel would adjust its' programming to what it used to be.

LaVerne

Feb 13, 2011 09:19 AM
#11